Where will the most realistic gameplay be found? All Pro or All Madden?

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • lint
    Pro
    • Jul 2006
    • 692

    #1

    Where will the most realistic gameplay be found? All Pro or All Madden?

    rookie and pro are right out.

    I am curious as to what will be the true gameplay.

    From the guys at community day it seems that all pro was challenging, so that leaves me to believe all madden will be done even better.

    If going from pro to all pro made the game more realistic will all madden make it that much more or will it be like other years where on all madden you were playing against superstars at every position.

    I am hoping this year all madden is the most realistic than where in most years all pro is the most realistic and all madden is everyone on steroids.
    I doubted you Roy Williams since you only won with a someone else's team... Now you have proven me wrong.

    You have earned my respect.

    4-6-09
  • berad88
    MVP
    • Aug 2008
    • 1211

    #2
    Re: Where will the most realistic gameplay be found? All Pro or All Madden?

    I know that on old gen they used to say that All Madden was more for an extra challenge than realism but things may of changed since then. I always play on all pro.

    Comment

    • DavonBrown
      MVP
      • Oct 2008
      • 1484

      #3
      Re: Where will the most realistic gameplay be found? All Pro or All Madden?

      All Pro because they play realistically to the best of their abilities. On All Madden they cheat you in order to win.

      Comment

      • thmst30
        MVP
        • Mar 2005
        • 4153

        #4
        Re: Where will the most realistic gameplay be found? All Pro or All Madden?

        All-Pro is where everything is tuned for realism. All-Madden trys to make the game more challenging by giving the CPU unrealistic boosts and cheats. I'd use All-Pro and adjust sliders if you find it's not hard enough. I try to stay away from the All-Madden BS.

        Comment

        • lint
          Pro
          • Jul 2006
          • 692

          #5
          Re: Where will the most realistic gameplay be found? All Pro or All Madden?

          Originally posted by thmst30
          All-Pro is where everything is tuned for realism. All-Madden trys to make the game more challenging by giving the CPU unrealistic boosts and cheats. I'd use All-Pro and adjust sliders if you find it's not hard enough. I try to stay away from the All-Madden BS.
          I would agree in past years, but this year it seems it is all about realism. So maybe this year all madden will be the most realistic. It could henge on too realistic ie you have 3-4 seconds to pass or you are toast.

          I am playing in whatever mode Nnamdi is not passable on. (though I will be playing with the Falcons.)
          I doubted you Roy Williams since you only won with a someone else's team... Now you have proven me wrong.

          You have earned my respect.

          4-6-09

          Comment

          • thmst30
            MVP
            • Mar 2005
            • 4153

            #6
            Re: Where will the most realistic gameplay be found? All Pro or All Madden?

            Originally posted by lint
            I would agree in past years, but this year it seems it is all about realism. So maybe this year all madden will be the most realistic. It could henge on too realistic ie you have 3-4 seconds to pass or you are toast.

            I am playing in whatever mode Nnamdi is not passable on. (though I will be playing with the Falcons.)
            Maybe. I still think All-Madden will have it's quirks to make sure it's more of a challenge. I know for a fact that All-Pro is where they try to tune for absolute realism so I think I'll stay with that.

            Comment

            • Vikes1
              Proctor, MN. Go Rails!
              • May 2008
              • 4102

              #7
              Re: Where will the most realistic gameplay be found? All Pro or All Madden?

              For me...this has been a problem with the game...well, forever.

              It's play on All-Pro= win every game...or All-Madden and feel as though the ratings mean nothing. And it seems I can never really find sliders I'm happy with. Mainly because they lack being effective.

              One of my big hopes for M10 is to be able to play on All-Pro. And have it be a fair, yet challenging experience.
              1969 NFL Champions

              Comment

              • lolfalconsbeatu
                Pro
                • Apr 2009
                • 886

                #8
                Re: Where will the most realistic gameplay be found? All Pro or All Madden?

                Im an online guy, and ever since I began playing madden online, All-Pro has been the mode, that tells me right there, EA expects the most realism out of All-Pro than any other difficulty level. So if you are a online player, or not, I would see what the online Ranked Match difficulty is automatically set at, because I think thats a good way to see what the Max realism sim game you can get out of Madden.

                If Ranked Matches online is All-Madden this year (which I doubt because most of yall even realize the CPU get a clear unfair advantage), than I think thats how you can get the Max Real Sim Style Game Experience.

                Comment

                • CKW11
                  MVP
                  • Mar 2009
                  • 1540

                  #9
                  Re: Where will the most realistic gameplay be found? All Pro or All Madden?

                  I felt that doing the My Skill thing gave me realistic gameplay...just my 2 cents.

                  Comment

                  • J-Roc
                    Rookie
                    • Jun 2009
                    • 21

                    #10
                    Re: Where will the most realistic gameplay be found? All Pro or All Madden?

                    All-Madden the only way to go

                    Comment

                    • kcarr
                      MVP
                      • Sep 2008
                      • 2787

                      #11
                      Re: Where will the most realistic gameplay be found? All Pro or All Madden?

                      Player vs CPU all pro usually gives the most realistic, players play to their abilities, game although it isn't usually much of a challenge due to terrible AI. Player vs Player I have always had better games playing on all madden.

                      Comment

                      • J Masta J
                        Pro
                        • May 2009
                        • 597

                        #12
                        Re: Where will the most realistic gameplay be found? All Pro or All Madden?

                        All-Pro with a healthy bump in CPU sliders makes for a realistic, challenging game.
                        Visit JonBob's Packer Blog,your home for insightful analysis and opinion on everything Green and Gold.

                        Comment

                        • stopper654
                          Pro
                          • Nov 2008
                          • 537

                          #13
                          Re: Where will the most realistic gameplay be found? All Pro or All Madden?

                          Originally posted by CKW11
                          I felt that doing the My Skill thing gave me realistic gameplay...just my 2 cents.
                          ^^^THIS
                          The EAGLES Are The Most Dominate Team In The NFC Beast And The Best Team In The League, I Will BLEED GREEN For The Rest Of My Life, So To Any Team Who Thinks They Can Test Us Then If You Want Some Then Come Get Some. GO EAGLES!!!!!!!!!!!
                          • PSN: Stopper654

                          Comment

                          • PlatooN
                            GO PACK GO
                            • Apr 2009
                            • 713

                            #14
                            Re: Where will the most realistic gameplay be found? All Pro or All Madden?

                            modded sliders
                            __________________________________________
                            you're not feeling me?
                            Fine; it cost you nothing - pay me no mind
                            __________________________________________

                            Comment

                            • maddenps2
                              MVP
                              • Jul 2004
                              • 1865

                              #15
                              Re: Where will the most realistic gameplay be found? All Pro or All Madden?

                              Whats the point of this question until you've actually played the game extensively? Random guesses and speculation....

                              Comment

                              Working...