1st of all, Madden is NOT like 2k5...they tried to duplicate some of the presentation, and failed miserably, IMO. The presentation aspects just don't flow in many cases...they feel like something EA threw together just to say "it's in the game". And this, more than anything, shows me Tiburon really doesn't understand what they're doing...the game looks and feels rushed and unfinished in many ways. And ONCE AGAIN, QA absolutely sucks for the Madden series, which Ian stated they were gonna' address this year.
2nd, people are pissed off and complaining because these problems have been the same ever since EA bought the NFL license! People can say it was the changeover to 360 and PS3, but the truth is EA has sat on their laurels and run Madden damn near into the ground ever since there has been no competition...coincidence???
3rd, many of the complaints of the game are the SAME ones we've had for years. Yet, rather than just fix the damn game and make it right, every year we're fed some baloney new "feature" that's supposed to make our jaws drop (in EAs own words). The only time Madden 10 made my jaw drop was the numerous times I saw unbelievably idiotic programming that hasn't changed in years.
and lastly, there's the video of Ian, spouting ALMOST word for word the same tired rhetoric when he was talking about Madden a couple years back. Basically, people are fed up.