NCAA Football 10 Rosters Issue

[Security Device]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Rosters Issue

Yep. Everyone's a star in the offseason. That's why FSU and other BCS teams are severely overrated each and every year.

I mentioned 1 guy. WTF?!?!?!?

[mhossa]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Rosters Issue

Yep. Everyone's a star in the offseason. That's why FSU and other BCS teams are severely overrated each and every year.

Agreed....thats great he made gains in the off season....what has he proven come game time? Oh wait EA doesn't care anyway aslong as FSU OSU USC and Florida are sick.

[yanks26ngoin]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Rosters Issue

My favorite rating mess up is Michigan's Mike Martin (DT) is a redshirt freshman who barely played last year...and he's 91 overall on the rosters. Hahahaha.

I'm a huge Michigan fan, but that's ridiculous.

Freshman (2008) ... earned first varsity letter ... Sporting News All-Freshman second team ... Phil Steele's All-Freshman third team ... played in all 12 games at defensive tackle ... led all freshmen with 20 tackles ... also contributed 4.5 tackles for loss and two sacks ... made career debut vs. Utah (Aug. 30), playing defensive tackle and special teams ... assisted on a tackle for loss against the Utes ... earned first career sack and posted two tackles vs. Miami (Sept. 6) ... assisted on a tackle at Notre Dame (Sept. 13) ... posted two tackles and one TFL vs. Wisconsin (Sept. 27) ... registered two tackles and one TFL vs. Illinois (Oct. 4) ... earned one solo stop vs. Toledo (Oct. 11) ... assisted on two tackles at Penn State (Oct. 18) ... tallied one sack and three solo stops vs. Michigan State (Oct. 25) ... played defensive tackle at Purdue (Nov. 1) and Minnesota (Nov. 8) ... assisted on three tackles vs. Northwestern (Nov. 15) ... equaled career high with three tackles at Ohio State (Nov. 22).

That was from mgoblue.com.

Yeah he barely played alright

Mike Martin is a redshirt freshman?

Your a huge Michigan fan?

Haha, nice try though.

[Security Device]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Rosters Issue

That was from mgoblue.com.

Yeah he barely played alright

Mike Martin is a redshirt freshman?

Your a huge Michigan fan?

Haha, nice try though.

Thank you. I didn't have time to go get that info. I'm working on Sunday

[KleShreen]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Rosters Issue

That was from mgoblue.com.

Yeah he barely played alright

Mike Martin is a redshirt freshman?

Your a huge Michigan fan?

Haha, nice try though.

If you look at his stats, yes he barely played. The fact of the matter is he had 20 total tackles and 2 sacks...and he's a 91 overall. That's wrong.

And sorry, I meant he was a RS Freshman last year.

Either way, he did nothing to warrant a 91 overall rating. 20 tackles and 2 sacks is not a 91 overall rating.

[yanks26ngoin]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Rosters Issue

If you look at his stats, yes he barely played. The fact of the matter is he had 20 total tackles and 2 sacks...and he's a 91 overall. That's wrong.

And sorry, I meant he was a RS Freshman last year.

Either way, he did nothing to warrant a 91 overall rating. 20 tackles and 2 sacks is not a 91 overall rating.

LOL. He was?

http://michigan.scout.com/a.z?s=162&p=9&c=8&yr=2008

Look at that list. Those were all freshman last season.

12 games isnt barely playing. 20 tackles and 2 sacks isnt a 91 rating, your right. But it isnt barely playing. If you watched the games, he played alot. He couldnt rack up any stats because the defense couldnt penetrate the o'line, and when they did, Brandon Graham got most of the sacks.

Mike Martin is also a beast and really bulked up this off season, and was getting raves all spring practice. Now we know they rarely mean anything, and a perfect example of this is Stevie Brown. If you wanna talk about a terrible rating job by EA, this is it. LOL! The guy is the worst excuse for a safety ever. He lost his starting job and is going to be a hybrid S/LB this season.

[caseym12]

why cant EA just buy a copy of Lindys or Phil Steeles college football preview and just copy and paste the rosters from there...as far as the ratings go...just read what is said about the players on each team...for example...if it says should be the best in conference at this position...they should be rated accordingly in the 90s ...why would that not work...? or i mean just give 120 people that love the game one team apiece to research and come up with the correct rosters..i mean with unlimited control over auburn in teambuilder i could have a 100% accurate roster in less than 6 hours.

[MBFranchise]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Rosters Issue

LOL. He was?

http://michigan.scout.com/a.z?s=162&p=9&c=8&yr=2008

Look at that list. Those were all freshman last season.

