NCAA Football 10 Video: Miami @ Florida St.

[mmorg]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Video: Miami @ Florida St.

Only 2 things I didn't like were no player momentum at all and QB's were still throwing like Johnny On The Spot. Hopefully QB accuracy was tweaked so make them less accurate.

This video has me actually excited for NCAA football again. But I still hope next year EA shakes up their plan for the game.

[rudyjuly2]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Video: Miami @ Florida St.

I liked the video. The player lock angles were cool to see even if I couldn't tell what was going on. It seemed every time Steve used player lock the play went away from him.

The more videos I see the better.

[rudyjuly2]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Video: Miami @ Florida St.

I will say this. I do think the Madden videos are nice but I think people are being overly critical of the NCAA ones and overly nice on the Madden ones. I personally think the Madden gameplay speed is way too slow and prefer the NCAA speed. Not a huge deal since Madden has a speed slider but even guys like Chris Johnson feel like they are running in mud.

Glad we are seeing betas now and I'm starting to get excited again.

[Ed O'Neil]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Video: Miami @ Florida St.

I can never get these videos to load ..

All I get is a white rectangle saying this ..

'Miami (AI) moves the ball to get the first points of the game. FSU starts off on the right foot. <!-- Start ad campaign info --> <script language="javascript" src="http://publishers.springboard.gorillanation.com/js/get_superconfig_data.php?player_id=ospt001" type="text/javascript"></script> <!-- End ad campaign info --><!-- Start 5x5 pre-roll request --> <script language="JavaScript" type="text/javascript"> if (typeof(companion_gnm_ord)=='undefined') companion_gnm_ord=Math.random()*10000000000000000; if (typeof(companion_gnm_tile) == 'undefined') companion_gnm_tile=1; document.write('<scr'+'ipt language="JavaScript" src="' + adServerUrl['player'] + adCampainDomain + '/' + mediaType + ';sect=' + sectType + ';sz=5x5;type=' + adType + ';tile='+(companion_gnm_tile++)+';ord=' + companion_gnm_ord + '?" type="text/javascript"></scr' + 'ipt>') </script> <!-- End 5x5 pre-roll request --> <script language="javascript" src="http://cdn.springboard.gorillanation.com/storage/js/swfobject.js" type="text/javascript"></script> '


Any help?

[sportzbro]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Video: Miami @ Florida St.

I will say this. I do think the Madden videos are nice but I think people are being overly critical of the NCAA ones and overly nice on the Madden ones. I personally think the Madden gameplay speed is way too slow and prefer the NCAA speed. Not a huge deal since Madden has a speed slider but even guys like Chris Johnson feel like they are running in mud.

Glad we are seeing betas now and I'm starting to get excited again.

I believe running animation contributes a large amount to how the speed of the game feels... I'd be more comfortable with the speed of NCAA if the players actually somewhat resembled a human running motion. Madden has tweaked the animations, and the slower play is more tolerable.. still not great though.

[Speedy]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Video: Miami @ Florida St.

I believe running animation contributes a large amount to how the speed of the game feels... I'd be more comfortable with the speed of NCAA if the players actually somewhat resembled a human running motion. Madden has tweaked the animations, and the slower play is more tolerable.. still not great though.

The look of the game itself is an improvement with the stadium, fans, and the field (I also like the camera view) but agreed w/the running animation - it looks too robotic. I still don't like the fact that players can run full speed in one direction then "turn" another way and run full speed without any slowing down...there's no transition or turning shoulders, hips, extra steps, etc.

[Young J 334]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Video: Miami @ Florida St.

The angle at which the camera follows the ball and the gameplay is quite nice overall . My only pet peeve at this point is the sideline interaction. It is booooring! No emotion. Just happiness and jubilation even if your team is losing. FAIL
<input id="*******" type="hidden"><!--Session data--><input onclick="jsCall();" id="jsProxy" type="hidden"><input id="*******" type="hidden"><!--Session data--><input onclick="jsCall();" id="jsProxy" type="hidden">

[moylan1234]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Video: Miami @ Florida St.

I will say this. I do think the Madden videos are nice but I think people are being overly critical of the NCAA ones and overly nice on the Madden ones. I personally think the Madden gameplay speed is way too slow and prefer the NCAA speed. Not a huge deal since Madden has a speed slider but even guys like Chris Johnson feel like they are running in mud.

Glad we are seeing betas now and I'm starting to get excited again.

Ian said he had the game speed set to slow on that vid. however i really don't get the criticism NCAA is getting. that madden vid was just awful, to me it's Madden 09 with more cutscenes. they didn't even get off target shotgun snaps.

[Shade Shadows]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Video: Miami @ Florida St.

The OPed drag route is still going strong i see.

[stoncold32]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Video: Miami @ Florida St.

wow that Defense chant sounded terrible.

[Solidice]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Video: Miami @ Florida St.

wow that Defense chant sounded terrible.

I'm fairly certain it was from a custom stadium sound

[Rocky]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Video: Miami @ Florida St.

I know I going to get bashed for saying this, but it's never stopped me before so:

The presentation in NCAA is better than the presentation in Madden.

Yes I said it. For two reasons.

1) and very obviously the commentary. There is more banter back and forth between the commentators creating a flow within the game. Madden's commentary is so atrocious that it distracts from the game.

2) NCAA is less schizo. I like the cutscenes in Madden, I think he actual scene is well done. I just think the timing and transitions are so jerky and random. Again, NCAA has a flow to it that makes it easier to get into.

[sportzbro]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Video: Miami @ Florida St.

I know I going to get bashed for saying this, but it's never stopped me before so:

The presentation in NCAA is better than the presentation in Madden.

Yes I said it. For two reasons.

1) and very obviously the commentary. There is more banter back and forth between the commentators creating a flow within the game. Madden's commentary is so atrocious that it distracts from the game.

2) NCAA is less schizo. I like the cutscenes in Madden, I think he actual scene is well done. I just think the timing and transitions are so jerky and random. Again, NCAA has a flow to it that makes it easier to get into.

I agree with about #1 hands down. That has been something that has been consistently better than Madden.

With #2 though, you can't tell me you wouldn't want pregame warmups, player breakdown, halftime show, post game interviews, players running into the tunnel, 3D fans, or real coaches on the sidelines..

Madden dominates #2 this year.

[moylan1234]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Video: Miami @ Florida St.

I agree with about #1 hands down. That has been something that has been consistently better than Madden.

With #2 though, you can't tell me you wouldn't want pregame warmups, player breakdown, halftime show, post game interviews, players running into the tunnel, 3D fans, or real coaches on the sidelines..

Madden dominates #2 this year.

woa woa woa...did you watch that madden vid? I totally agree with #2 statement I definitely do want that stuff, but from what I saw today you're insulting halftime shows by referring to that as a halftime show. pregame warmups, stat banners, and cutscenes were all really good, but i didn't see any of that other stuff you listed.

[sportzbro]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Video: Miami @ Florida St.

woa woa woa...did you watch that madden vid? I totally agree with #2 statement I definitely do want that stuff, but from what I saw today you're insulting halftime shows by referring to that as a halftime show. pregame warmups, stat banners, and cutscenes were all really good, but i didn't see any of that other stuff you listed.

No, I didn't watch that 10 minute vid. I agree that the halftime show isn't that great, and I posted that when everyone first saw it... but hey, at least its something. It is more than you can say about the halftime in NCAA (nothing). I was just referring to what I have seen from the oodles of 30 sec -1 minute vids from E3. Everything I listed is in Madden, and not NCAA.