Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top 10 WR's

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • G-Men_in_Mass
    Rookie
    • Jul 2009
    • 443

    #61
    Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top 10 WR's

    Originally posted by ScoobySnax
    I hope it is. Getting 30 dink and dunks a game hardly makes you "one of the best WR to ever play the game of football" LOL

    How many Pats games do you watch a year?? He cuts on a dime he makes the best LB and S miss on almost every play. He can stretch the field with the best of them.. The guy is a beast and should get more credit as one of the elite WR in the NFL
    "Thank you EA for a Great Football Game"
    "Eli you are one tough SOB"

    Comment

    • SA1NT401
      Banned
      • Sep 2007
      • 3498

      #62
      Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top 10 WR's

      Only 3-4 WRs (hell any position for that matter) should have ratings higher than 95+.....Then the next highest should be mid to high 80's...Love MOSS, but he should be no higher than a 88 same with a few others on that list. Not enough seperation....Thats whay thye all feel the same...Oh well.

      But i am someone who feels the 'stretched' ratings should be even more, meaning an avergae NFL player at any position should be like a 63-68 ovr.

      Comment

      • Shawnj86
        Rookie
        • Jul 2009
        • 354

        #63
        Nice
        New York Yankees/Giants/Knicks

        Comment

        • WFColonel56
          Pro
          • Feb 2009
          • 620

          #64
          Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top 10 WR's

          Originally posted by G-Men_in_Mass
          Do any of you watch football or just play Madden??

          Welker is unstopable he has proven that every year! If he would have played 16 game instead of 13 he would have end up with close to 150 catches..
          yes but look where he catches those balls. Screens, drags, short ins and outs....he is by far the best short ball WR in the game, he has a little med game but very little deep game....put almost any other WR on that list and throw them bubble screens and drags and they will be right next to him in catches to imo anyway

          Comment

          • salbowski
            Banned
            • Aug 2008
            • 928

            #65
            Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top 10 WR's

            Originally posted by WFColonel56
            yes but look where he catches those balls. Screens, drags, short ins and outs....he is by far the best short ball WR in the game, he has a little med game but very little deep game....put almost any other WR on that list and throw them bubble screens and drags and they will be right next to him in catches to imo anyway
            It's hard not to agree with that analysis.

            Comment

            • zav
              Rookie
              • Oct 2009
              • 139

              #66
              Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top 10 WR's

              Originally posted by Ronnie brown23
              LOL VJ is not better than marshall. not by any stretch of the imagination.and roddy white isn't even on moss's level.
              VJ is better than Marshall in a number of catagories

              Marshall does have better hands but thats about it so i give VJ the small edge.

              Roddy White is better than Moss hes been better the last two year
              Maryland terrapin for life
              St. Louis Rams Fan

              Comment

              • Tweeg
                MVP
                • Jul 2008
                • 1414

                #67
                Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top 10 WR's

                Originally posted by G-Men_in_Mass
                Do any of you watch football or just play Madden??

                Welker is unstopable he has proven that every year! If he would have played 16 game instead of 13 he would have end up with close to 150 catches..
                You have to be kidding. Welker without Randy Moss would be laughable. I don't understand all this Roddy White hate. Roddy White is a monster.
                Prototype Supreme

                Comment

                • WFColonel56
                  Pro
                  • Feb 2009
                  • 620

                  #68
                  Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top 10 WR's

                  Originally posted by Tweeg
                  You have to be kidding. Welker without Randy Moss would be laughable. I don't understand all this Roddy White hate. Roddy White is a monster.
                  Most hate on Roddy cause they dont know who he is....I remember when the ratings for M09 came out, thats when a ton of uproar was going on....Roddy is a top 8 WR in the NFL and he has been the last 3 years, since he was a starter for ATL..I would put roddy's skills vs any WR in the league...he does everything great, not just a few things here and there. I hope after this year people will give him his due

                  Comment

                  • Senator Palmer
                    MVP
                    • Jul 2008
                    • 3314

                    #69
                    Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top 10 WR's

                    I love Ocho, but I don't know how he cracks the top 10 over Marques Colston who is nowhere to be found.

                    C'mon son...
                    "A man can only be beaten in two ways: if he gives up, or if he dies."

                    Comment

                    • warrior7807
                      Rookie
                      • Jul 2009
                      • 228

                      #70
                      Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top 10 WR's

                      Originally posted by zav
                      VJ is better than Marshall in a number of catagories

                      Marshall does have better hands but thats about it so i give VJ the small edge.

                      Roddy White is better than Moss hes been better the last two year
                      I agree VJ needs a higher rating 93ish, but Marshall has the edge when comparing the two.

