Which is better, NCAA or Madden?

[tessl]

I asked the question on the Madden forum and most people said Madden.

[jda1202]

Re: Which is better, NCAA or Madden?

this year I would have to say Madden by a mile

[football5680]

Re: Which is better, NCAA or Madden?

i have and play both and would say NCAA is better because i like the NFL better and the recruiting is very fun and stuff. madden their is not much new stuff to add to it. when you get to the season all it is is playing games but NCAA you get to recruit and stuff. also the NCAA offseason is funner.

[wisecav]

Re: Which is better, NCAA or Madden?

I like them both. Neither game has been a waste of my money. But its all a matter of personal opinion.

[Roggie]

Re: Which is better, NCAA or Madden?

There's a simple answer here. The majority of people on the Madden boards will say Madden and the majority here will say NCAA, minus the ones who constantly bash it.

I say NCAA, because Madden on slow puts me to sleep.

[Daniels]

Re: Which is better, NCAA or Madden?

Both are great. I'd say NCAA by an inch.

[stoncold32]

Re: Which is better, NCAA or Madden?

The bottom line is this, Madden is better by a mile. The guy earlier said "there's not much new to MAdden" Really? Are you serious, dude? The whole game is literally new.

And look at my avi, I'm a college football to the core. But NCAA is just bad compared to Madden. And to the other guy who said Madden is boring on "slow" mode....how bout you bump the speed up to match the NCAA speed? Easy fix....

Madden moves better and is smoother, while NCAA is too jerky. If thats what you like though, then get NCAA.

[Roggie]

Re: Which is better, NCAA or Madden?

And look at my avi, I'm a college football to the core. But NCAA is just bad compared to Madden. And to the other guy who said Madden is boring on "slow" mode....how bout you bump the speed up to match the NCAA speed? Easy fix....

You can't bump up the speed online.

[gotvols]

Re: Which is better, NCAA or Madden?

I like them both. Neither game has been a waste of my money. But its all a matter of personal opinion.

I agree with this. I also own both games. Both are worth the money.

[Laettner32]

Re: Which is better, NCAA or Madden?

I like both.

I like NCAA better, but I live in the ATX...so I like the the college game more too. I like the process of recruiting more than signing FA. Just me.

[johntom2000]

Re: Which is better, NCAA or Madden?

i have and play both and would say NCAA is better because i like the NFL better and the recruiting is very fun and stuff. madden their is not much new stuff to add to it. when you get to the season all it is is playing games but NCAA you get to recruit and stuff. also the NCAA offseason is funner.

I agree with you. but, I like NFL better but, I love option football so...

[JAYMO76]

Re: Which is better, NCAA or Madden?

This competition is like a nine year old choosing brussel sprouts versus cauliflower. Sure he will choose one but either way he's not going to like it. NCAA and Madden are still weak as compared to last gen.

[thdudeabides]

Re: Which is better, NCAA or Madden?

NCAA, by the nose of a football. When the 2nd Patch is released for Madden it could be a different story.

[koebner]

Re: Which is better, NCAA or Madden?

NCAA, by the nose of a football. When the 2nd Patch is released for Madden it could be a different story.

+1

[hcopenhagenh]

Re: Which is better, NCAA or Madden?

Here is the right answer.... THEY BOTH SUCK. Madden sucks more than NCAA.