Team Prestige in NCAA Football 10

[jeremym480]

Re: Team Prestige in NCAA Football 10

LMAO, at all the Homer's in this thread. But, then again Bama's has 6 star's.

[Tovarich]

Re: Team Prestige in NCAA Football 10

How does Alabama not deserve a 6 star rating? Honestly. Most historical powerhouses seem to have them and Alabama has fared just as well or better than them. Does Notre Dame not deserve it's ranking?

If they want to make the historical powers all 6 stars, then the logic needs to be consistent to fit with everyone else. If Notre Dame and Alabama are going to be 6 stars always no matter what, then the game should make it impossible for them to lose it because the fact that they are historical powers will never change. My disagreement is more with the logic than with their decisions. It's not consistent with what they pick before the game is finalized, and how the game treats it once you're into a dynasty.

[wisecav]

Re: Team Prestige in NCAA Football 10

lol yep. and without even taking a snap in a real college game they think this kid is going to be the greatest thing since sliced bread. i get such a kick out of this tool. he has his own website and he thinks he is gonna be the greatest QB who ever lived

http://www.qbforce.com/NEW2009/TATE/tates-home.html

Sam McGuffie, anyone?

Don't forget his brother's transfer speech.

My Big Ten Prestige Ratings

Ohio State - 6*
Michigan - 6*
Penn St. - 5*
Iowa - 4*
Purdue - 3*
Wisconsin - 3*
Northwestern -3*
Indiana - 2*
Illinois - 3*
Michigan St. - 4*
Minnesota - 3*

I agree with all these. I still think Penn State could be a 6*. Don't wanna make Utah fan's upset. :wink:

[pistonchamps04]

Re: Team Prestige in NCAA Football 10

You are and we are, but Tate Forcier and Denard Robinson are already better than what we had last year without even taking a snap. If I'm not mistaken, you all will be experiencing a little inexperienced QB syndrome as well. I revert back to a formula I came up with: Talent > Experience. But only if you can't have both.

here are the facts buddy. i know quite a few players who were recruited and offered by ur buddy DickRod. they guy has the nickname for a reason. he has dick for a personality. he can't even recruit in his own state, and don't give me that "oh well he just recruits nationally" garbage, because quite frankly when it comes down to trying to run with the ball or catch the ball in 20 and 30 degree weather, and when it comes down to the rivalries against MSU and OSU, these kids won't understand and will treat it like a normal game.

Lloyd Carr...now that was a winner. that was a man with class. that was a man that i could respect, even as someone at State. but your buddy Rodriguez is a joke.

here's a few videos for you to watch just to prove my point

http://vids.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=vids.individual&videoid=50706848

http://vids.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=vids.individual&VideoID=50708290

oh, and P.S., none of the actual UM - ANN ARBOR alumni (Flint and Dearborn are kinda a joke) that i know actually believe that he'll be around in 3 years. they believe the program is headed in the wrong direction, not because of his record, but because of his overall style

[Kentucky3D]

Re: Team Prestige in NCAA Football 10

Kentucky a 3 star and Louisville a 4 star?

C'mon seriously? We've won 3 bowl games in a row where we beat Clemson, FSU, and ECU. Definitely deserve 4 stars. Louisville should be 3 stars since they haven't made a bowl game in 2 years and are going to be bad this year.

[six]

Re: Team Prestige in NCAA Football 10

To that one guy, how out of all of the bad rankings do you think kentucky should be dropped to a 2 star?

3 straight bowl games, clearly on the rise...yet you don't mention 4 star Rutgers and 4 star Louisville? Give me a break.

None of the SEC teams should be below 3 stars, cause Kentucky, Ole miss, SC, etc, are 4 or 5 stars in every other conference except the Big XII.

[auburntigersfan]

Re: Team Prestige in NCAA Football 10

Clemson should definitely not be a 3 star, they should be a 4 star.

[pistonchamps04]

Re: Team Prestige in NCAA Football 10

Don't forget his brother's transfer speech.



I agree with all these. I still think Penn State could be a 6*. Don't wanna make Utah fan's upset. :wink:

lol at that speech

and yeah, i think those ratings are all correct and i do think that Penn State should probably be a 6 if Michigan is 6. OSU is without a doubt a 6

[davidmj444]

Re: Team Prestige in NCAA Football 10

Clemson should definitely not be a 3 star, they should be a 4 star.

Exactly, we haven't had a losing season since '98.

[pistonchamps04]

Re: Team Prestige in NCAA Football 10

id say Nichol is pretty talented for MSU

yeah, 2 qb's who were in the Elite 11 camp in high school on this years roster, and it was just announced that the qb we have coming in next year will be in the Elite 11 camp too. no big deal.

[STLcardz-NDirish]

Re: Team Prestige in NCAA Football 10

just one of the hundreds of reaons why its great to be a Notre Dame fan. my 6* rating to start a dynasty. haha

[Sublime12089]

Re: Team Prestige in NCAA Football 10

USF is only a 3 still? The same as UCF? Look at the two programs accomplishments and tell me they deserve the same.

[sportzbro]

Re: Team Prestige in NCAA Football 10

The thing that sucks about these ratings is they were figured in the same manner as the banter in this thread - back & forth about teams until we come to an agreement... maybe.

The developers/designers sit down and talk about it..That's it. There isn't a system, or a logical way to determine them..its just conversation, and they move on. There should be a deeper method to figuring this imo. It may be a small part of the overall game, but it goes a long ways in dynasty..

[aimiami]

Re: Team Prestige in NCAA Football 10

The thing that sucks about these ratings is they were figured in the same manner as the banter in this thread - back & forth about teams until we come to an agreement... maybe.

The developers/designers sit down and talk about it..That's it. There isn't a system, or a logical way to determine them..its just conversation, and they move on. There should be a deeper method to figuring this imo. It may be a small part of the overall game, but it goes a long ways in dynasty..

in dynasty all you need to do is win and it goes up so...

[sportzbro]

Re: Team Prestige in NCAA Football 10

My SEC Prestige Ratings:

Florida - 6*
Alabama - 5*
LSU - 6*
Arkansas - 4*
Kentucky -3*
Vanderbilt -2*
Tennessee - 4*
Georgia - 5*
Ole Miss - 4*
Miss St. -3*
Auburn - 5*
South Carolina - 3*

In my opinion