49ers Users Smith or Hill? - Operation Sports Forums

49ers Users Smith or Hill?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • babythug23
    MVP
    • Oct 2005
    • 1988

    #1

    49ers Users Smith or Hill?

    I will be running with Niners in my 1st franchise ever on Madden(nfl2k fan).I was wonder who you going to put at QB. I try to keep things real so i won't go out and sign anyone. Right now I'm Leaning with Hill.
    GameTag Babythug24

    PSN Brandon26ms
  • bafiofromgermany
    Rookie
    • Sep 2005
    • 11

    #2
    Re: 49ers Users Smith or Hill?

    I picked Hill for my 49ers franchise. Hill is a very good short to medium range passer, just don't ever pass deep with the guy! Smith is a much wilder passer but he's better at moving out of the pocket and passing the deep ball. Just pick the player that suites your style. Be prepared though during every drive with Hill the commentary will continously talk about how much Hill sucks and they are amazed he's making completed passes to keep a drive going.
    Last edited by bafiofromgermany; 08-17-2009, 04:51 PM.

    Comment

    • GSW
      Simnation
      • Feb 2003
      • 8041

      #3
      Re: 49ers Users Smith or Hill?

      I use Hill.. VD in the flat.. thats all u need VD is a freaking BEAST in this game
      #Simnation

      Comment

      • str8stuntin03
        Rookie
        • Feb 2003
        • 448

        #4
        Re: 49ers Users Smith or Hill?

        Personally I like Alex Smith better than Shaun Hill. I try to get Hill a chance since he is a Terp but I like Alex Smith release and mobility when things break down
        GamerTag - Swt James Jones


        [OS Vets NBA 2k8 S1 Co-Champion - Nuggets]
        [OS Vets NBA 2k8 S2 Runner Up - Trailblazers]
        [OS Vets NBA 2k9 Champion - Sixers]
        [OS Vets NBA 2k10 Runner Up - Warriors]
        [OS Vets NBA 2k11 S2 Regular Season Champ - Knicks]
        [New Era Sims NBA 2K12 Champion - Bulls]

        Comment

        • bafiofromgermany
          Rookie
          • Sep 2005
          • 11

          #5
          Re: 49ers Users Smith or Hill?

          I have a bias against Smith too, the money he demanded and got for being the first pick in the draft and ended up being such a awful bust. 49ers still haven't recovered from that horrible draft pick. I refuse to play as him.

          Comment

          • woody2goody
            MVP
            • Mar 2009
            • 2104

            #6
            Re: 49ers Users Smith or Hill?

            Smith isn't as bad as everyone makes out he is/was.

            Remember that the team has improved since Smith was QB before.
            Supporting Leeds United, Colorado Rockies, Detroit Lions and the Colorado Avalanche!

            Now Playing FIFA, UFC 4, PGA Tour 2k23, WWE, MLB The Show and Dirt Rally 2.0

            Comment

            • theyhateme14
              Rookie
              • Mar 2009
              • 3

              #7
              Re: 49ers Users Smith or Hill?

              Hill seems to be more accurate...

              I want Smith to be good but like in real life he disappoints...

              Comment

              • bafiofromgermany
                Rookie
                • Sep 2005
                • 11

                #8
                Re: 49ers Users Smith or Hill?

                He's very injury prone, and he's only decent at best... I remember ripping my hair out when the 49ers decided to pick him. Then he demanded to be the highest payed draft pick ever and the 49ers gave him the money.... Got my blood bowling now gonna release him on my franchise now lol.

                Comment

                • Bruin26
                  Pro
                  • Feb 2003
                  • 724

                  #9
                  Re: 49ers Users Smith or Hill?

                  I was just wondering this myself while just eating my lunch. Wondered what others here were doing with their 49ers franchise.

                  I actually haven't decided yet. I have two games complete in my pre-season I started Hill the first game and Alex the second game, playing them each the first half with the other starters. Then the backup for each gmae only played the 3rd qtr because I wanted to play a qtr with Nate Davis as well.

                  Through two games Smith looks to be winning the job for me, but not going to decide until the pre-season is done. Hill had a poor game my first game, but he was 7-7 with the second stringers and two td's in the second game. Smith played well both games though. Hill is more accurate with the short passes, but I do see the difference with longer passes between the two.