                      And last season Moss clearly had the better season. actually since White burst onto the scene 3 years ago, moss bested him 2 of the 3 seasons with his one down year being when Cassel started.

                      Comment

                      • Joeyland
                        Banned
                        • Sep 2007
                        • 80

                        #71
                        One Steve Smith was 2nd in catches, 4th in yards, and a rising star, with hes first pro bowl in his 3rd year.
                        The other is a former great who hasn't had a great season in years, and my be done with hes 2nd broken arm in 8 months.
                        Which should be more effective in Madden11?

                        Comment

                        • warrior7807
                          Rookie
                          • Jul 2009
                          • 228

                          #72
                          Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top 10 WR's

                          CAR. Steve Smith is still one of the best WR in the league. check out his stats. If he had half of a QB last season he would have put up comparable numbers to NYG Smith. With That, if NY Smith has another season this year similar to the one he had in 09, he should a 90

                          Comment

                          • WFColonel56
                            Pro
                            • Feb 2009
                            • 620

                            #73
                            Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top 10 WR's

                            Originally posted by warrior7807
                            I agree VJ needs a higher rating 93ish, but Marshall has the edge when comparing the two.

                            And last season Moss clearly had the better season. actually since White burst onto the scene 3 years ago, moss bested him 2 of the 3 seasons with his one down year being when Cassel started.
                            So ur saying that moss bested White 2 out of the 3 years. Think about what you are saying. Moss is in a Pass 1st offense. White is in a runn1st offense. Moss has the luxury of Welker to take heat off of him. White is the only pass threat so he is doubled every game all game.... and 1 of the years that u say moss bested white is the best year ever for a wr...WHEN IS A SEASON LIKE THAT GUNNA HAPPEN AGAIN. And about this past year half of the ATL offensive starters were hurt (Ryan, Turner, Norwood, 3 of the OLman)....So white was doubled with the 3RD STRING RB IN THE GAME, WITH CHRIS REDMAN THROWING THE BALL IN SOME GAMES... Moss isnt better than white. and last year moss had a little over 100 over white.....so that isn't CLEARLY better when you factor in what ATL had to fight through last year
                            Last edited by WFColonel56; 06-22-2010, 08:32 PM.

                            Comment

                            • theant1h3ro
                              Banned
                              • Mar 2008
                              • 385

                              #74
                              Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top 10 WR's

                              Originally posted by Joeyland
                              One Steve Smith was 2nd in catches, 4th in yards, and a rising star, with hes first pro bowl in his 3rd year.
                              The other is a former great who hasn't had a great season in years, and my be done with hes 2nd broken arm in 8 months.
                              Which should be more effective in Madden11?
                              Eli Manning >>>> Jake Delhomme

                              You sound pretty foolish now....

                              Also in 2008 Smitty had over 1,400 yards (averaging over 18 yards per catch) despite missing the first two games of the season.....now you really look foolish....

                              Comment

                              • warrior7807
                                Rookie
                                • Jul 2009
                                • 228

                                #75
                                Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top 10 WR's

                                Originally posted by WFColonel56
                                So ur saying that moss bested White 2 out of the 3 years. Think about what you are saying. Moss is in a Pass 1st offense. White is in a runn1st offense. Moss has the luxury of Welker to take heat off of him. White is the only pass threat so he is doubled every game all game.... and 1 of the years that u say moss bested white is the best year ever for a wr...WHEN IS A SEASON LIKE THAT GUNNA HAPPEN AGAIN. And about this past year half of the ATL offensive starters were hurt (Ryan, Turner, Norwood, 3 of the OLman)....So white was doubled with the 3RD STRING RB IN THE GAME, WITH CHRIS REDMAN THROWING THE BALL IN SOME GAMES... Moss isnt better than white. and last year moss had a little over 100 over white.....so that isn't CLEARLY better when you factor in what ATL had to fight through last year
                                Most of what you say is exactly right, but do you seriously think this is all taken into consideration when making player ratings? White is rated lower because Moss had a better season than him statistically. Donny Moore doesnt take into consideration that since ATL had 3 o-linemen hurt and a backup QB playing(who had almost an identical comp% and Passer Rating as Ryan) and White still had a great season, than he must get a boost. Also i'd like to point out that ATL had fewer rushing attempts than NE and only 20 or so fewer passing attempts. White was also thrown at more than Moss, so the run-first/pass-first statement holds little water.

                                The post i responded to stated that White was better than Moss the last two years, when in reality, that is not the case. You also help my point proving Moss has been better when stating that he did have one of the best seasons ever. I'm not a fan of Moss, and do like White alot, but Moss is the better receiver of the two.
                                Last edited by warrior7807; 06-22-2010, 11:41 PM.

                                Comment

                                Working...