NBA Elite 11, NBA Jam Impressions from New York

[Hulkules]

Re: NBA Elite 11, NBA Jam Impressions from New York

And the defense will have an effect on the sweet spot this has been said time and time again. If you are being heavily guarded when you take a shot your sweet spot will shrink it will not be the same as when you are open.

So that concern is being addressed all we can do is hope for the best though because if we don't all it will lead to is nitpicking and frustration.

Dude, I know the sweet spot gets smaller. But I want there to be a penalty for taking dumb shots over doubles and heavy guarding. If you can push it straight up then it goes in all the time which shouldnt be the case. I can already see people shooting heavily contested shots with Kobe instead of passing the ball to the open man which isnt good basketball.

Even open shots are missed by great shooters, but apparently it goes in if you push it up perfectly. I hope I am very wrong cause this game sounds unbelieveable.. Cant wait to get my hands on the Demo.

[©roke]

Re: NBA Elite 11, NBA Jam Impressions from New York

Dude, I know the sweet spot gets smaller. But I want there to be a penalty for taking dumb shots over doubles and heavy guarding. If you can push it straight up then it goes in all the time which shouldnt be the case. I can already see people shooting heavily contested shots with Kobe instead of passing the ball to the open man which isnt good basketball.

Even open shots are missed by great shooters, but apparently it goes in if you push it up perfectly. I hope I am very wrong cause this game sounds unbelieveable.. Cant wait to get my hands on the Demo.

If the open man has a larger sweet spot than a heavily contested Kobe, why people wouldn't pass the ball?

Anyways, shooting those heavily contested shots with Kobe even if 4 teammates are open is 100% realistic, so...

[dexvex]

Re: NBA Elite 11, NBA Jam Impressions from New York

I have no gripe with EA trying to get their bball correct. But why is it they always, and I mean always are one year behind 2k? In 2K, the shooting has always been done with a signature shot, signature release point and a varying window for release point accuracy based on player skill, defense, spacing, etc.

Why is that the EXACT same explaination for this "new" for NBA ELITE? Maybe others don't pick up what I do, maybe I read between the lines better than most, but come on, don't you see it? Live 10 played alot like 2k8, now you want ELITE to be 2k10?

I love the quotes they make that state bball games in GENERAL all have the same issues. Well why are you implementing A SHOT STICK? About 4 Years ago you guys still used 2 shooting buttons, LMAO.
In 2k10 Kobe has a very funny release point, so does Dirk, which both are different from Lebron's, anyone who just shoots, will never hit on a consistent basis unless they practice, now nba elite is saying you might have to practice more with your favorite teams to get their style down...wow, something any 2ker has been doing. I still cant get Danillo Gallinari's shot release...lol
So once again to try to join them, you must copy them, just don't be so ignorant in these community events, admit that you guys still praise NBA 2K and they give you guys all your ideas for the next year, when yall see what they've implemented in the same turnaround time as you guys. I can see it already, NBA ELITE with 400 pairs of kicks to unlock, but no realism, and I see they might be going back to baseline view, Im a Broadcast view man. They want you to use baseline low cuz their corny control scheme only works when the ball handler is facing up/down. Gimmie a break with this. I care not about EA basketball. Like I never Cheerios, cuz Im a frosted flakes man. EA Canada continues to wait for 2K to show them what basketball should play like.

so much fail dude........

[Da_Czar]

Re: NBA Elite 11, NBA Jam Impressions from New York

What's up Czar? I can honestly say that I am actually excited for at least one EA Sports title this year. That is NBA Elite 11. I almost got excited for NCAA 11, but I had to pass.

Now, from many years of experience with video games, about a year with FNR4, and now a few weeks experience with Backbreaker, I can say that physics is definitely the way to go. And giving us more control over dribbling, shooting, passing, running, and hopefully dunking will put this game on top of the NBA 2k series. I am a 2k fan, but I used to be an avid NBA Live fan.

On to my question. Are there any plans to go to a variable, real-time acceleration system or are we going to be stuck with a stop and sprint system seen from in the 7 minute NBA Elite 11 video. The reason I ask is since I have been playing Backbreaker, I have notice that all the players accelerate realistically. I would like to see that in a basketball game for once.

What's happening Turf forgive me for not answering this question man I just saw it... I am not sure of the exact plans and maybe one of the devs can step in here but there is no more turbo button so the aim would have to be towards something more along the lines of what your question is..

So short answer I don't know, But also yes I think so if that makes any sense.

[loadleft]

Re: NBA Elite 11, NBA Jam Impressions from New York

Czar, I've asked this question of the dev's several time and have gotten no response, but did anyone explain to you why they didn't just put the full range of speed on the left analog?

[thomonkey]

Re: NBA Elite 11, NBA Jam Impressions from New York

the thing you people don't understand is that if somebody does play ****ty defense they SHOULD get killed with an "unrealistic" shooting percentage. if an nba team played defense like some people play online, the opposing team would be shooting in the 80 percents. that is realistic.

