Yea, everything was working fine for me too, but about 12 games into my Franchise, I finally got the no Replays glitch, and when I went to view things in the vault, all replays only had one player hitting and no one on the field. The ball would get hit and then jiggle around to wherever it was hit.
The only thing different I did last night was I kept pressing X at the end of the game to skip through stuff since I was tired. I normally just listen to the whole thing and let it run on its own.
I decided not to save that franchise game because of it, plus it was my excuse for not saving a game where I got pounded 8-1, lol.
I'm going to play today, and hopefully the replays will be back to normal.