Madden NFL 10 Videos: Ravens (CPU) vs. Titans (Ian) Full Gameplay in HD

[adembroski]

Re: Madden NFL 10 Videos: Ravens (CPU) vs. Titans (Ian) Full Gameplay in HD

*At 2:29 of 3rd Vid, the "QB comparison is missing the attempt stat. "Comp" should say "Comp/Att" and the stat should be "6/8", "8/12" etc... it's improper to show just a completion stat without the attempt stat.

Oddly enough, in the 5th vid, near the end, you actually have it correct in the "Star of the Game" shot, showing the completions and attempts.

*There were very few auto-replays when compared to the number of plays worthy of having an auto-replay.

*Commentary lines are terribly written. New writers with know-how are needed. There are just too many bad lines to list them all. To hear Alex saying these bad lines, too... It's tragic... just tragic.

In all honesty, the commentary sounds the same as last year.

*Not enough guys in sleeves... Coaches not in Jackets. Refs not in jackets... Fans not in jackets... it's January and obviously cold...

*I've noticed this in several vids but in the 4th vid at 2:05, they measure a run that was clearly way ahead of the first down marker.

It seems to almost always happen at the exact same point, too. Measurements shouldn't happen on obvious successful first down attempts like this one. I saw this a lot at CD.

*The refs coming out to confer about whether a guy crossed the goaline simply happens way too much, to the point of actually making the scene an eye-roller. This scene should only happen every once in a while. Like once per game, IF that.

Also, there should be a replay showing us whether the player got in or not... but only sometimes.

*The exact same cutscene of the Ravens coach on the sideline played constantly. The exact same scene. Something is wrong with that. I know there are more cutscenes than that, they should be playing.

I wanna reiterate this... too many measurements, too many conferences, and not NEARLY enough auto-replays.

Next year there needs to be a lot of Collinsworth replay audio recorded as well.

[Palo20]

Re: Madden NFL 10 Videos: Ravens (CPU) vs. Titans (Ian) Full Gameplay in HD

yeah this bothered me too.If you go back to the playoff game in Jan. u'll see K.Collins in long sleeves and alot of the Titans wore long sleeves or half sleeves when its cold.

I liked that some guys wore short sleeves. On NCAA last year, during cold games they would automatically put everyone in long sleeves--not very realistic.

I just hope we have options for warm and cold weaher equipment for each player. Some guys wear sleeves when it's cold and some still don't.

[2krules]

Re: Ravens (CPU) vs. Titans (Ian) full gameplay in HD

Ian can we PLEASE get more AUTOMATIC replays after Touchdowns and big yardage plays. What NFL broadcast do you watch on Sundays fail to show Touchdowns instant replay.

I agree 100%!

[Dawkins#20]

Re: Madden NFL 10 Videos: Ravens (CPU) vs. Titans (Ian) Full Gameplay in HD

The auto replays really need to be added, it's the one thing that makes it seem a little dead and letting the atmosphere down. Need to replay the play and maybe use backtrack or something and identify where the blown coverage/assignment happened on big plays.

I think on big plays you should have replay and maybe backtrack, on short yardage TD's just haev a quick auto replay

[Guffers]

Re: Madden NFL 10 Videos: Ravens (CPU) vs. Titans (Ian) Full Gameplay in HD

Isn't there going to be an auto replay slider in this game? Maybe it was set down low in this vid?

[rudyjuly2]

Re: Madden NFL 10 Videos: Ravens (CPU) vs. Titans (Ian) Full Gameplay in HD

I've watched a couple videos and I think Madden looks good. I like the presentation and player momentum. I think the game speed seemed way too slow but someone said this was on slow? Chris Johnson looked slow and he should look fast but the speed slider should take care of that.

