All time best NCAA game

[johnnysnaps]

I was just wanting feedback on what you guys think is the best created NCAA game (ps2 and next gen) based off of the gun game. This could be judged on effectiveness of the run block, blocking schemes, importance of recruiting dominant O-lines, and reasonable end of season pancake totals.
Maybe not an interesting topic for most but for an O-line junkie I find it very interesting and would like to get the best possible Ncaa game based on line play and recruiting. I love the 2k blocking schemes and have yet to find anything like it. I would like to find the next best option though for the NCAA series. It could be 360 or ps2.

thanks

[johnnysnaps]

Re: All time best NCAA game

In addition:
What years kept actual stats on pancakes. I remember the years of having lineman with 50+ pancakes. It was a lot of fun

[Sting]

Re: All time best NCAA game

If you're looking for importance of dominant o-linemen and recruiting dominant o-linemen then you definitely have to go with 2003. Hands down.

[johnnysnaps]

Re: All time best NCAA game

How does 06 stack up??

[Rocky]

Re: All time best NCAA game

Between '03 and '06.

[moylan1234]

Re: All time best NCAA game

'10 for 360 hoping for '11

[Tick32]

Re: All time best NCAA game

between 05 and 07 last gen

[simgamer0005]

Re: All time best NCAA game

NCAA Football 2005 on PS2. Most well rounded and balanced football game ever.

[johnnysnaps]

Re: All time best NCAA game

I am looking to run the zone read where I can actually read the backside DE, which is impossible in the next gen games because the blocking schemes are so screwed up.

My question is: IN Ncaa 2006 do they have the full zone play. I believe they called it HB Read in that years playbook? WIth the HB read play the O-line actually full zoned to the playside. Alot of people did not like this play but I had alot of success with it.

Last question:
What last gen (xbox) games are compatible for the x box 360?

[Solidice]

Re: All time best NCAA game

Last question:
What last gen (xbox) games are compatible for the x box 360?

only '06.

[UCFTirade]

Re: All time best NCAA game

I played the hell out of '09, which I thought overall was good for the 360...Also probably due to last year of undergrad and classes were done..Before that I give it up to 06 on the PS2. rather difficult game at times pretty fast paced as well. Stadium intensity was there as well.

[WIAggie]

Re: All time best NCAA game

For me the best is NCAA 10..hands down

[Stunna2006]

Re: All time best NCAA game

ncaa 10. no question. in my online dynasty we play humans 6 games a year in the big east tho i'm not sure how the AI would hold up

[lav]

Re: All time best NCAA game

Between 10 and 06 for me.

NCAA 10 has the edge. The supersim feature, graphics, and moving classes to Madden 10 (favorite Madden in years) has me involved in my longest running dynasty ever on NCAA. I'm in 2019 w/ the Wolverines right now. I started w/ U of M and it's kept my interest even w/ staying w/ them for the duration.

[coogrfan]

Re: All time best NCAA game

NCAA Football 2005 on PS2. Most well rounded and balanced football game ever.

Wasn't that the one with the excessive drops and beach ball physics for tipped passes?