I think you misunderstood my point a bit. I mean that in many circumstances where I devised (brilliant if I say so myself) schemes to get pressure on the qb and give the qb no room to step up and make a pass with my pass rushers right there about to hit him, the qb quick throw or not makes a very strong accurate throw despite the pressure. The only reward I get is a quicker thorw or an animation of the qb adjusting, but the throw itself is just as strong and accurate despite the pressure.
Which is why I brung up All Pro as an example of where they got it right to an extent. NFL 2k5 had the composure rating but it did not work right. I would like madden to do it the way All Pro did it.