My one beef that jumped out at me while Ian was playing on offense was that the Baltimore defense didn't seem to make adjustments pre-snap to the formation that came out. Ian loved to use the Strong I formation and yet it seemed too many LBs or safeties were still playing against Tennessee as though it were a balanced attack. They weren't sliding over to the unbalanced side of the field enough imo. Sorry if this has already been mentioned but this thread is almost 500 posts!

[Dawkins#20]

Re: Madden NFL 10 Videos: Ravens (CPU) vs. Titans (Ian) Full Gameplay in HD

Also no line push on the QB sneak at 7.44 on the first video looks like a new way to do what people did last year...

[carnalnirvana]

Re: Madden NFL 10 Videos: Ravens (CPU) vs. Titans (Ian) Full Gameplay in HD

Qb play needs adjusting, cpu QB had all day and still dumped it off to the backs

[2krules]

Re: Madden NFL 10 Videos: Ravens (CPU) vs. Titans (Ian) Full Gameplay in HD

I'm gonna say it again, I love EVERYTHING about this game except that there are no instant replays!!!! in 2k5, everytime there was a 10+ yards completion or run there was an instant replay.

Actually, they were even more frequent than that in 2K5.

Ian, are you skipping past the replays when you make these videos? If so, please don't do that. We want to see a complete view of what Madden 10 has to offer.

[capa]

Re: Madden NFL 10 Videos: Ravens (CPU) vs. Titans (Ian) Full Gameplay in HD

Too many pages to read through, but from a presentation point of view, if you can see the player's breathing vapor on a frigid day, the coaches, fans, trainers, etc should not be in short sleeves. A nit I know, but it does affect the ability to immerse yourself into the experience.

[Sardine117]

Re: Madden NFL 10 Videos: Ravens (CPU) vs. Titans (Ian) Full Gameplay in HD

Just finished watching all the videos, that's a lot of stuff! Thank you very much Ian. Really appreciate it.

[will12203]

Re: Ravens (CPU) vs. Titans (Ian) full gameplay in HD

You have to keep in mind that even the most vehement complainers are still guys who will buy the game and get hundreds of hours of fun out of it. I know like 99% of everyone here really, really appreciates the approach you've taken to this game and all the hard work you put in. And the game looks like potentially the best one since 03 (my personal favorite) and maybe even the best ever. Just keep your head up and take the constructive criticism from the smart guys here to help make the game even better in the short time left before development finishes.

The bottom line is, when this game comes out and all the positive feedback and great reviews roll in, all the hard work and listening to us complain (some valid, some silly) will have been worth it.

Great job and thanks again for the videos.

Ian he is right the worse complainers will still buy the game and complain about this game and every other game they buy nothing will change that but as a whole the community loves what you have done with this game

[jr86]

Re: Madden NFL 10 Videos: Ravens (CPU) vs. Titans (Ian) Full Gameplay in HD

Actually, they were even more frequent than that in 2K5.

Ian, are you skipping past the replays when you make these videos? If so, please don't do that. We want to see a complete view of what Madden 10 has to offer.

Agree 100%, please tell us you are skipping the replays and not that they are not there, totally detracts from making a big play when there is no replay

[HealyMonster]

Re: Madden NFL 10 Videos: Ravens (CPU) vs. Titans (Ian) Full Gameplay in HD

Also, I have a serious question. Pastapadre said the "interviewed" the player of the game after the game yet Ian rides out the replays all the way back to the menu, and Hammond and collinsworth say goodbye right at the beginning of the replays so cutting down to the field would not make any sense as they would just pop up.

Needless to say it doesnt look like that is in the game, therefore, what does everyone make of this?

[Deegeezy]

Re: Madden NFL 10 Videos: Ravens (CPU) vs. Titans (Ian) Full Gameplay in HD

Quick note: As time expires in the game, there's a cut scene of Flacco talking on the phone. It probably shouldn't be playing at that moment. It's a little late for offensive adjustments.

Good catch...Yeah the phone scene should stop triggerring in the final minutes.

Something else that was a small issue was I saw the same John Harbaugh cut scene twice within a handful of plays.