Re: NCAA Football 10 Video: Virginia Tech vs. Alabama - Part 5 (Chase @ E3)
Is that a serious question?
The plays are repetitive and basic. Most of the playbooks are exactly the same witht he same formations and same plays, just in differenct formations.
There are also zero reverses, fade routes around the goal line. There is very little identity to any team except the flexbone teams and Florida.
There should also be one play that is a base play, that can have numerous plays to run off that base play.
Example:
Split right, flanker left...153 (off tackle right)
Off of that one play:
Split right, flanker left...253 (counter play)
Split right, flanker left...256 scissor (reverse off the PA to the TB)
Split right, flanker left...856 scissor pass--(PA off the reverse)
Split right, flanker left...853 934---(PA pass off the off tackle play.
That is one play with 4 other plays to run off that one play. Every school has unique formations and unique plays they run. I'd say 1% of the playbooks attempt to address this.
It's a joke, especially to fans of this game that have actually played football. Either make the playbooks more dynamic or put a play editor into the game so we can make up our own plays.
Another example is with the running game. It's far too basic. There should be a system that has running plays assigned to every hole using a number system.
Is that a serious question?
The plays are repetitive and basic. Most of the playbooks are exactly the same witht he same formations and same plays, just in differenct formations.
There are also zero reverses, fade routes around the goal line. There is very little identity to any team except the flexbone teams and Florida.
There should also be one play that is a base play, that can have numerous plays to run off that base play.
Example:
Split right, flanker left...153 (off tackle right)
Off of that one play:
Split right, flanker left...253 (counter play)
Split right, flanker left...256 scissor (reverse off the PA to the TB)
Split right, flanker left...856 scissor pass--(PA off the reverse)
Split right, flanker left...853 934---(PA pass off the off tackle play.
That is one play with 4 other plays to run off that one play. Every school has unique formations and unique plays they run. I'd say 1% of the playbooks attempt to address this.
It's a joke, especially to fans of this game that have actually played football. Either make the playbooks more dynamic or put a play editor into the game so we can make up our own plays.
Another example is with the running game. It's far too basic. There should be a system that has running plays assigned to every hole using a number system.
Comment