I played superstar mode and its was complete trash. I was the running back and they barely called a running play even when it was on first and goal and even on when the ball on was on the 1 yard line, they called a passing play 9/10 times and the QB got picked off 7/10 times.
I played with Warner so it wasn't a case of a bad QB. In the 2 seasons I played warner had more then 20 picks in each year and usally 2 - 4 less TDs that INTs.
When they did call the running play its usally up the middle and the blocking up the middle is horrible I got stuffed like more then half the time.