Official Madden Gripe Thread #2

[aholbert32]

This thread is solely for gripes/issues about Madden. While this thread is for users who want to complain about an aspect of the game, we will not tolerate any trolling, cosntant complaints from people who have not played the game or any baseless complaints. This thread is for people who have played the game and have a complaint about any aspect of the game.

[sois]

Re: Official Madden Gripe Thread #2

I played the game at Gamestop, I guess I don't have proof that I played it, but am I allowed to post here? Is it against the TOS for me to post in threads about games I don't own? Is a rental good enough?

I keep most of my posts pretty clean and try to provide meaningful feedback, but I thought the gripe thread would allow me to vent a little more than a typical thread.

I have many complaints and would like to gripe. Thank you.

[aholbert32]

Re: Official Madden Gripe Thread #2

I played the game at Gamestop, I guess I don't have proof that I played it, but am I allowed to post here? Is it against the TOS for me to post in threads about games I don't own? Is a rental good enough?

I keep most of my posts pretty clean and try to provide meaningful feedback, but I thought the gripe thread would allow me to vent a little more than a typical thread.

I have many complaints and would like to gripe. Thank you.

As long as youve played the game. With that said, there is no more leeway here than there is in a regular forum. You go overboard and you will receive an infraction.

[Football4Natic]

Re: Official Madden Gripe Thread #2

I played the game at Gamestop, I guess I don't have proof that I played it, but am I allowed to post here? Is it against the TOS for me to post in threads about games I don't own? Is a rental good enough?

I keep most of my posts pretty clean and try to provide meaningful feedback, but I thought the gripe thread would allow me to vent a little more than a typical thread.

I have many complaints and would like to gripe. Thank you.

You do not own the game and playing int at gamestop does not provide you with the facts about the complete package and experience. Since your biggest gripe was about injured reserve then that is it. You said your peace now move along.You post more in the gripe thread then most and you dont have the game.Nothing wrong with not liking a game. But you act like EA took your lunch money.Write them a letter or send them an e-mail.But you just want to throw dirt on the matter and you do not have the game.Enough is enough. Let people with the game post their issues and do not troll. Because that is what you are doing my friend.

[NC State-31 UNC-27]

Re: Official Madden Gripe Thread #2

Pursuit angles are horrible. Sucks playing a game when I know every TD I score is marred because the defense is stupid and should have tackled me 40 yards before the endzone.

I guess it evens out because of how bad the blocking is. Basically what you get in the open field is no blocks made, and no defenders actually trying to tackle you. When a tackle is in the midst of being broken, all the other defenders STOP playing and watch. Of course the tackle gets broken, the ball carrier is immediately at full speed again, and the defense is too stupid to catch you. They follow you all the way to the endzone with their heads up their you know what.

Two critical parts of football...blocking and pursuing the ball carrier. Completely BROKEN.

This is unacceptable.

[Football4Natic]

Re: Official Madden Gripe Thread #2

Pursuit angles are horrible. Sucks playing a game when I know every TD I score is marred because the defense is stupid and should have tackled me 40 yards before the endzone.

I guess it evens out because of how bad the blocking is. Basically what you get in the open field is no blocks made, and no defenders actually trying to tackle you. When a tackle is in the midst of being broken, all the other defenders STOP playing and watch. Of course the tackle gets broken, the ball carrier is immediately at full speed again, and the defense is too stupid to catch you. They follow you all the way to the endzone with their heads up their you know what.

Two critical parts of football...blocking and pursuing the ball carrier. Completely BROKEN.

This is unacceptable.

This does not happen in all madden or with custom sliders. Sorry but it just does not.

[Jukeman]

Re: Official Madden Gripe Thread #2

Pursuit angles are horrible. Sucks playing a game when I know every TD I score is marred because the defense is stupid and should have tackled me 40 yards before the endzone.

I guess it evens out because of how bad the blocking is. Basically what you get in the open field is no blocks made, and no defenders actually trying to tackle you. When a tackle is in the midst of being broken, all the other defenders STOP playing and watch. Of course the tackle gets broken, the ball carrier is immediately at full speed again, and the defense is too stupid to catch you. They follow you all the way to the endzone with their heads up their you know what.

Two critical parts of football...blocking and pursuing the ball carrier. Completely BROKEN.

This is unacceptable.

You should try some of the popular sliders in the slider forum...Cant help you with online play sorry....

[reyes the roof]

Re: Official Madden Gripe Thread #2

A few things I'm having issues with

1. When I have a DE and a DT doing a stunt, there shouldn't be a lb lining up between them faking a blitz, all he does is get in the way. I don't have time to manualy move him and I don't want to reposition all 3 LBs

2. When I have a guys near the sideline and I throw an accurate pass to him, the ball tends to carry him out of bounds too much

[miaturne]

Re: Official Madden Gripe Thread #2

Just wanted to say first of all that this is the first madden I bought since 05, and its good to be back at OS... home of the sim ballers

It seems waaay to easy to shut out the CPU running attack in All-Pro. All I have to do is blitz. While blocking is somewhat improved over last year, it seems like the CPU cannot get any sort of push on the line. Some teams this year are beasts on the pass and are a headache to deal with, but some teams (eg Minn, SD, NYG, Car, SF) rely on the run heavily and should have some success ramming it down my throat and forcing me to stack the line; however, this is not the case becasue the run is too easy to stop.

