Madden NFL 11 Video: Jets vs. Ravens - Revis Pick 6 (K0ACHK)

[RaiderKtulu]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Video: Jets vs. Ravens - Revis Pick 6 (K0ACHK)

First off all... You guys are crazii -_-

Second The ball was a drifter.. Revis left his man went to the ball. What's wrong with that?

Nothing's wrong with it, in theory.

The problem is the way it looked when it happened. If people want to claim that they want a realistic football game, then you can't accept "close enough" for a result. Oh it was realistic for a video game... NO, it wasn't. It looked fracking wrong. Period.

Like I said earlier in the thread, if Revis was strafing when the ball came out, it wouldn't be worth complaining about. But he wasn't.

Not to mention how stupid it looked for the RB to just stand there at the 5 and look into the backfield while Revis is going after this wounded duck pass. They were running the same direction when the ball came out, why didn't the RB go after it too?

[canes21]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Video: Jets vs. Ravens - Revis Pick 6 (K0ACHK)

The RB hd his head clearly away from all the action. Revis's head did not look completely turned away from the QB.

[BezO]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Video: Jets vs. Ravens - Revis Pick 6 (K0ACHK)

The folks that don't see a problem with the play, do you not have a problem with the lack of change of direction animation? You don't want to see him gather, plant, lean, explode then jump?

[Skyboxer]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Video: Jets vs. Ravens - Revis Pick 6 (K0ACHK)

There was change of direction. Rev is was barely even moving to his left. Don't see how that means there needs to be a huge body lean.

He also, from what my eyes seen jumped off his right leg and made a catch. Again the ball was barely moving and was just fluttering in air. Why did it need some sore of highlight reel INT move?

At this point I think it's just picking to pick. So that's it for me in this thread.

[JayD]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Video: Jets vs. Ravens - Revis Pick 6 (K0ACHK)

There are a lot of empty seats.

[K_GUN]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Video: Jets vs. Ravens - Revis Pick 6 (K0ACHK)

The folks that don't see a problem with the play, do you not have a problem with the lack of change of direction animation? You don't want to see him gather, plant, lean, explode then jump?

not in a video game....because that's a mighty long, beautiful animation that won't let me take control until its over

[ODogg]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Video: Jets vs. Ravens - Revis Pick 6 (K0ACHK)

LMAO, that comment caught me off guard...

[monkeybutlerz]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Video: Jets vs. Ravens - Revis Pick 6 (K0ACHK)

Revis is good, but he's not good enough to defy the laws of physics. You can't change directions like that without losing some manner of speed. For him to get back to the ball he would have to decelerate, plant, turn, re-accelerate and make the catch, or at least take a wider trajectory if it's a mere turn.

I'm a Madden fan too, but that certainly wasn't the depiction of realism some are making it out to be. I understand it's a video game and it won't be perfect and that's fine, but to argue that we see THAT every sunday is flat out BS.

[BezO]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Video: Jets vs. Ravens - Revis Pick 6 (K0ACHK)

not in a video game....because that's a mighty long, beautiful animation that won't let me take control until its over

It's 3 different animations. Gather. Plant. Lean. 4... I forgot the shorter steps while accelerating.

And Madden allows you to break any animation. As long is I transition to another realistic animation, I'm cool.

I think Madden's uber control kills the timing of football. I also think controlling the game would be easier if the movement was more realistic.

[canes21]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Video: Jets vs. Ravens - Revis Pick 6 (K0ACHK)

Revis does not need to chop his feet to turn around and catch that pass. When he was just strafing and not really going fast at all, turning around in two steps is easy. Heck, most pro athletes can turn around in a couple steps when sprinting. I play football as a DB/WR and the Revis play does not look unrealistic or anything like a superstar play. I probably won't play football in college and I would have been able to make the same interception and taken it for 6.

[BezO]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Video: Jets vs. Ravens - Revis Pick 6 (K0ACHK)

Revis does not need to chop his feet to turn around and catch that pass. When he was just strafing and not really going fast at all, turning around in two steps is easy.

I'll have to take another look, but I remember him in a running animation, not straffing. Even jogging, you can't spin on a foot and turn in the opposite direction without breaking stride. I'm not saying chop his feet. Gather & plant. When moving with any type of speed, athletes brace themselves in some way before planting and changing direction.

And you also don't hit full stride right after changing direction. There are some choppier steps when accelerating.

This stuff takes time. More time than Revis took.

[canes21]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Video: Jets vs. Ravens - Revis Pick 6 (K0ACHK)

He took two steps and jumped, thats not hard at all. And he did get low when changing direction, or was in a crouched type position anyways. Its not like he was sprinting and turned and then jumped 4 feet for the pick. He was going pretty steadily, turned and jumped 2 feet in the air for the pick.

[Joeyland]

The great thing about Madden is I can make the same play with my dimeback

[tlc12576]

Re: Madden NFL 11 Video: Jets vs. Ravens - Revis Pick 6 (K0ACHK)

There are a lot of empty seats.

I have been meaning to comment on this for a while but kept forgetting to. The seats are probably empty because it's an Exhibition Game, IMO. In a franchise or direct Superbowl game, the stands would most likely be almost or completely full. This is actually a potentially good sign that dynamic attendance is in the game.

The folks that don't see a problem with the play, do you not have a problem with the lack of change of direction animation? You don't want to see him gather, plant, lean, explode then jump?

I dont see what he did wrong, this is actually one of the more realistic plays I have seen in next-gen Madden. Like I said before, when the RB breaksdown in his route, Revis takes his eyes off the RB and surveys the field. Revis sees the ball fluttering in the air, follows the ball with his eyes while TURNING upfield. Revis takes a step or two upfield and jumps for the interception. That's perfect technique, IMO.

Maybe I shouldnt use the term "breaksdown". What I mean is, the RB slows down as is he is preparing to either get in position to be able to receive a pass or make an evasive move. It is at this point that Revis, who is in zone and only responsible for that area, surveys the field as he should.

Again,I have no comment on the TD return though. LOL

[gilljon26]

why doesn't no one show the game in broadcast camera com'on man