As a huge fan of The Show for the last 3 years I would like to see something like analog pitching and hitting like in 2K and maybe even fielding for next year as an option.
Key word being OPTION. Don't force people to use it and I think it should be an option for each aspect of the game. Like someone might want analog hitting but still want to use the button metered pitching or vice versa.
I also remember I think MVP 06 used the analog for throwing to certain bases and if you didn't hit it right the throw could sale or be wide.
In video games though, more options are always better and I am one who probably wouldn't even use analog controls and I love the way it works now but who knows....