[DonkeyJote]

Quote: Originally Posted by vaibhavp3

in madden i see QB like Peyton manning have tackle ratings, tell me any QB who has practiced tackling drills. same for CB, why do they have QB accuracy and trow power like there going to play QB.this goes for mostly all positions. so what's your opinion on this do you think a player overall rating be based on the player's position rating or how it is right know.

I don't think changing Peyton's tackle rating is going to affect his overall.

Some QB's are better at tackling than other. They do practice it, though not as intensely, obviously, as defensive players. And not all CB's throw equally well. But the throw ratings don't affect their overall. The only things that affect overall ratings are positional ratings relevant to the position they play. So it's already the way you want, so the poll is pointless.