NCAA Football 11 Video: First Look at Presentation Upgrades

[SageInfinite]

Re: NCAA Football 11 Video: First Look at Presentation Upgrades

I'm a champion of complaining about NCAA, BUT you're wrong. Matter of fact, name me one game that uses REAL TV presentation on replays. NBA 2K's replays are GREAT, but they aren't what you see in a real game, nor are the replays from The Show.

It's a videogame, and sometiems "unrealistic" stuff comes off better than if they were to do it exactly the way its done in real life.

NBA 2k10's replays are exactly what you see on TV.

[Solidice]

Re: NCAA Football 11 Video: First Look at Presentation Upgrades

while I don't hate the new replay angles, I do think it's zoomed in a little too far. in the videos from thezoneblitz.com, there was a replay that was so zoomed in, you couldn't even see the ball being thrown. then it kept swapping camera angles so fast you couldn't really get a good look at what was happening.

hopefully the replay system is being tweaked here and there.

there was also a butt shot of a ref when he was signaling a first down(I think it was the same video). why? I don't want to see the ref's butt.

[Bigdmo9999]

Re: NCAA Football 11 Video: First Look at Presentation Upgrades

Here stoncold, watch

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pS5rTvpTDaw

Realistic cameras are used in this whole video

[SageInfinite]

Re: NCAA Football 11 Video: First Look at Presentation Upgrades

Here stoncold, watch

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pS5rTvpTDaw

Realistic cameras are used in this whole video

While this is 1 of EA's better efforts, NBA 2k10 is still the best representation of an actual broadcast.

[stoncold32]

Re: NCAA Football 11 Video: First Look at Presentation Upgrades

NBA 2k10's replays are exactly what you see on TV.

Here stoncold, watch

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pS5rTvpTDaw

Realistic cameras are used in this whole video

No, neither of them are 100% real IMO, they're just alot closer than what we've seen thus far in NCAA '11.

Now I will agree that if every reaply we see in '11 is a close up of a certain player and not showing the play unfolding, that will be disappointing. But I dont think that'll happen.

[SageInfinite]

Re: NCAA Football 11 Video: First Look at Presentation Upgrades

No, neither of them are 100% real IMO, they're just alot closer than what we've seen thus far in NCAA '11.

Guess we'll have to agree to disagree because everything I've seen in NBA 2k10 I've seen on tv.

[Bigdmo9999]

Re: NCAA Football 11 Video: First Look at Presentation Upgrades

No, neither of them are 100% real IMO, they're just alot closer than what we've seen thus far in NCAA '11.

Now I will agree that if every reaply we see in '11 is a close up of a certain player and not showing the play unfolding, that will be disappointing. But I dont think that'll happen.

What do you mean not 100%? I can't spot one camera angle in that video that wouldn't be seen in real life. Unlike NCAA 11 which is EVERY angle (yes I play with the camera behind the players but even that isn't realistic)

I think the only realistic shot I saw in the NCAA 11 videos were ones following guys back to the huddle and the sky cam one. The replay cameras suck in terms of realism

[TheWatcher]

Re: NCAA Football 11 Video: First Look at Presentation Upgrades

there was also a butt shot of a ref when he was signaling a first down(I think it was the same video). why? I don't want to see the ref's butt.

Hmmmmm... Perhaps they're catering to a new demographic

[twodaysslow]

Re: NCAA Football 11 Video: First Look at Presentation Upgrades

Hahaha... do you guys realize how ******** you all look arguing about "instant replays?" I am sorry, but "instant replays" are on the absolute bottom of what I care about when I am playing a game. I am more interested in this new linear lighting, locomotion, expanded playbooks, QB read option that works, bubble screens that work, solid rosters, and in dynasty, having the CPU recruit the correct players to their schools. If "instant replays" are really what you are going to base investing $60 on a game, then I am sorry you will be missing out on a great time playing NCAA 11 because the "instant replays" don't look EXACTLY like they do on Saturdays.

PS... If you are THAT concerned about everything being 100% realistic, then get off your couch, grab some buddies, and go play some football.

[SageInfinite]

Re: NCAA Football 11 Video: First Look at Presentation Upgrades

Hmmmmm... Perhaps they're catering to a new demographic

[Bigdmo9999]

Re: NCAA Football 11 Video: First Look at Presentation Upgrades

Hahaha... do you guys realize how ******** you all look arguing about "instant replays?" I am sorry, but "instant replays" are on the absolute bottom of what I care about when I am playing a game. I am more interested in this new linear lighting, locomotion, expanded playbooks, QB read option that works, bubble screens that work, solid rosters, and in dynasty, having the CPU recruit the correct players to their schools. If "instant replays" are really what you are going to base investing $60 on a game, then I am sorry you will be missing out on a great time playing NCAA 11 because the "instant replays" don't look EXACTLY like they do on Saturdays.

PS... If you are THAT concerned about everything being 100% realistic, then get off your couch, grab some buddies, and go play some football.

Who cares what you want, its what everyone wants. None of us ever said anything about not wanting anything you brought up. However we could say you sound ******** too since everyone else is bringing up those issues. I am just stating my opinion on this whole replay thing anyway, I'm not crying about it and writing angry letters to EA, hell I didn't even start a new thread for it.

Let us argue about what we want in peace and we'll let you go on with yours.

[PantherBeast_OS]

Re: NCAA Football 11 Video: First Look at Presentation Upgrades

Some of you will never be happy no matter what they do. I think it looks great compared to the last few years. They aren't forcing you to buy it, so don't. Simple as that.

Agreed. Some people seem never happy no matter what EA does. No game is never going to be perfect. The video was good but nothing really new at this point. I'm just ready to see a full video of the game in play with everything in it at once. Not no alpha build. But good anyway.

[SageInfinite]

Re: NCAA Football 11 Video: First Look at Presentation Upgrades

And some people will be happy with whatever EA does. That's just the way things work. Everyone is entitled to their opinion and their purchase.

[Bigdmo9999]

Re: NCAA Football 11 Video: First Look at Presentation Upgrades

If everyone stopped giving criticism do you think we'd even be past the first NCAA?

[JerseySuave4]

Hahaha... do you guys realize how ******** you all look arguing about "instant replays?" I am sorry, but "instant replays" are on the absolute bottom of what I care about when I am playing a game. I am more interested in this new linear lighting, locomotion, expanded playbooks, QB read option that works, bubble screens that work, solid rosters, and in dynasty, having the CPU recruit the correct players to their schools. If "instant replays" are really what you are going to base investing $60 on a game, then I am sorry you will be missing out on a great time playing NCAA 11 because the "instant replays" don't look EXACTLY like they do on Saturdays.

PS... If you are THAT concerned about everything being 100% realistic, then get off your couch, grab some buddies, and go play some football.

I agree, its pretty pathetic how much people are arguing about the camera angle of replays. Its a video game. No not all of NBA 2k10's replay cameras are 100% realistic, i play the game a lot and there are some replays in that game that you wouldnt see on tv but who really cares? I mean seriously, the fact that you guys are getting so upset over replay camera angles is pretty pathetic. I mean you're not even arguing about the actual game anymore, but replays?!? Wow