Announcing the NCAA Football Wishlist Tournament (ncaaStrategies)

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • J-Unit40
    Boom!!
    • Sep 2005
    • 8261

    #16
    Re: Announcing the NCAA Football Wishlist Tournament (ncaaStrategies)

    Originally posted by mjussawalla
    Good points.

    I would have 2 tournaments. One for gameplay/sim issues and one for presentation/graphical issues.

    For example, the team responsible for "new playbook in practice" would be different than those putting in new mascots.
    Great point. On the field areas (gameplay) come way before other areas, but they are two separate teams, which is good in a way.

    Thanks for posting Steve!
    "Hard work beats talent, when talent isn't working hard.”

    Comment

    • da ThRONe
      Fire LesS Miles ASAP!
      • Mar 2009
      • 8528

      #17
      Re: Announcing the NCAA Football Wishlist Tournament (ncaaStrategies)

      I want formation subs but it isnt #1 on my list!
      You looking at the Chair MAN!

      Number may not tell the whole story ,but they never lie either.

      Comment

      • gschwendt
        EA Game Changer
        • May 2003
        • 1044

        #18
        Re: Announcing the NCAA Football Wishlist Tournament (ncaaStrategies)

        We plan to have another polling & discussion regarding gameplay tuning among other tuning aspects (sliders, position changes, etc.). Since those things happen every year and happen a hundred times each development cycle, we wanted to keep that separate.

        Comment

        • da ThRONe
          Fire LesS Miles ASAP!
          • Mar 2009
          • 8528

          #19
          Re: Announcing the NCAA Football Wishlist Tournament (ncaaStrategies)

          Originally posted by gschwendt
          I whole-heartedly disagree. For those that have posted their 1-68 on the site, my list would look completely different. Even just my 1-10 wouldn't even have the same items.

          The development team is not just catering to one subset of users and they're certainly not catering just to the vocal minority. They have to cater to the mascot mode guy on up to the guy that plays straight on Heisman and still blows out Florida using Idaho.
          Its funny Madden added most things people wanted on there wishlist and NCAA list. So you cant say they dont know they just have their own agenda!

          My top thing is better physics(a la Madden)
          You looking at the Chair MAN!

          Number may not tell the whole story ,but they never lie either.

          Comment

          • JAYMO76
            MVP
            • Aug 2008
            • 1361

            #20
            Re: Announcing the NCAA Football Wishlist Tournament (ncaaStrategies)

            Originally posted by J-Unit40
            Great point. On the field areas (gameplay) come way before other areas, but they are two separate teams, which is good in a way.

            Thanks for posting Steve!
            Yes, junit, gameplay is crucial to NCAA Football. However, every year on next gen the development team has neglected the most basic aspects of the dynasty mode (presentation, atmosphere, etc, etc.) What I am saying is you can't have one without the other. Continue to tweak gameplay BUT for NCAA 11 give some major, major focus to dynasty mode. If a game palys great but is boring to play, why would I want to play the game longterm?
            Roar you Lions roar!

            Comment

            • gschwendt
              EA Game Changer
              • May 2003
              • 1044

              #21
              Re: Announcing the NCAA Football Wishlist Tournament (ncaaStrategies)

              Round 1 is officially underway. Today brings 16 of the 32 Round 1 matchups with the remainder coming later this week. Vote and make sure your opinion is heard.

              Comment

              • rudyjuly2
                Cade Cunningham
                • Aug 2002
                • 14816

                #22
                Re: Announcing the NCAA Football Wishlist Tournament (ncaaStrategies)

                I'll have to remember to do that later tonight or tomorrow when I can log on at home. How long do the votes stay open?

                Comment

                • gschwendt
                  EA Game Changer
                  • May 2003
                  • 1044

                  #23
                  Re: Announcing the NCAA Football Wishlist Tournament (ncaaStrategies)

                  Originally posted by rudyjuly2
                  How long do the votes stay open?
                  3 days.

                  Comment

                  • gschwendt
                    EA Game Changer
                    • May 2003
                    • 1044

                    #24
                    Re: Announcing the NCAA Football Wishlist Tournament (ncaaStrategies)

                    The second half of Round 1 has been posted.


                    Matchups are:
                    9-Man Gang Tackles vs Online Roster Editor
                    Access OD via Web vs DLC Uniforms
                    Better Defensive Playbooks vs Wider Offensive Line Splits
                    Better Offensive Playbooks vs Better Fatigue System
                    Coaching Carousel vs Duplicate Numbers
                    Correct Option Blocking vs Bowl Patches
                    Create-a-Stadium vs Medical Redshirts
                    Cut Scenes vs Selectable Captains & Impact Players
                    More & Unique Animations vs In-Game Saves
                    More Slider Options vs Spring Game
                    New QB Ratings vs Online Depth Charts
                    On-Field Refs & Coaches vs Continue Dynasty Year-to-Year
                    Replace FCS with TB Teams vs Neutral Site Games
                    Special Teams Overhaul vs Helmet Numbers In-Play
                    Team Celebrations vs Fight for the Fumble
                    Team Entrances vs Select New Playbook in Practice

                    Comment

                    • gschwendt
                      EA Game Changer
                      • May 2003
                      • 1044

                      #25
                      Re: Announcing the NCAA Football Wishlist Tournament (ncaaStrategies)

                      Round 2 is now underway.


                      For anyone interested in seeing the results of Round 1 or just checking out the bracket:
                      http://www.bracketmaker.com/tmenu.cfm?tid=334316

                      What's your favorite matchup in Round 2?

                      Comment

                      Working...