Madden NFL 11 and Madden NFL 10 Screenshot Comparison: Philip Rivers

[xNYGx]

Re: Madden NFL 11 and Madden NFL 10 Screenshot Comparison: Philip Rivers

Not sure what's considered art, but I wish this effort would have gone into sidelines & crowds. The players already looked great.

But I'm with the folks that say leave the graphics alone. I know, I know, different folks work on different aspects of the game. Well, reassign the art folks to gameplay and KIM.

http://www.operationsports.com/forum...post2040898038

[Only1LT]

Re: Madden NFL 11 and Madden NFL 10 Screenshot Comparison: Philip Rivers

The 11 screenshot obviously looks better. Great strides on the textures in 11 with respect to the jersey. Looks much more like fabric in 11. Skin looks more realistic as well.

Just a guess, but I would say that the polygon count for the player models has been upped as well.

All of this is fine and well, but for me, where Madden's graphics are most lacking is with the player models themselves. This has been a weakness, not just of Madden, but of most EA Sports games, for as long as they have been making them. Doesn't matter if the team changes either, the player models have always been too skinny and had heads that were a little too large. Marionette limbs as well.

When they address that, then we will have something. Until then, no matter how much tweaking they do, the players will just look like photo-realistic caricatures.

[Only1LT]

Re: Madden NFL 11 and Madden NFL 10 Screenshot Comparison: Philip Rivers

I'm not reading all the posts, but I've already seen a few complaints about QB's looking thinner than they should. If they paid attention in the past, they'd know why QB's don't quite look right in Madden.

I suppose most people aren't aware that Flak-Jackets haven't been in Madden on Next-Gen. Some may not even know what a Flak-Jacket is. For those unaware, "Flak-Jackets" are a piece of equipment most QB's in the league wear to protect themselves from the blows they take. The padding is a bit above the waist, and gives the QB a "bigger" look.

So stop complaining about the size of the players. The QB's would look fine if they had the Flak-Jackets in the game. I believe it's something they're looking to get into this years game, since they didn't have time to get it in last years.

Flak-Jacket:


Flak-Jacket in NCAA Football:


Big Ben IRL:


Big Ben in Madden:

Madden's player model issues have absolutely nothing to do with a lack of a flak jacket. The player models across the board are off and always have been.

[Only1LT]

Re: Madden NFL 11 and Madden NFL 10 Screenshot Comparison: Philip Rivers

Nobody ever seems to get this.

There are 22 players on the field at all times in football. There's only 10 in baseball (if we're not counting the refs/umpires, the guy on deck, and the 1st/3rd base coach). Rendering 22 players in high resolution takes up more resources than 10 players. That's part of why SCEA is capable of putting out a beautiful game year in and year out. They have the extra space to work with, unlike Madden.

Ever notice the dull sidelines in Madden? That's because almost all of the resources are poured onto the field, giving Madden a great graphical look. If you've played APF, you can see the hit graphics take when rendering more than 22 interactive player models at one time. APF has interactive sidelines, which is awesome. But the graphics are far from stellar. In a thread a long time ago, I recall Ian posing a question to the community asking if they'd be willing to give up a little on graphics, to gain in other areas. I will attempt to find the thread for you guys.
*Found the post - http://www.operationsports.com/forum...post2039288579 *

If EA wasn't going to be put at risk by consumers for losing graphical value in Madden, then they would be able to do a lot more with the game.

I understand your point but to compare APF is totally unfair. The game was a budget title that did not have all of the resources allotted to it that it would have had if it were an NFL Licensed game. They knew that the market for the type of game that they were allowed to make would not be anywhere near as large as their NFL 2k market.

Second, that game came out 3yrs ago. You are basically talking about a launch title. There is no telling what they could do if they actually tried to make a game that could compete with Madden on even terms. Especially considering that a lot of their time on the first game was spent on making a next gen engine. Just look at the difference between Madden 06 and Madden 10 or 11 even.

Come on now.

[stateprop]

how about focusing on gameplay EA

[NavigatorD83]

2K has always been better at Madden to bringing a true Broadcast feel. I would really like it if Madden did the same and It sounds like they are. Werent some of 2K's people joining the M11 team?

[boltsfan92]

maybe Madden needs to work omore on NFL jerseys on the look thats not even close to how the real Chargers jersey looks the real one need to have a white collar

[BisonPride]

If you look closely at the helmet you will in the 10 pic four banks of stadium lights meaning that the pic was from a night game. The pic from 11 is in sunlight. ITS GOING TO BE BETTER LIGHTING! I think the comparison with Rivers is much more accurate.

[NavigatorD83]

http://hawkfantasysports.files.wordpress.com/2009/08/philip-rivers.jpg
I wish they would make all the uniforms look correct. Its really noticeable

[FunNgun034]

how about gameplay and actual pass rush... and good offensive line play... who gives a $%#@@ about how good a player looks .. iI dont zoom in on faces and look at graphics it will always be about the gameplay.

[NavigatorD83]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XqFTt-IGCus

I know its old but I cant get over the animation of the QB running and then throwing a bomb. It looks so good

[TreFacTor]

Definitely looks crisper, but my concerns are the bugs and glitches that plague the game each year. What about the physics, the missing elements of actual NFL football, blocking, cheating AI, morphing / sliding players, the 360 arm swing, those things concern me more than the graphics. Only time will tell.