I know that this issue really has to do with blocking animations and the game engine, but it was just a gripe.

Also, why does it seem like Robo QB is back in full effect?

[SA1NT401]

Re: Official Madden Gripe Thread #2

I only have 3 gripes which are more than likely patch-able.....The other bigger issues i feel are design flaws which are not able to be fixed with a patch like...Ol Blocking and Pursuit angles being the Big 2. I personally believe the poor pursuit angles were actually on purpose. But that is just me, i know its probably not so, but how did they get SO bad and more importantly go unnoticed?

My HUGE issues which NEED to be addressed yesterday as they do absolutely KILL the game AS a whole.

1- The Flats...Nuff said.
2- The CPU Play logic overall especially on D. (4-5 wide sets lined up against 4-3 / 3-4 defenses)
3- The STUPID Blitz-tastic aggressiveness by the D. They will sellout ALL THE TIME! Makes the game SO EASY its not even fun.

Fix those 3 and we can live with the other stupid things as they reall dont "break" the game per say (The overall sim engine is GOD awful. You know what i am talking about).

I honestly think we got a completely different game than the one at community day...I want that one.

[pf8363]

Re: Official Madden Gripe Thread #2

lead passing is a joke. ill have a receiver wide open with a safety 10 yards in front of him. i press the button and then down on the left stick. my receiver should come back to the ball so he doesnt get drilled. no, the lead passing doesnt work and the safety picks off the pass because my wr doesnt even try to catch the ball. every time i press down to make the receiver come back to the ball, it gets picked by a player that is past where my reciever is.

The entire passing game is a joke really. passing downfield is impossible and i can just throw it to the flats every play and gain 15+ yards if i want to.

The fact that dbs can react to the ball in the air and go get it but my receiver has to wait and not jump for it is stupid. it makes having tall receivers like calvin johnson and larry fitz pointless. there is no jump catch animation just that stupid ****ing over the shoulder crap. does ea test their games at all? how can you ship a football game where the only way to complete passes is to throw it short or have tom brady?

[kingkilla56]

Re: Official Madden Gripe Thread #2

I just want fair attributes on higher difficulties. No more cpu randy moss linebackers

[likebuttababy11]

Re: Official Madden Gripe Thread #2

lead passing is a joke. ill have a receiver wide open with a safety 10 yards in front of him. i press the button and then down on the left stick. my receiver should come back to the ball so he doesnt get drilled. no, the lead passing doesnt work and the safety picks off the pass because my wr doesnt even try to catch the ball. every time i press down to make the receiver come back to the ball, it gets picked by a player that is past where my reciever is.

The entire passing game is a joke really. passing downfield is impossible and i can just throw it to the flats every play and gain 15+ yards if i want to.

The fact that dbs can react to the ball in the air and go get it but my receiver has to wait and not jump for it is stupid. it makes having tall receivers like calvin johnson and larry fitz pointless. there is no jump catch animation just that stupid ****ing over the shoulder crap. does ea test their games at all? how can you ship a football game where the only way to complete passes is to throw it short or have tom brady?

I agree w/ this guy,I was in practice mode to see what was going wrong w/ my passing game,I just decided to throw streaks with Brady and Favre,I tried everything from pushing up on the L anologue stick to R,L and they still tend to throw the ball out of bounds or closer to the sideline,all I want is a damn streak,this happens 7/10 times for me,push up,instead of a nice fade rt,it goes out of bounds to both outside WRs.

[ityaboy56]

Re: Official Madden Gripe Thread #2

This does not happen in all madden or with custom sliders. Sorry but it just does not.

Ahh yes it does happen on all madden, all pro, pro, custom sliders, my skill you name it. But it definitely happens.

[LBzrule]

Re: Official Madden Gripe Thread #2

lead passing is a joke. ill have a receiver wide open with a safety 10 yards in front of him. i press the button and then down on the left stick. my receiver should come back to the ball so he doesnt get drilled. no, the lead passing doesnt work and the safety picks off the pass because my wr doesnt even try to catch the ball. every time i press down to make the receiver come back to the ball, it gets picked by a player that is past where my reciever is.

The entire passing game is a joke really. passing downfield is impossible and i can just throw it to the flats every play and gain 15+ yards if i want to.

The fact that dbs can react to the ball in the air and go get it but my receiver has to wait and not jump for it is stupid. it makes having tall receivers like calvin johnson and larry fitz pointless. there is no jump catch animation just that stupid ****ing over the shoulder crap. does ea test their games at all? how can you ship a football game where the only way to complete passes is to throw it short or have tom brady?

I disagree some what. Not completely. I've been able to hit some passes down the field. Do you switch over to the WR as soon as the ball leaves the QB's hands and try to make a play on it? I've actually been able to throw it up over the top and outrun some DB's and get it this way. I definitely disagree with the Johnson and Fitz comment. They are monsters in this game if you switch over and make plays on the ball and there are jump catch animations. I get them at times with Mark Clayton and he's nowhere near Fitz or Johnson.