NCAA Football 10 Video: Powerhouse vs. Weak School (AI vs. AI)

[Strummer101er]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Video: Powerhouse vs. Weak School (AI vs. AI)

I'm with agreement with everyone else they really need to work on the atmosphere. I would even take a cut scene of the players celebrating

I think we should have optional user-controlled celebrations after every play or TD. There's a whole lot of buttons on the controller. I'm sure EA could find a button or two for a random user-controlled celebration after a big play or a TD.

Toss in the risk of an unsportsmanlike penalty and it adds a new wrinkle.

But yeah, the energy in NCAA has been dead for years. Custom stadium sounds help a lot, but the players and the crowd all seem suicidally depressed.

[sportzbro]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Video: Powerhouse vs. Weak School (AI vs. AI)

Yeah...it;s called a drawe, a trap, or a delay...not a dive.

Nice try kid.

owned.

I'm with agreement with everyone else they really need to work on the atmosphere. I would even take a cut scene of the players celebrating

..or just everything that was in last gen. there is zero emotional connection with the players, team, or game in general for me without presentation. Its like playing with hallow robots.

[longshanks]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Video: Powerhouse vs. Weak School (AI vs. AI)

this sucks, i'm a utah state fan and the rosters are jacked up, they're different from last years but still jacked up, number 32 jacob atkinson is not a tight end, he played fullback last year and now will start middle linebacker this year, i hope they get the rosters fixed

[jsquigg]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Video: Powerhouse vs. Weak School (AI vs. AI)

Unfortunately, this game hasn't made any significant improvements over last year. The continued lack of presentation is inexcusable, but not as inexcusable as the game play. I have a feeling "robo QB" is back and as mentioned previously, the running animations are somewhat gimmicky. But the #1 problem I have is the lack of any scheming in line play. Just because the OL can form a pocket doesn't mean it should look like that every play, especially when a DL can dominate and prevent the pocket from forming. The run game blocking is broken, especially on the option. The game happens in the trenches, not on the skill sticks with skill players. I'd like to see more strategy on both lines, not force fed this pro tak pocket forming garbage. Just my two cents.

[65South]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Video: Powerhouse vs. Weak School (AI vs. AI)

I've been nothing but a NCAA football player for the last 3-4 years, gave up Madden during that time, but after watching this video there are a couple of things that worry me...

1. There STILL seems to be a lack of pass rush. This definitely should not be a problem with Florida in the trenches against Utah State. This is called "Powerhouse vs. Weak School" for a reason.

2. AI Play-calling. I think this has been touched on a lot in this thread so no reason for me to repeat it.

3. Why in the heck are offensive lineman (still) turning around to face the dog-on QB!?? I surely hope this is something that will be remedied before release or via patch update shortly after.

I was about as excited as any hardcore NCAA player, but I'm just not at the point where I can drop 60 bucks on a product that is shipped while incomplete only hoping to have it fixed after market. Having new "bells and whistles", season showdown or online dynasty just isn't going to be enough to have me sweep gameplay issues under the rug. I'm not talking about roster stuff here, but to me these seem to be common things that go with the game of football.

When did we get to this point where we're expected to buy an incomplete or bugged product, paying up-front, and have it fixed later??

[sportzbro]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Video: Powerhouse vs. Weak School (AI vs. AI)

Just watched it..

The only good that I could really pick out were the fixed pursuit angles & the lighting for night games, which looks great.

Other than that, the running & throwing animations continue to hurt my eyes. Absolutely no sense of weight or momentum. Twitch running has got to be addressed with that being said.. Lack of presentation goes without saying at this point. Ball physics on passes look horrible.

And how isn't Florida (at home no less) only managing a 27-0 lead? In reality, it would be more like 60-7 by this point. Florida should be dominating every aspect of this game, yet the Aggies were still able to blow up Florida's line several times. The Gators should be running circles around them..

These videos continue to kill any hope I may have left for 2010.

[MacPlex]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Video: Powerhouse vs. Weak School (AI vs. AI)

Lol at all thses guys saying running on 3rd and long is not realistic. Playing the number 1 team and Im using utah state. I am not going to risk a pic and field position. Id rather run get 5 yards or so n punt the ball.

[mjussawalla]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Video: Powerhouse vs. Weak School (AI vs. AI)

After seeing the video, I think EA needs to improve the CPU play calling chart? (i.e. so they know what calls to make in what situation)

It seems the CPU randomly call plays based on the school's/coach Run-Pass tendencies. i.e. if it is a 60%Run-40%Pass there is a 60% probability they will run on every play.

[jsquigg]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Video: Powerhouse vs. Weak School (AI vs. AI)

Lol at all thses guys saying running on 3rd and long is not realistic. Playing the number 1 team and Im using utah state. I am not going to risk a pic and field position. Id rather run get 5 yards or so n punt the ball.

Great strategy! Run the ball to keep the clock going so we can get out of Florida as fast as possible. Wait.... That makes no sense at all, since that would mean they aren't playing for the win. I would want you to coach my bad college team so we could run every play to try and keep the game within six touchdowns.

If you think it's NOT a game play flaw to run on third and long for any team (consistently) than you probably don't comprehend football too well. This is a problem because it happened twice in a clip that is a small sample size of the plays that will happen in a full game. It's also a problem because it happened a lot last year. Unfortunately, I think there is too much randomness still in cpu play calling. Based on what I've seen, I definitely won't be buying on opening day.

[legendkiller5]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Video: Powerhouse vs. Weak School (AI vs. AI)

Lol at all thses guys saying running on 3rd and long is not realistic. Playing the number 1 team and Im using utah state. I am not going to risk a pic and field position. Id rather run get 5 yards or so n punt the ball.

So...I guess you don't like being employed?

[Strummer101er]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Video: Powerhouse vs. Weak School (AI vs. AI)

And how isn't Florida (at home no less) only managing a 27-0 lead? In reality, it would be more like 60-7 by this point.

Looks like five-minute quarters to me. 27-0 seems like a good score if you take that into account.

[countryboy]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Video: Powerhouse vs. Weak School (AI vs. AI)

I didn't have a problem with Utah St. running the ball on 3rd and long. Seemed realistic to me. Although, it may only seem that way because I'm used to Steve Kragthorpe's playcalling..lol

[Hova57]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Video: Powerhouse vs. Weak School (AI vs. AI)

i thinks its realistic many times in football when you are to backed up u run to get some space and take what you can get. i do think though the cpu should have atleast take a stab down field once

[nstod]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Video: Powerhouse vs. Weak School (AI vs. AI)

If I were a USU guy, I would be happy they ran the ball on 3rd down. In the 90's when they would play Utah, they would punt on 3rd down periodically to surprise the Utes. At least they're not punting on 3rd anymore.

[williamf30]

I dont know if anyone else noticed but doesnt utah state have team color socks on. They might be black but they look like their dark blue..

P.S. Nice video