12 games isnt barely playing. 20 tackles and 2 sacks isnt a 91 rating, your right. But it isnt barely playing. If you watched the games, he played alot. He couldnt rack up any stats because the defense couldnt penetrate the o'line, and when they did, Brandon Graham got most of the sacks.

Mike Martin is also a beast and really bulked up this off season, and was getting raves all spring practice. Now we know they rarely mean anything, and a perfect example of this is Stevie Brown. If you wanna talk about a terrible rating job by EA, this is it. LOL! The guy is the worst excuse for a safety ever. He lost his starting job and is going to be a hybrid S/LB this season.

Gotta throw in my .02. The argument Mike Martin barely played last season is questionable at best. How many freshmen DTs do you see putting up huge numbers? Obviously not many since someone who "barely played" was named to multiple all-american teams.

Now does he deserve a 91? Hard to say, but at this point I would say no. By the end of the year it might be a different story, but for now it does sound too high.

And yes, I agree Stevie Brown should be listed as a LB.

Go Blue!

[stevedrumsdw]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Rosters Issue

why cant EA just buy a copy of Lindys or Phil Steeles college football preview and just copy and paste the rosters from there...as far as the ratings go...just read what is said about the players on each team...for example...if it says should be the best in conference at this position...they should be rated accordingly in the 90s ...why would that not work...? or i mean just give 120 people that love the game one team apiece to research and come up with the correct rosters..i mean with unlimited control over auburn in teambuilder i could have a 100% accurate roster in less than 6 hours.

That would take time away from season showdown and wouldn't work with EA's new policy for NCAA " If its a gimmick its in the game."

[FSU93]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Rosters Issue

why cant EA just buy a copy of Lindys or Phil Steeles college football preview and just copy and paste the rosters from there...as far as the ratings go...just read what is said about the players on each team...for example...if it says should be the best in conference at this position...they should be rated accordingly in the 90s ...why would that not work...? or i mean just give 120 people that love the game one team apiece to research and come up with the correct rosters..i mean with unlimited control over auburn in teambuilder i could have a 100% accurate roster in less than 6 hours.

Probably cause it doesn't come out in time?

[19]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Rosters Issue

That would take time away from season showdown and wouldn't work with EA's new policy for NCAA " If its a gimmick its in the game."

Extremely well said. I'm with you.

[KleShreen]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Rosters Issue

LOL. He was?

http://michigan.scout.com/a.z?s=162&p=9&c=8&yr=2008

Look at that list. Those were all freshman last season.

12 games isnt barely playing. 20 tackles and 2 sacks isnt a 91 rating, your right. But it isnt barely playing. If you watched the games, he played alot. He couldnt rack up any stats because the defense couldnt penetrate the o'line, and when they did, Brandon Graham got most of the sacks.

Mike Martin is also a beast and really bulked up this off season, and was getting raves all spring practice. Now we know they rarely mean anything, and a perfect example of this is Stevie Brown. If you wanna talk about a terrible rating job by EA, this is it. LOL! The guy is the worst excuse for a safety ever. He lost his starting job and is going to be a hybrid S/LB this season.

Ok, no need to get all personal...

I didn't mean "barely played" as in not playing in all games. I meant "barely played" in that he got a small fraction of snaps within each game. Yes, he played in all of them, but he was usually out there for ~20 defensive snaps of 50. Sure, that can be considered more than barely playing, but it's definitely barely playing, IMO, if you're going to give him a 91 rating.

Also, sorry, I got the class wrong. For some reason it feels like Martin has already been around forever, probably because I was following his recruitment because that was my first year working for Scout was when he was a senior, and it already feels like a long time ago.

With that said, it makes it even more ridiculous, IMO, that he's a true sophomore ranked 91 overall. Haha.

[leetdemon]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Rosters Issue

pryor is too and has a 90 speed to go with it....

[Security Device]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Rosters Issue

pryor is too and has a 90 speed to go with it....

Pryor and Griffin both earned their 90 SPD in my opinion. We all know Griffin is fast. Pryor has deceptive speed with his long strides. Denard Robinson is up there too, but since he's never touched the college field, so I'm happy with the 88 rating.

[tswiatkowski]

speaking of fast, edwin baker, an incoming freshman for michigan state, ran against me in high school. the guy makes me look like a tree when i run well. I talked to one of his teammates and they said he ran a 10.2 100m dash, so I would like to see his speed a bit higher, like 97 or something. 93 is cool since he hasnt played any games yet, but 10.2? thats faster than Jahvid Best man.