With no variable speed, its bound to look very similar to the robotic Madden 09. When Ian can fix the most basic problem, then I can give him his props. But to me, theres a BUNCH of small changes. They sound big, but when the players only move at one speed, nothing will come together very well. Leaves all the possible variable combinations of situations out the game.
And the throwing motions look pretty good, the footwork in the pocket doesnt. In the NFL, when a QB steps up, he dips his shoulder almost every time. In Madden, they stutter glide in an upright position.