It's not just you, and yes, this is a Red Wings fan agreeing with a Penguins lover. Haha.
It's the same formula over and over and over again. Playing FIFA 10 (which is my sports title of the year, BTW) made me realize just how unique each individual player is in that game, and how incredibly similar every player in NHL is. Not just similar in the sense that they're all rated 70-100 OVR, but that there aren't enough ratings that actually mean something in gameplay.
In a basketball game (like 2k10), the players ratings are going to give me a sense of my ability to maneuver with the ball, my range in shooting, and the types of finishes I'll use at the net. In soccer (like FIFA 10), there's not only speed, shooting, and dribbling ability, but accuracy on different types of passes (like throughs and crosses), balance, strength, ability in the air, and how these all interact with one another when taking a particular action.
In NHL 10, the better players are a little bit faster than the crappier players, shoot a little harder, and miss the net less frequently. That's about it. In fact, take Sidney Crosby towards the end of a shift in NHL 10, and he plays almost exactly the same as somebody like Kris Draper would at the beginning of a shift. There's no special abilities, difference in shot release, or significant difference anywhere else that explains why one is a Hart candidate, and the other is an aging role player.


Comment