I haven't tried that yet. We were going to do that last night but during the game I got an "unreadable disc error" (first time ever...very weird) and had to disconnect. I'm going to try that tonight.
OK so the consensus here is that because douchebags abuse it, we don't have it? It's amazing how bad people cheese online. I guess I'll wait for the patch to fix the auto-replays then. I had a few great plays that were deserving of the auto-replay but it didn't happen.