You have to start somewhere don't you? And we were told when it was first introduced that highlights from other games weren't going to be part of the package.
Nobody is defending EA here, just understanding that you have to start somewhere. No it doesn't have all the things that we may want, but its not horrible either. In my opinion, its great first step and more in-depth then I expected it to be.
And no, this isn't perfect, but its better than nothing. And I, and probably 95% of this community would rather have this than nothing at all.
Now you can label me as easy to please. And before you ask, I have played 2k5 and seen its presentation.