Madden NFL Arcade Review - Operation Sports Forums

Madden NFL Arcade Review

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • RaychelSnr
    Executive Editor
    • Jan 2007
    • 4846

    #1

    Madden NFL Arcade Review

    It’s sometimes easy to forget that video games are a business like any other -- run, not by consumers, but by corporations and shareholders.

    Like many businesses outside of the video-game industry, many game companies have recently been forced to downsize their range of products to all but the safest, most essential wares.

    For many sports gaming companies, the "arcade" department seems to have been the first group to receive its pink slip in these tough economic times. Fans of the genre have recently seen franchises like EA’s Street games or Midway’s classic Blitz and Jam titles either completely abandoned by the parent company or given little more than a low-risk, low-budget sequel.

    But despite EA shutting down its Street brand and taking a year off to reassess its approach to the genre, EA’s relaunched arcade sports department still does not seem to have learned from the mistakes it was making earlier this generation with games like NBA Street Homecourt or NFL Tour, i.e., releasing half-baked sequels that fail to match the modes or features of their last-gen counterparts.

    EA’s 3 on 3 NHL Arcade, the company’s first shot to recapture some of its past arcade glory (Mutant League Hockey, anyone?), ended up being a fun but shallow experience that wasted a great hockey engine on a game that was completely bereft of modes or features -- to the point that 3 on 3 NHL Arcade felt more like a mini-game that should have been included on the NHL 09 disc instead of a standalone downloadable game.

    The nine months since 3 on 3 NHL Arcade was released does not seem to have taught EA any major lessons. I say that because Madden NFL Arcade is another feature-thin game that, at its $15 asking price, does not seem to justify its status as a full, arcade release. In reality, it’s little more than mini-game that has been lifted from the "arcade mode" included in Madden 10 for the Wii.

    Read More - Madden NFL Arcade Review
    OS Executive Editor
    Check out my blog here at OS. Add me on Twitter.
  • JkA3
    Strategy
    • Jul 2008
    • 858

    #2
    Not great!
    STRATEGYHUSTLERESULTS

    Comment

    • nbluedevils
      Rookie
      • Sep 2008
      • 52

      #3
      While I certainly agree that the game was overpriced, I think that this review fails to touch on some of the more successful aspects of the game. For example, while the gameplay may be overly simplistic for a Madden veteran, it is a great way to introduce beginners to the Madden experience. I have had several friends who refuse to play Madden 10, yet have had a lot of fun with Madden Arcade. In addition, the gameplay is very well-rooted in strategy: when to employ powerups and how to catch your opponents off-guard with your play calling certainly plays a large role in the game. In addition, unlike most Arcade games, scoring is not a given and effective defense can be played.

      You have to realize that Madden Arcade is not for your typical OS user. You will not have progression (a la Franchise Mode), there will be limited roster updates, and you will not find nearly the depth in features found in Madden 10. However, if you are looking for a quality, pick-up-and-play sports game or just another way to play Madden with non-sports-gaming friends, there isn't really a better option on the market.

      As always, give the trial a try if you have an Xbox and see if you like it for yourself. I can easily say that I have gotten more than $15 worth of entertainment out of this limited, yet fun game.

      Comment

      • dave374
        Banned
        • Feb 2003
        • 1933

        #4
        I think 5.5 is too low a score.
        It is what it is - a fun game.
        Is it too expensive? Yes ... but it's not a 5.5 game.
        I would give it a 7.5

        Comment

        • bang911
          Pro
          • Jun 2004
          • 616

          #5
          I honestly believe this should of been included in Madden 10 for free, just like it was on the Wii. This should be an in-game mode and nothing more. If they ever add new animations/plays/sounds/hits/graphics then maybe it deserves to be a $15 download.

          Comment

          • MrNFL_FanIQ
            MVP
            • Oct 2008
            • 4675

            #6
            Wait, isn't regular Madden basically the same as Madden arcade?

            (I joke, I joke. Please don't ban me! lol)

            Comment

            • roadman
              *ll St*r
              • Aug 2003
              • 26431

              #7
              Re: Madden NFL Arcade Review

              Originally posted by MrNFL_FanIQ
              Wait, isn't regular Madden basically the same as Madden arcade?

              (I joke, I joke. Please don't ban me! lol)
              That's a new one, haven't heard that one before.

              Comment

              • ezio
                MVP
                • Jun 2003
                • 2853

                #8
                I agree with Dave I would give it about a 7.5 as well. It is a fun game. Maybe it should have been $10 instead but it is fun.

                Comment

                • swill43507
                  Banned
                  • Aug 2003
                  • 831

                  #9
                  Re: Madden NFL Arcade Review

                  Yeah Madden Arcade should have just been an game option mode included into Madden 10.

                  Comment

                  • ghm125
                    john14:6
                    • Jul 2002
                    • 2439

                    #10
                    4.99 tops,but hey I enjoy it...
                    VIOLATION!!!!!!!!

                    Comment

                    • Nature_Boy
                      16 Time World Champion
                      • Jun 2003
                      • 930

                      #11
                      Re: Madden NFL Arcade Review

                      I've been playing it since release day last week and I enjoy it. It's a nice chance of pace. I can't argue too much about the price. I bought all three NFL Street games and NFL Tour for full price back in the day.

                      Comment

                      • jyoung
                        Hall Of Fame
                        • Dec 2006
                        • 11157

                        #12
                        If price is not an issue to you and you have some friends to play locally, I can see getting some fun out of the game.

                        But for everyone else, I think this one's a bit of a bust. No single player value, no stat tracking, online play is full of quitters and cheesers, etc.

                        EA could be doing so much more with these games, but instead, they're just content to put out what's basically a minigame with (bad) online play.

                        Comment

                        • econoodle
                          MVP
                          • Sep 2009
                          • 4885

                          #13
                          is it better than Tour? lol

                          Comment

                          • superstarshad
                            Rookie
                            • Aug 2009
                            • 36

                            #14
                            They need to bring back NFL street. NFL tour reminded me of something the cat puked up.

                            Comment

                            • MC Fatigue
                              Banned
                              • Feb 2006
                              • 4153

                              #15
                              This could be a great game with some halfway decent AI and some more options. The offline mode is worthless because the AI is just absolutely pathetic. Too bad I had to buy the game to find that out.

                              Comment

                              Working...