The difference here is that you just don't care for the Harry Potter film, thats mostly not the case with this. Id imagine a large number of the ppl who harp on EA or the game, at one point really enjoyed this game. I am the same way. I used to line up at midnight every year to purchase this game and would play it constantly through the year, since the move to next gen, I'm lucky if i don't get bored of the game in a week. Thats not my fault, thats EA's fault for not delivering a title worth playing. Up until a few months ago, anything EA related out of my mouth wasn't positive. Once i started seeing the progress they were making with Madden 2010, those negative sentiments began to turn positive. Its now gotten to the point where i plan on placing a pre-order on Madden, something i haven't done since Madden 2005. That, however, doesn't seem to be the case with NCAA 2010, it doesn't look to be making the strides that Madden is and thats frustrating for fans like me, who once, really enjoyed the game. I think thats were most of the negativity comes from, altho, there are some ppl, like one individual a page or two back who seem to be harping just to harp.