Official Rate My Trade Thread

[chezzie11]

Re: Official Rate My Trade Thread

Personally, I think you paid you much.

[chokokoko]

Re: Official Rate My Trade Thread

OKC Trades:

Big man:

Greg Oden for Kristic & 11 1st round

PG:

T. Evans for Westbrook & 10 1st round pick

I think Evans will turn out to be bigger than Westbrook

[The_Patriot_12]

Re: Official Rate My Trade Thread

I am the Grizzlies and i want a good defensive minded center. Would it be fair/realistic to trade marc gasol 76 ovr. for greg oden 75 ovr. or joakim noah 73 ovr.

[iRepOklahoma]

Re: Official Rate My Trade Thread

OKC Trades:

Big man:

Greg Oden for Kristic & 11 1st round

PG:

T. Evans for Westbrook & 10 1st round pick

I think Evans will turn out to be bigger than Westbrook

Neither is fair. You gave up too much for Evans and got waaaay too much for Nenad. Center's like Kristic are a dime a dozen. If Portland wanted a Nenad type player, they'd sign him and keep Oden too. 2011 OKC first rounder is nothing either

[Comduklakis]

Re: Official Rate My Trade Thread

I'm OKC. Its year two. The heat have signed Boozer, and are playing Beasley at the 3.

OKC Trades:
Jeff Green
Kyle Weaver
2011 1st rnder

MIA Trades:
Michael Beasley

I'd edit Jeff Green to his natural 3 position, which gives him a 79 rating. The Heat don't have a real 3, and are using Beasley. I don't have a real 4, and Im using Green. Is this going to be fair? (assuming they even accept it)

Too much for Beasley. He's not an all star in the game and IRL he's absolutely been going backwards in the last month. I expect his ratings to drop in the next roster update. However I understand why you did it. I had the Heat sign Boozer and tried Boozer at C with Beasley at PF and it tanked. So I tried Beasley at SF and inserted Joel Anthony at C just to rebound (O'neal was gone). That failed miserably too. Boozer and Beasley just didn't play well together. I would say that Weaver and Green is probably fair for Beasley without the pick.

[Comduklakis]

Re: Official Rate My Trade Thread

OKC Trades:

Big man:

Greg Oden for Kristic & 11 1st round

PG:

T. Evans for Westbrook & 10 1st round pick

I think Evans will turn out to be bigger than Westbrook

Not recommended. I've simmed through several assocations for a few years and Tyreke never develops into the star you think he will. 18 and 7 is about what he peaks at each time. Westbrook on the other hand has been rated as high as 3rd in the league for efficiency for an entire season. So for 2k, I actually think Westbrook has consistently developed into the superior player.

[chokokoko]

Re: Official Rate My Trade Thread

Not recommended. I've simmed through several assocations for a few years and Tyreke never develops into the star you think he will. 18 and 7 is about what he peaks at each time. Westbrook on the other hand has been rated as high as 3rd in the league for efficiency for an entire season. So for 2k, I actually think Westbrook has consistently developed into the superior player.

I thought the same after a couple of games. Anyway being from Chicago I started a new association with the bulls. I needed a SG so I did the following trade:

Chicago trade:

Hinrich & Noah & 11 1st round pick

Memphis trade:

Mayo & Thabeet

This way I get a SG and a potential 7.3 ft player to develop

Mayo by the way has been a beast scoring 23-25 pts / game

[marktg30]

Re: Official Rate My Trade Thread

I thought the same after a couple of games. Anyway being from Chicago I started a new association with the bulls. I needed a SG so I did the following trade:

Chicago trade:

Hinrich & Noah & 11 1st round pick

Memphis trade:

Mayo & Thabeet

This way I get a SG and a potential 7.3 ft player to develop

Mayo by the way has been a beast scoring 23-25 pts / game

You robbed them... lol... nice

[mvspree8]

Re: Official Rate My Trade Thread

I thought the same after a couple of games. Anyway being from Chicago I started a new association with the bulls. I needed a SG so I did the following trade:

Chicago trade:

Hinrich & Noah & 11 1st round pick

Memphis trade:

Mayo & Thabeet

This way I get a SG and a potential 7.3 ft player to develop

Mayo by the way has been a beast scoring 23-25 pts / game

You robbed them... lol... nice

I'm not sure that IRL that's really robbery. Noah is arguably the second best player on the Bulls and is one of the best rebounders in the league. Hinrich is a great fit for Memphis with his versatility. The Bulls get a great scorer and a C that has a LONG ways to go. I'd be cool with this deal.

[Danny McCoy]

Re: Official Rate My Trade Thread

Tell me what you guys think of this trade. I'm the Heat in the 1st season of my association and we are currently 3-6 in a 29 game season. I signed Ilgauskus at the beginning of the season from free agency. I made this trade just to get a little more rebounding and long range shooting from my bench.

Heat trade:
Ilgauskus (Mav's)
Q. Richardson (Cav's)
M. Bonner (Mav's)
2nd rnd pick- from spurs (Mav's)

Mav's trade:
E. Dampier (Heat)

Cav's trade:
A. Parker (Heat)
2nd rnd pick (Heat)

[chokokoko]

Re: Official Rate My Trade Thread

I'm not sure that IRL that's really robbery. Noah is arguably the second best player on the Bulls and is one of the best rebounders in the league. Hinrich is a great fit for Memphis with his versatility. The Bulls get a great scorer and a C that has a LONG ways to go. I'd be cool with this deal.

Actually Thabeet has a long way to go. So I need a C or a big PF.

I am thinking trading T. Gibson and 2nd pick for A. Blatche from the wizards.

Any suggestions?

[marktg30]

Re: Official Rate My Trade Thread

Just pulled off two nice trades... One I offered.. the other was via trading block.

I am the T-Wolves

My offer -

PG - Sessions (70 OVR) to Denver

SG - JR Smith (70 OVR) to Minnesota


Placed Ryan Gomes (66 OVR) On Trading Block and Got this offer:...

Ron Artest (80) and Luke Walton (66)

[cubsball899]

Re: Official Rate My Trade Thread

LOL @ some of these OKC trades on here.... green for beasley? really? no idea why you would want beasley over green... but i can live with that i suppose....

westbrook for tyreke? no no no no no lol westbrook is the better player in the game and IRL he gets overshadowed cause he's playing with durant.... tyreke is an awesome talent... but SAC had to ship kevin martin because tyreke isn't a point guard lol

and why on god's green earth would you want oj mayo over james harden? better yet why would either team make that trade? james harden is bigger scores in the paint better and is perfectly suited for the 6th man role for OKC as he can slide down and spell durant at the 3 for short periods

[Danny McCoy]

Re: Official Rate My Trade Thread

Haven't made this trade yet but I am the Miami Heat and i need a little more rebounding from my starting center.

Heat (me) trade:
M. Beasley(Blazer's)
Sefolosha (Blazer's)
1st rnd pick (Blazer's)

Blazer's trade:
G. Oden (Heat)
R. Fernandez (Heat)

What do u guy think of this trade? Any other variations of this trade you suggest?

[marktg30]

Re: Official Rate My Trade Thread

Haven't made this trade yet but I am the Miami Heat and i need a little more rebounding from my starting center.

Heat (me) trade:
J. O'neal (Cav's)
2nd rnd pick (Cav's)

Cav's trade:
S. O'neal (Heat)
D. Gibson (Heat)

What do u guy think of this trade? Any other variations of this trade you suggest?

I would go after Hickson before Shaq. Giving up any sort of Draft pick for Gibson isnt worth it either. You will most likely have a good chance at getting a better player than him in the 2nd Rd.