                  I have a feeling I will restart my franchise once the real pre-season is over anyway because it will want to use the updated roster which may have some added players to the team especially if guys like Sheets or any others make the team.

                  But for now with this franchise I will wait to decided like I said, but kinda want to go with Smith just because if I can get him imrpoved he seems to have more upside just be`cause of the age difference, but we'll see.

                  If I do restart once the real season begins with an updated roster I will go with whoever the team really did go with.

                  Comment

                  • Big_Mig_11
                    Rookie
                    • Mar 2009
                    • 344

                    #10
                    Re: 49ers Users Smith or Hill?

                    In the game, I use Hill. I actually believe that M10 does a GREAT job with the way these two play. Hill does a great job at managing the game and not turning the ball over. Now, I know what your thinking, "it is not Hill who doesnt turn the ball over, its the player". Yes this is true for the most part, but if anybody has religously switched between the 2 like I have, they would notice that while playing with Smith, his unload time is SUPER slow, so he becomes more vulnerable to the "ugly duck pass" when almost getting sacked.

                    Also, he would inexplicably throw a ball that was so off to a wide-open reciever in medium range every now and then resulting in a turnover.

                    I am a fan of Smith. He has a million excuses to why he has not blossomed to a star, but he FULLY blames himself and all real 9er fans know this and appreciate this. He is a humble young man (only 25 still!!). Not saying he will avoid being a bust, but man he works his tail off. And for the 4 mil or so he makes as a back-up is not bad. A thing to consider in your franchise (good back-up at least). I will root for him always...

                    Comment

                    • dubz
                      Rookie
                      • Jul 2008
                      • 289

                      #11
                      Re: 49ers Users Smith or Hill?

                      Nate Davis....yes I'm serious.

                      Comment

                      • adembroski
                        49ers
                        • Jul 2002
                        • 5820

                        #12
                        Re: 49ers Users Smith or Hill?

                        Originally posted by dubz
                        Nate Davis....yes I'm serious.
                        +1... due to the nature of how Madden works, he is easily the best QB on the roster.

                        Awareness doesn't count for the user
                        There are two types of people on OS: Those who disagree with me, and those who agree.

                        The first kind is wrong. The second is superfluous.

                        “The only difference between reality and fiction is that fiction needs to be credible.”
                        -Mark Twain.

                        Comment

                        • Bruin26
                          Pro
                          • Feb 2003
                          • 724

                          #13
                          Re: 49ers Users Smith or Hill?

                          Funny you both said that because in reality Davis won't improve unless he plays right? I mean that is how it usually happens in Madden, which I hope changes at some point, especially with their being a focus on the potential ratings. A or B rated players for potential should improve even if they sit on the bench a year.

                          Davis's ratings do look pretty good when you don't pay attention to awareness.

                          Comment

                          • SFNiners816
                            Pro
                            • Aug 2008
                            • 578

                            #14
                            Re: 49ers Users Smith or Hill?

                            Originally posted by dubz
                            Nate Davis....yes I'm serious.

                            I will start out with Hill, but my goal is to develop Davis in to the franchise QB.

                            Comment

                            • goh
                              Banned
                              • Aug 2003
                              • 20779

                              #15
                              Re: 49ers Users Smith or Hill?

                              I signed Harrell off the FA list. So far I've given them 1 quater each in the 2 pre-season games I've done. Davis gets the 1st,Harrell 2nd,Smith 3rd and Hill 4th.

                              Harrell has the highest rating,most yards,most TDs,longest pass (wich wasn't actually long,Davis just busted 2 tackles and took off then Crabtree did the same thing the next game) and average but worst completion %. He came in wearing #8 btw,I changed it to 12.

                              Smith is 2nd in rating,yards,longest pass,completion % and average. All are equal in TDs after Harell with 1 each.

                              Hill is 3rd in rating,yards,longest pass and average but 1st in completion %.

                              Davis is 3rd in completion % and 4th in everything else. He does have the best highlight wich I couldn't upload because I'm silver. (Despite being able to in NCAA 10) He's also been bailed out twice on great catches by Crabtree and Burress.

                              So basically I'm right back to where I started. 4 games each?
                              At the end of season I plan on getting Montana anyway.

                              Comment

                              Working...