View Single Post
Old 04-08-2010, 11:07 PM   #462
TheRunAndShoot
MVP
 
OVR: 18
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: The Emerald City
Re: MLB '10: The Show Rosters: OS Full Minors V.1

Quote:
Originally Posted by Knight165
Yep.
Jay...the file you wanted us to use...had all the A's and B's already set up by you....so unless you sent us the wrong base set....

Problem is...there is VERY little wiggle room. I steal a C from somewhere else....those guys are unhappy....steal one from somewhere else...those guys are unhappy....vicious cycle.
When you start your franchise...there are some new editable guys added to the FA list.....you guys could use those.

M.K.
Knight165
If you need an A pot pitcher. Steal Kanekoa Texeira from the Mariners, he can be a B/C.

I know positional players w/good potential are scarce but for the M's...

Catcher
Steve Baron- needs to be at least a C potential.
Travis Howell- should be changed to Trevor Coleman. Both are single-A guys but Coleman has far more going for him. Howell's a 25 year old stuck in single A.

1st Base
Rich Poythress- Not sure how he didn't make it into the game. He's a better prospect than Carp (yes i know he's scea).
Dustin Ackley- Needs to be moved here from 1st base. I'm sure it was just an oversight on your guys end.

2nd Base
Gambriel Noriega-
He's a switch hitter. I'd like to see him at C potential but I understand.

3B

Matt Mangini- Replaced with Pedro Okuda.

SS
Carlos Triunfel
- Move him to 3B with SS as a secondary pos.

LF
Brad Nelson- He played mostly 1B in the spring. LF is a backup pos. I know you guys want accurate minors but you might consider dumping him in favor of editing in a prospect.
Guillermo Pimentel- Needs to be added. Just google him. Was seen as a top 5 IFA this past year.

CF
Carlos Peguero-
OK prospect but I'd like to see him swapped with Johermyn Chavez. Who's a RF.
James McOwen- Outside of his hitstreak the guy is nothing noteable. Replace with George Drullard

RF
Julio Morban-
Should be a CF projects as a LF. From what I've read he's a high upside guy, fast, and could be a leadoff hitter one day in the majors. I'd do some research on him b/c he looks like a good prospect.








Corey Patterson- Was released at the end of spring training. This opens up a spot. Use him to get Pimentel into the game. Needs to be a B/C potential guy.



I can critique pitchers over the weekend but I don't have the time right now. Hope you take my advice to heart... Keep up the good work guys!!!
__________________
Cosmetic Guides to the Show v2 Rosters

STANCE GUIDE
http://bit.ly/HtkpmT
MOTION GUIDE
http://bit.ly/IqkdGh
TheRunAndShoot is offline