Whats better nfl 2k5 or all pro football 2k8- 2k fans please help

[vaibhavp3]

can you please tell me which one is better overall thanks:wink:

[The Otrain]

Re: Whats better nfl 2k5 or all pro football 2k8- 2k fans please help

Depends on what you want. If the "real" NFL is what matters, go with 2K5. Presentation is top notch. AllPro is good for playing but doesn't have the NFL license.

[sb24]

Re: Whats better nfl 2k5 or all pro football 2k8- 2k fans please help

can you please tell me which one is better thanks:wink:

Which one is "better" is all subjective. However the on the field gameplay is better with 2k8. Everything else 2k5.

[vaibhavp3]

Re: Whats better nfl 2k5 or all pro football 2k8- 2k fans please help

Which one is "better" is all subjective. However the on the field gameplay is better with 2k8. Everything else 2k5.

thanks for the post, does nfl 2k5 have a franchise mode like madden cause i never played nfl 2k5 cause i might get nfl 2k5 or all pro 2k8.:wink:

[tomymac23]

Re: Whats better nfl 2k5 or all pro football 2k8- 2k fans please help

Honestly why not get both it will cost you all of 6 bucks! No doubt that's what I did and I enjoy them both.

[vaibhavp3]

Re: Whats better nfl 2k5 or all pro football 2k8- 2k fans please help

Honestly why not get both it will cost you all of 6 bucks! No doubt that's what I did and I enjoy them both.

yh i might as well do that:wink:

[pepsiclock]

Re: Whats better nfl 2k5 or all pro football 2k8- 2k fans please help

well i just bought 2k8 and its a nice step foward. the animation is more realistic and the graphics when your viewing replays look real nice. but just after a few games i never played it again, even though its better young to rice gets boring fast.

[kingkilla56]

Re: Whats better nfl 2k5 or all pro football 2k8- 2k fans please help

Get them both, 2 games equals like 8 bucks.

[murdamann10]

Re: Whats better nfl 2k5 or all pro football 2k8- 2k fans please help

I like to do franchise mode mostly, so 2k5 gets my vote. I play APF 2k8 at my friend's house, and I love the gameplay. So really, its really about what you want. 2k5 has all the bells and whistles that a NFL game comes with. 2k8 comes with what I like to call closest to perfect gameplay.