Posey=A
Montero=A
Meyers=A
Santana=A
Ramos=B
Meyers is 19 and just got started... Montero is only 20 but is super good. Posey may spend time at 1st base in his career.
I guess I feel that in the MAJOR leagues there are not a lot of great catchers. These guys all are going to make a mark because of that. I feel that Ramos is going to be ready very soon to play in the majors every day for a team. Posey and Montero are also there.
Home runs?
Ramos =31 in 5 years, Posey= 19 in 4 years, Montero=37 in 4 years
You can't tell me that Ramos doesn't at least deserve the A rating like the rest of them! Especially when Meyers hasn't even seen any time yet.
Don't like the Twins much?
Anyway I agree with you that there are some nice catching prospects out there. I meant... 'how many good catchers do you see in the major leagues?' Mauer, McCann, Martinez, um........ Wieters?Suzuki? The top-level catcher pool is rather slim.