Operation Sports Forums - View Single Post

Dianwei32 · 09-12-2009, 04:02 PM

Who would you rather have as your QB in Madden? Carson Palmer or Jay Cutler? I like Palmer better, but was unable to draft him in my franchise fantasy draft (not enough cap room for that pick, got a bunch of big contract guys early on), so I picked up Jay Cutler. They have very similar stats for the most part (identical THP very similar SAC/MAC/DAC, similar Throw on the Run and Play Action), but Cutler is a little better in the scrambling department and is younger.

Yet, after a rather sad simmed season (78.8 QB rating, 63% completion, 23 TDs, 17 INTs, a little over 3000 yards), I'm contemplating trading Cutler for Palmer. I like Palmer better and after one season (one decent season, which he had) his accuracy skyrockets (+11 to each of SAC/MAC/DAC) and he becomes an elite QB. Who would you rather have as your QB, Cutler or Palmer?

Let me reiterate that this is in MADDEN, not a fantasy football league or in real life, in Madden.

09-12-2009, 04:02 PM	#1
Dianwei32 Pro OVR: 12 Join Date: Sep 2008	C. Palmer or J. Cutler in Madden. Who would you rather have as your QB in Madden? Carson Palmer or Jay Cutler? I like Palmer better, but was unable to draft him in my franchise fantasy draft (not enough cap room for that pick, got a bunch of big contract guys early on), so I picked up Jay Cutler. They have very similar stats for the most part (identical THP very similar SAC/MAC/DAC, similar Throw on the Run and Play Action), but Cutler is a little better in the scrambling department and is younger. Yet, after a rather sad simmed season (78.8 QB rating, 63% completion, 23 TDs, 17 INTs, a little over 3000 yards), I'm contemplating trading Cutler for Palmer. I like Palmer better and after one season (one decent season, which he had) his accuracy skyrockets (+11 to each of SAC/MAC/DAC) and he becomes an elite QB. Who would you rather have as your QB, Cutler or Palmer? Let me reiterate that this is in MADDEN, not a fantasy football league or in real life, in Madden.