Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

[im_noob]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

Ben should be a 90 at least. He's better, or at least as good as, Romo and Schaub. I wonder what Wallace's speed rating will be hopefully at least 95.

Can't complain too much about the ratings though, some great defensive players

Smith - 87
Hampton - 91
Woodley - 91
Harrison - 97
Polamalu - 97

Taylor has 95 speed as well. Nice d

I think they should scale the ratings back more though like some of EA's other games, make like 93-95 the highest. And keep them scaled like last year.

[CaliDude916]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

Peterson being a 98 is a joke....I guess fumbling doesn't decrease your stats.....also Willis being 3 points higher then Beason is laughable....Beason plays in a Tampa 2 system where he is asked to cover much more then Willis and their stats are pretty comparable.....

Your comment is laughable, which is exact what I did. Willis is the best MLB in the league. Beason is good but not as good as Willis.

[Gosens6]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

LMAO. Cedric Benson was 8th in rushing in the leauge and he MISSED 3 GAMES. And he had 160 yards rushing against the leauges top defense in the jets IN THE PLAYOFFS. I believe that warrants a top 10 rating in running backs, doesn't anyone else?

To save everyones head from exploding if that happened, no.

[steelers1]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

One last thought...... I will never say that Patrick Willis isn't a complete beast and the best or one of the best at his position in the league........ but 90 speed for a ILB......???.......... Really........?/?.............. That makes him faster than Nick Collins then....... Wow........ LMAO 1

Ridiculous.

Patrick Willis is ridiculously fast. He runs in the 4.3s... I think 4.37 or somewhere in there. He didn't just have an 86 yard INT return TD a couple years ago because of luck. The guy is fast and deserves a 90 speed. That being said, Collins is faster than an 87 for sure.

[treee]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

To save everyones head from exploding if that happened, no.

Regardless, had he not have missed a game against the RAIDERS, as well as the other 2, he would easily have been in the top 5 in rushing. And I do not care what anyone says, when he got 160 yards against the Jets in playoffs when THEY KNEW ALL WE HAD WAS CED, then that is a premier running back performance.

[Jukeman]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

I pretty much agree with the rankings but I cringe everytime I see a 99...

whats wrong with a 95 being the the highest...At 99, their's 0 room for improvement and not much of a regress

S.Alexander, sure he was a "99" one year the next year when he had a terrible year, I wouldnt rate him a 89(assuming he'd regress 10 points) a 85 would be better or even 75(assuming he regressed another 10 points) looks better than 79

/end pet peeve

[Gosens6]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

Regardless, had he not have missed a game against the RAIDERS, as well as the other 2, he would easily have been in the top 5 in rushing. And I do not care what anyone says, when he got 160 yards against the Jets in playoffs when THEY KNEW ALL WE HAD WAS CED, then that is a premier running back performance.

O yeah but don't get me wrong, Benson had a GREAT comeback year last season, but, since most people here on OS don't recognize him as an elite back they would riot if he was rated higher than some of their favorite players.

I personally don't care about ratings, they mean nothing in the game anyway. I agree with you though, Benson went off last year.

[gmitch23]

Now Atlanta Falcon Back up FS Giordano was on the Packers roster last year.... and he still has his 91 speed rating..... and at no time during anything I witnessed during last season, was he even close to Collins in the speed department.

When Giordano was with the Colts the media said he was second fastest on the team, Giordano can fly.

[treee]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

O yeah but don't get me wrong, Benson had a GREAT comeback year last season, but, since most people here on OS don't recognize him as an elite back they would riot if he was rated higher than some of their favorite players.

I personally don't care about ratings, they mean nothing in the game anyway. I agree with you though, Benson went off last year.

Yeah that and the fact the M Turner is higher than benson and he had less than 900 yards. Was 19th in the leauge in rushing. WTF? lol

[Senator Palmer]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

LMAO. Cedric Benson was 8th in rushing in the leauge and he MISSED 3 GAMES. And he had 160 yards rushing against the leauges top defense in the jets IN THE PLAYOFFS. I believe that warrants a top 10 rating in running backs, doesn't anyone else?

I'll co-sign that. When Chris Henry went down, the Bengals were pretty much one dimesional. Week after week, everyone knew what was coming and he still couldn't be stopped. Save those two, three games he missed and he would have been right behind Johnson for the league lead in yards.

Good to see Hall, Joseph and Bobbie Williams get a little love, but where's Whitworth?

Oh well, like I said in another post, rating as they're done here seem antiquated. I like to look deeper than just overalls.

[warrior7807]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

No p!$$ing here but when two people are basing the fact a player should be faster than he is on the same statement, I'd expect to see video or some sort of proof or it's fair to assume, it's just homerism.

imo, a 4.36 40 and then asking for a speed increase isnt homerism.

[rylynner]

Bryant McKinney is a joke. He should be like a 79. He got taken out of 2 games last season because he was getting beaten so badly. Any speed rusher has his way with him.

Also, I think Ryan Picket should have been a top DT.

[a4reak]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

That's Jets D looks nasty. Ellis 86, Jenkins 94, Taylor 82, Harris 91, Scott 89, Revis 99, Leonhard 85. Then toss a rookie in Kyle Wilson who is a 77, Cromartie should be an 83ish. Our O-line is easily best in the game, good WRs. Here we gooooooooo

[salbowski]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

I'll co-sign that. When Chris Henry went down, the Bengals were pretty much one dimesional. Week after week, everyone knew what was coming and he still couldn't be stopped. Save those two, three games he missed and he would have been right behind Johnson for the league lead in yards.

Good to see Hall, Joseph and Bobbie Williams get a little love, but where's Whitworth?

Oh well, like I said in another post, rating as they're done here seem antiquated. I like to look deeper than just overalls.

Benson had the lowest yards/attempt in the top 15 rushers last year.
His yards total was inflated by the fact that he ran so frequently. He had three 35 run attempt games and a further three 27+ attempt games. To put that in perspective, Adrian Peterson didn't have a single 27+ attempt game all season, Benson had 6.

I also happen to think the Bengals Oline is a top 5 Oline in the league as shown by Larry Johnson and Bernard Scott (his backups) having a better average than Benson over the season and shining in the games that Benson missed.
If Benson reproduces this season then boost him up but you can't say he's that good after the first good season of his career.

[Eski33]

Nothing like a couple of alleged sexual assault incidents to drop a top QB from the ranks...Confusing how Roethlisberger isn't one of the top QB's....