Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

[King Gro23]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

I will have fun editing the rosters to be based by last two years performances in the NFL. I think it will be fun, and the ratings will be drastically lower were talking QB's with the starting job at 71 OVR & HB's with starting jobs at 79 OVR ..etc

[salbowski]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

Errr. Ray Lewis with 82 speed at his age?!

Ray has many talents but speed is certainly not one of them anymore. I mean according to this, he's faster than some elite TE's.

[GreenReign86]

Nick Collins ran a faster 40 then Percy Harvin, Jeremy Maclin, CJ Spiller, and Jahvid Best, and ran a 40 on par with that of Chris Johnson. Now don't you tell me he does not have elite speed. He ran a 4.31 40, whereas Harvin ran a 4.42 40, more then a tenth of a second slower yet he gets 97 speed, and Collins gets 89? Also, don't tell me it's just a 40 time either. I've seen Collins run Harvin down from behind, and Harvin had a 10 yard head start on him. So Collins is clearly faster then Percy Harvin yet only gets 89 speed. Well that's popularty for you. Donny sees a big name so he decides to overrate them just to make their fans happy, while underrating someone, because he has no knowledge of football. What a joke

[Megatron2k7]

The Nick Collins argument has been long going...... and with a ton of 40 times, videos, real game play footage, etc... etc........... to prove he deserves a 93 + speed rating. Collins runs low 4.3's in the 40 and has an unofficial pro day best time of 4.28 sec.

Collins caught Percy Harvin from behind on numerous occasions last year.... I guess Donny must have just thought Percy was having another migrane headache those days........ lol.....

Now Atlanta Falcon Back up FS Giordano was on the Packers roster last year.... and he still has his 91 speed rating..... and at no time during anything I witnessed during last season, was he even close to Collins in the speed department.

One last thought...... I will never say that Patrick Willis isn't a complete beast and the best or one of the best at his position in the league........ but 90 speed for a ILB......???.......... Really........?/?.............. That makes him faster than Nick Collins then....... Wow........ LMAO 1

Ridiculous.

[salbowski]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

Nick Collins ran a faster 40 then Percy Harvin, Jeremy Maclin, CJ Spiller, and Jahvid Best, and ran a 40 on par with that of Chris Johnson. Now don't you tell me he does not have elite speed. He ran a 4.31 40, whereas Harvin ran a 4.42 40, more then a tenth of a second slower yet he gets 97 speed, and Collins gets 89? Also, don't tell me it's just a 40 time either. I've seen Collins run Harvin down from behind, and Harvin had a 10 yard head start on him. So Collins is clearly faster then Percy Harvin yet only gets 89 speed. Well that's popularty for you. Donny sees a big name so he decides to overrate them just to make their fans happy, while underrating someone, because he has no knowledge of football. What a joke

I've seen Collins run Harvin down from behind, and Harvin had a 10 yard head start on him!

Yeah, I think you mean on the kick return, what you failed to say was that Harvin had already run 60 yards and juked, stumbled and over- rotated forwards all causing him to slow down when Collins started catching him.

Oh and by the way, Collins didn't even catch him.

[GreenReign86]

It wasn't on special teams. I don't even think Collins plays on special teams, and if he does it's rare. Also, it was a straight line no stumbling or anything, and Collins made the tackle.

[salbowski]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

The Nick Collins argument has been long going...... and with a ton of 40 times, videos, real game play footage, etc... etc........... to prove he deserves a 93 + speed rating. Collins runs low 4.3's in the 40 and has an unofficial pro day best time of 4.28 sec.

Collins caught Percy Harvin from behind on numerous occasions last year.... I guess Donny must have just thought Percy was having another migrane headache those days........ lol.....

Now Atlanta Falcon Back up FS Giordano was on the Packers roster last year.... and he still has his 91 speed rating..... and at no time during anything I witnessed during last season, was he even close to Collins in the speed department.

One last thought...... I will never say that Patrick Willis isn't a complete beast and the best or one of the best at his position in the league........ but 90 speed for a ILB......???.......... Really........?/?.............. That makes him faster than Nick Collins then....... Wow........ LMAO 1

Ridiculous.

Collins caught Percy Harvin from behind on numerous occasions last year.

You mean the two games where the Packers defense couldn't stop a single pass and Harvin had 7 catches for 130 yards and one 51 td. Oh and 225 yards in kick returns.

[salbowski]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

It wasn't on special teams. I don't even think Collins plays on special teams, and if he does it's rare. Also, it was a straight line no stumbling or anything, and Collins made the tackle.

If that happened there's a video of it somewhere. Find and show it or I'm going to assume you're being a homer and making stuff up.

[salbowski]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

Here's the one I'm talking about:

http://www.nfl.com/videos/minnesota-...n-s-big-return

[s38s38s]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

D.Williams is not evevn the best RB in Carolina!

Umm, nah. Just because Williams was hurt when J. Stew torched the G-men doesn't mean anything. Check the stats the last two years they were both there. Williams is number one for a reason, don't get me wrong Stew is a Monster as well, but Williams is a more versatile runner.

As far as MJD, OOOOVVVVEEEEERRRRRAAATTTTTEEEEDDDD!!! I understand the Jags needed a little love, and he's the only recognizable name for most people on that team, outside their fans.

[GreenReign86]

LMAOI, you also forget to mention how the refs handed you the 1st game. Woodson should have had 10 INT on the season. That PI call in the endzone he had while covering HARVIN, was a flat out terrible call worst PI call I've ever seen. Which ended up being the difference in the game. You also got lucky the 2nd game too.

[salbowski]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

LMAOI, you also forget to mention how the refs handed you the 1st game. Woodson should have had 10 INT on the season. That PI call in the endzone he had while covering HARVIN, was a flat out terrible call worst PI call I've ever seen. Which ended up being the difference in the game. You also got lucky the 2nd game too.

What's that got to do with Harvin and Collins?
Im dying to see the proof of Collins catching Harvin on numerous occasions last season.

[Megatron2k7]

Hey... lets not make this turn into a Packers vs Vikings pissing contest.

No one was asking for Harvin's speed rating to drop..... we were just using him as an example because he has such a high speed rating in the game.

Nick Collins is definitely faster than Ed Reed... yet Reed still gets a 93 speed rating..... and Polumalu has a 92 speed. I'm not saying Collins is a better player than those two.... but it seems like Donny Moore exaggerates the speed ratings unrealistically on many of the great players just to make them "stand out" and be dominate players within the video game.

If we had a better game engine, speed wouldn't have to be exaggerated on top tier players just to make them great in the game......... sad really..... really sad.

[salbowski]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

Hey... lets not make this turn into a Packers vs Vikings pissing contest.

No one was asking for Harvin's speed rating to drop..... we were just using him as an example because he has such a high speed rating in the game.

Nick Collins is definitely faster than Ed Reed... yet Reed still gets a 93 speed rating..... and Polumalu has a 92 speed. I'm not saying Collins is a better player than those two.... but it seems like Donny Moore exaggerates the speed ratings unrealistically on many of the great players just to make them "stand out" and be dominate players within the video game.

If we had a better game engine, speed wouldn't have to be exaggerated on top tier players just to make them great in the game......... sad really..... really sad.

No p!$$ing here but when two people are basing the fact a player should be faster than he is on the same statement, I'd expect to see video or some sort of proof or it's fair to assume, it's just homerism.

[treee]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

LMAO. Cedric Benson was 8th in rushing in the leauge and he MISSED 3 GAMES. And he had 160 yards rushing against the leauges top defense in the jets IN THE PLAYOFFS. I believe that warrants a top 10 rating in running backs, doesn't anyone else?