MLB '10: The Show Rosters: OS Full Minors V.1

[Anavar]

Re: MLB '10: The Show Rosters: OS Full Minors V.1

You guys are the freaking best!

[yyhy]

Re: MLB '10: The Show Rosters: OS Full Minors V.1

Majority or not, it doesn't make sense to have pitches next when it changes the gameplay more than stances, equipment. Equipment, stances do not change playing the game much. Changing most the 4 steam fastballs to running, sinkers, 2 FB instead changes the game much more.

If anything, should be corrections to the file like who is where, then struts changes, then pitching changes.

I guess some people don't like the pitch/stamina edits

[RedsManRick]

Re: MLB '10: The Show Rosters: OS Full Minors V.1

Great work guys, I believe David Weathers being on the Reds (he's not) has already been mentioned, but a few other Reds notes:

- Danny Ray Herrera throws a screwball. He should probably have that instead of the 12-6 curve.
- Paul Janish's fielding attributes are way too low. He's legitimately a top 10 defensive SS in baseball -- he just can't hit a lick.
- Drew Stubbs is also being short-changed defensively.
- Neftali Soto will be playing C a few times a week in an attempt to convert him. Should have C as a secondary position
- Extremely nitpicky (I know!), but against LHP w/ DH, Dickerson should be in LF with Gomes DHing
- Please leave Fransisco down and Leake up -- that will most likely be what happens when Leake comes up on the 15th.

Overall, it's look real great. Thank you so much for your hard work. I wish the best to Knight and his family concerns.

[abcabc]

Re: MLB '10: The Show Rosters: OS Full Minors V.1

Versions to come (as far as I know)
V1 - Out there already'
V2 - will include all faces done and minor league lineup cleanup edits
V2.1 (?) - will include Strut's equipment / stance edits
V2.2 (?) - all above with Razr and Pope's pitch (and stamina) edits
V2.3 (?) - all above with myself and ThirdDegree most SCEA created players pitcher (non-pitch / stamina edit i.e. H/9, BB/9 etc) and hitter (all except throwing) attributes re-rated using Bahnzo's roster tool 3 year average (2007 - 2009 non-weighted).

yo thanks alot for this outline, read through many pages of this thread, maybe it should be on the first page of this thread.


Me personally, though maybe others agree... would have loved to see game play aspects released before visual aspects like below.... maybe next year.

V1 - Out thereready'
V2 - (?) - Razr and Pope's pitch (and stamina) edits
V2.1 (?) - myself and ThirdDegree most SCEA created players pitcher (non-pitch / stamina edit i.e. H/9, BB/9 etc) and hitter (all except throwing) attributes re-rated using Bahnzo's roster tool 3 year average (2007 - 2009 non-weighted).
v2.x (?) - Strut's equipment / stance edits
v2.x (?) - will include all faces done and minor league lineup cleanup edits

[brettryantalley]

Re: MLB '10: The Show Rosters: OS Full Minors V.1

dang....really interested to see what this looks like with Bahnzo's ratings, but not sure i can wait that long.

[abcabc]

Re: MLB '10: The Show Rosters: OS Full Minors V.1

After this version is fixed can I make a request that the pitch/stamina edits be the next thing edited? I know everyone (myself included) wants the equipment edits, but as far as realism and gameplay I (personal opinion) think the stamina/pitch edits should take precedence.

Not gonna say my opinion means everything, but I'm wondering if the majority would feel like this?

just read your opinion after i posted mine. i'm with you. the pitch/stamina edits are a change to the game towards realism and i'm for that. harder? likely but again, takes realism up a notch from what SCEA does.

[Bedard4CY]

Re: MLB '10: The Show Rosters: OS Full Minors V.1

Couple things about the A's I noticed.

1) Edgar Gonzalez isn't in the organization anymore, they never re-signed him after last year, and he's the 8th best pitcher on the A's in the roster.
2) Andrew Carignan is a reliever, if not a closer. I'm pretty sure he never made a switch to a starter.
3) Jonathan Joseph throws a slider, not a curveball as his 3rd pitch.
4) James Simmons is a starter, and throws a cutter/curve/change.
EDIT: Simmons is Caucasian, you have him as black in the game.
5) No Curtis Thigpen?
6) Sean Doolittle is treated like garbage, he was a force in '08 and had a bad year in '09, no reason to make him one of the worst players on the team.
7) No jason Fernandez.

[dorismary]

Re: MLB '10: The Show Rosters: OS Full Minors V.1

MK ,
I dont wanna bother you with PMs at this time but I have already started Full gear Edits from head to toe on this V.1 set as many stances and edit are subjective IMO.
I also fixed 40-50 players numbers , secondary pos and stuff like adjusting a few teams real 25 man roster ,Hughes more stamia and Edmonds being a lefty throw ect .
So Pm me if you wanna a copy and as always my prayers are with you and your family !
Once again great job guys .

[ether]

Re: MLB '10: The Show Rosters: OS Full Minors V.1

There were a couple small transactions since this came out and I'm fairly new to the game so...I went in the player movement screen to move Robbie Hammock from Col to NYY and I can't for the life of me figure out how to actually move him. Even the help screen says nothing other than to press x to highlight the player. Are you not allowed to move a single player from one team to another, does their have to be a player coming back? I can't figure it out.

[andrewz23308]

Re: MLB '10: The Show Rosters: OS Full Minors V.1

Is there anyone that would be willing to post what jersey# need to be changed for the major league teams?

[DustinT]

Re: MLB '10: The Show Rosters: OS Full Minors V.1

Great work on these guys!

Just fyi, Dustin Ackley for the M's is a 2b, not 1b

[dorismary]

Re: MLB '10: The Show Rosters: OS Full Minors V.1

Is there anyone that would be willing to post what jersey# need to be changed for the major league teams?

I only remember a few Holiday #7 , G. Anderson 9 , Johnson 5 both LAD , Jackson Det 14 and Detriot as a team had alot of wrong numbers , E Carsildad sp cubs and around 40 others I cant remember as I went thru each 25 man roster but pm me if you want my copy as its basically the same as this original with all the things mention here plus #s , correct 25 man rosters and im adjusting alot of players positiions and just started gear which is a task but so worth it .

[mjsthebest]

Re: MLB '10: The Show Rosters: OS Full Minors V.1

MK ,
I dont wanna bother you with PMs at this time but I have already started Full gear Edits from head to toe on this V.1 set as many stances and edit are subjective IMO.
I also fixed 40-50 players numbers , secondary pos and stuff like adjusting a few teams real 25 man roster ,Hughes more stamia and Edmonds being a lefty throw ect .
So Pm me if you wanna a copy and as always my prayers are with you and your family !
Once again great job guys .

any chance you could post all your changes, or maybe post your roster?

[mccutchisclutch]

Re: MLB '10: The Show Rosters: OS Full Minors V.1

I have hardly noticed any lineup problems with the roster, if I have seen a few differences they haven't been that big of a deal. Great work, appreciate it as always.

[Thielcats]

Re: MLB '10: The Show Rosters: OS Full Minors V.1

I have hardly noticed any lineup problems with the roster, if I have seen a few differences they haven't been that big of a deal. Great work, appreciate it as always.

If you play as the Pirates, the Dodgers batted Furcal 5th and Huroda started 2 days in a row