Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

[lippe1888]

yeah, the QB ratings are crazy. brees is good, but i see him more in the 97 range. manning is the best QB though, so it's fair

Yea. Brees is really good but Peyton's an all-time great. Its only cuz hes on the cover and won the SB

[angels eclipse7]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

Yea. Brees is really good but Peyton's an all-time great. Its only cuz hes on the cover and won the SB

That is true, but the ratings should be about who is the best right now. Not who is the best over their career. If Joe Montana made a come back, they wouldn't rate him a 99. He isn't what he used to be and his rating should reflect it.

[Chargersa7x]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

IMO FIFA does a much better job with ratings, and I remember right they have like three players in the 90s

[Exonerated]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

IMO FIFA does a much better job with ratings, and I remember right they have like three players in the 90s

Before the season, Ronaldo 93, Messi 91.

[pittsburgher86]

HOW IN THE WORLD IS BEN ROETHLISBERGER NOT ON THE BEST QB LIST? HE IS CLEARY BETTER THEN GUYS LIKE SHAUB AND PHILLIP RIVERS! Does production mean anything to the ratings. Ben has one 2 superbowls! HE EVEN WON THE GAME FOR THE STEELERS IN SUPER BOWL 43! Sure Ben is stupid, with his off the field problems, but I hope they didnt take anything like that in to account. Well, I know I will be editing his attributes. Also kind of surpised about Brady.

[angels eclipse7]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

HOW IN THE WORLD IS BEN ROETHLISBERGER NOT ON THE BEST QB LIST? HE IS CLEARY BETTER THEN GUYS LIKE SHAUB AND PHILLIP RIVERS! Does production mean anything to the ratings. Ben has one 2 superbowls! HE EVEN WON THE GAME FOR THE STEELERS IN SUPER BOWL 43! Sure Ben is stupid, with his off the field problems, but I hope they didnt take anything like that in to account. Well, I know I will be editing his attributes. Also kind of surpised about Brady.

IDK why Steelers fans are so upset about his rating. BTW, Pasta said he is an 88, which I have to say is right on the money. I would say that you can argue he is better than Schaub, but no way is he better than Rivers. Not even close. And I hate the Chargers.

[Donny_Moore]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

well I think they increased it as the season went on last year.......when he first came into the league he was rated 92 speed...then I believe they dropped him to "88" when the season started last year....

so as long as he is still the fasted TE in the game, I'm fine with 90.....but I'm not ok with Jason Witton having a better rating than Vernon......Vernon is a better pass blocker, faster, and has shown he can catch in traffic for big key plays.

I think us 9er fans need to worry more about Shawnte Spencer's speed...as well as Dashon Goldson's rating.....

Spencer should be moved back to 91 speed...like he was a couple of years ago, and his overall rating better be up this year....the guy is basically our best covering CB...and he can tackle too.

He is still fastest TE by 3 points. Nobody at TE can touch this guy in terms of SPD. Also, 90 SPD is fast, not sure where you can make the statement that 90 is not fast enough.

[Donny_Moore]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

Polite is better than weaver at FB?
Jason peters isn't a top 5 LT?
jamal Jackson isn't a top 5 C?
And quintin Mikell isn't a top 5 SS????????!!!!!!!!!

LOL, let me take a wild guess here....Eagles fan?? LOL

[SA1NT401]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

Why still so generous with the 90++ Ratings Donny?

I know i am in the minority here maybe...But a 95+ should be reserved for the top 10 players in the NFL, should be an ELITE rating...Hell, Moss at 95 is WAY too high IMHO....88-89 would be realistic(or a bit less)...and im a PATS fan.

The Above average players in the NFL should be mid 80s

A good NfL player should be low-mid 70s

60-65 should be the average rating for an NFL player....

Quite a few questionable overalls on that there list...

And i think there should only be 3-5 99s in the entire game.

Looks like i will have ALOT of player editing to to again this year....

[Luca Brasi]

IDK why Steelers fans are so upset about his rating. BTW, Pasta said he is an 88, which I have to say is right on the money. I would say that you can argue he is better than Schaub, but no way is he better than Rivers. Not even close. And I hate the Chargers.

It really makes no difference to me because i dont play online and can easily edit his ratings but did you notice his stats last season? 4328 yards passing, 66.6% completion percentage, 100.5 rating...and he even missed a game. So imo an 88 rating for Ben is HORRIBLE. Should be a 90-92. As far as Rivers and for that matter Romo who are rated higher....im still waiting for them to win that big game, the one that Ben has won TWICE.


And since Donnie is obviously reading this thread i would really love to see his explaination for giving Ben an 88 rating. Should be great! *rolls eyes*

[EaglesSkins210]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

It really makes no difference to me because i dont play online and can easily edit his ratings but did you notice his stats last season? 4328 yards passing, 66.6% completion percentage, 100.5 rating...and he even missed a game. So imo an 88 rating for Ben is HORRIBLE. Should be a 90-92. As far as Rivers and for that matter Romo who are rated higher....im still waiting for them to win that big game, the one that Ben has won TWICE.


And since Donnie is obviously reading this thread i would really love to see his explaination for giving Ben an 88 rating. Should be great! *rolls eyes*

"Big Ben was a very naughty boy and maybe since we took away his top 10 caliber rating, he can think about his actions in his room."

[Luca Brasi]

"Big Ben was a very naughty boy and maybe since we took away his top 10 caliber rating, he can think about his actions in his room."

LOL i guess thats the thinking behind it...<shrugs>

[EaglesSkins210]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

LOL i guess thats the thinking behind it...<shrugs>

Back in late April (after McNabb was traded to the Skins), pasta had these guys as the top 10 QBs:

Top 10
Peyton Manning – 99
Drew Brees – 99
Tom Brady – 95
Aaron Rodgers – 93
Phillip Rivers – 93
Brett Favre – 92
Ben Roethlisberger – 91
Donovan McNabb – 90
Tony Romo – 89
Matt Schaub – 89

We all know what happened to Roethlisberger, but what I want to know is, why does EA all of a sudden want Homo to be better than McNabb..

Of course the Cowboys are overrated.

I guess Miles Austin will soon be a 99 as Kim Kardashian has given him the magic good luck *** kiss.

[SA1NT401]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

Back in late April (after McNabb was traded to the Skins), pasta had these guys as the top 10 QBs:

Top 10
Peyton Manning – 99
Drew Brees – 99
Tom Brady – 95
Aaron Rodgers – 93
Phillip Rivers – 93
Brett Favre – 92
Ben Roethlisberger – 91
Donovan McNabb – 90
Tony Romo – 89
Matt Schaub – 89

We all know what happened to Roethlisberger, but what I want to know is, why does EA all of a sudden want Homo to be better than McNabb..

Of course the Cowboys are overrated.

I guess Miles Austin will soon be a 99 as Kim Kardashian has given him the magic good luck *** kiss.

More like the kiss of death...I hate that chick....HOTT HOTT HOTT...but annoying.

Ratings overall are meaningless when you really break it down and think about it. Espesially in OFFline franchise...I nerf 95% of the top rated players in every position anyway starting with Romo, Big Ben etc etc..

[EaglesSkins210]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

More like the kiss of death...I hate that chick....HOTT HOTT HOTT...but annoying.

Ratings overall are meaningless when you really break it down and think about it. Espesially in OFFline franchise...I nerf 95% of the top rated players in every position anyway starting with Romo, Big Ben etc etc..

I said good luck because she "helped" Reggie Bush win the Super Bowl, and her sister "helped" Lamar Odom win the NBA Finals this year.