I agree with ya Baa.
I also...along with many/most others have known for years that the player ratings just don't mean what they should. With the exception of speed. I suppose people seeing video proof of it, really drives the point home for many.
And like you Baa...I doubt Madden is the only offender. I'm just an idiot behind a keyboard....what the hell do I know? But I have my doubts this issue will truly be addressed until possibly the next gen of sports games. To where the player ratings, will be truly meaningful. Jmo.