[Da_Czar]

Re: NBA Elite 11, NBA Jam Impressions from New York

Czar, I've asked this question of the dev's several time and have gotten no response, but did anyone explain to you why they didn't just put the full range of speed on the left analog?

Great question Load. I haven't asked and no one has mentioned it. But they have said that they are still tweaking that aspect to try and get it to feel right. From the time I have spent with these companies there is one thing I definitely know for sure. That is that almost everything you see in a game is there because it solves some sort of problem or issue. Now it may cause many more but there is always a tradeoff when making these games.

As I said last I heard they were still working on this area. Maybe start a detail thread talking about how you would like to see it implemented and maybe that can give them some ideas or get them to test it out if they have time.

If i find out something on this and its not a top secret deal I will def let you know Fam !

[Da_Czar]

Re: NBA Elite 11, NBA Jam Impressions from New York

the thing you people don't understand is that if somebody does play ****ty defense they SHOULD get killed with an "unrealistic" shooting percentage. if an nba team played defense like some people play online, the opposing team would be shooting in the 80 percents. that is realistic.

Sup thomonkey. In theory, while a bit of an exaggeration, your right, If were talking over the course of a game or two against a bad defensive team and if your hot you can shoot a high percentage. Maybe not 80 but high.

However a bad defensive team would probably be giving up layups and dunks and offensive rebounds and things like that. With this system against a poor defender you could have guys shooting 60 % off of jumpers if they are wide open.

since no one has yet played a build with all the defensive stuff effecting the sweet spot and in a 5 on 5 situation we don't really know. I'm definitely intrigued though and there will definitely be two completely different and hopefully excellent games to choose from which is what I know a lot of us want.

I don't think we can loose this year.

From a me vs you standpoint that could be pretty entertaining as long as your playing with people of equal skill level and there are no major exploits.

[randombrother]

Re: NBA Elite 11, NBA Jam Impressions from New York

the thing you people don't understand is that if somebody does play ****ty defense they SHOULD get killed with an "unrealistic" shooting percentage. if an nba team played defense like some people play online, the opposing team would be shooting in the 80 percents. that is realistic.

I agree with this. The sim part of the game shouldn't be the score. The sim should be what your players on the court are able to do and the X factor is what can YOU do with them.

So if some chump runs with the Cavs all day and truly sucks at BBall IQ , has no idea there is even a pass button and thinks just by making a couple of dumb juke moves without setting anything up should get him the win he should lose and lose bad against the worse defensive team as long as THAT guy knows how to move his pieces on the hardwood chessboard. He knows how to bring the help, he knows exactly what this guy is going to do and get ready to combat it the he should destroy the Cavs.

See one thing people don't seems to realize is that these elite players aren't dummies. It's hard to defend a Kobe or Lebron because they can do you with the rock OR they can set you up for the kickout to the open man. See it's that "OR" that makes them lethal. But if you KNOW for a fact that he'll never trust his squad and once he gets the rock it's never leaving his hands then playing defense is that much easier. And if they played like these guys online where you ABSOLUTELY KNOW FOR A FACT the guy ain't passing then he should be getting stopped often and frequently by a guy who knows his defense.

Don't take my word on it just look at real life. When Kobe didn't trust his squad they didn't do squat. Once he started trusting his squad look at the rings start rolling in.

[ParisB]

Re: NBA Elite 11, NBA Jam Impressions from New York

I agree with this. The sim part of the game shouldn't be the score. The sim should be what your players on the court are able to do and the X factor is what can YOU do with them.

So if some chump runs with the Cavs all day and truly sucks at BBall IQ , has no idea there is even a pass button and thinks just by making a couple of dumb juke moves without setting anything up should get him the win he should lose and lose bad against the worse defensive team as long as THAT guy knows how to move his pieces on the hardwood chessboard. He knows how to bring the help, he knows exactly what this guy is going to do and get ready to combat it the he should destroy the Cavs.

See one thing people don't seems to realize is that these elite players aren't dummies. It's hard to defend a Kobe or Lebron because they can do you with the rock OR they can set you up for the kickout to the open man. See it's that "OR" that makes them lethal. But if you KNOW for a fact that he'll never trust his squad and once he gets the rock it's never leaving his hands then playing defense is that much easier. And if they played like these guys online where you ABSOLUTELY KNOW FOR A FACT the guy ain't passing then he should be getting stopped often and frequently by a guy who knows his defense.

Don't take my word on it just look at real life. When Kobe didn't trust his squad they didn't do squat. Once he started trusting his squad look at the rings start rolling in.

Well to his defense, it's not that he didn't trust his teamates before. It was because they sucked. The starting lineup was Kwame Brown, Chris Mihm, Smush Parker, and Luke Walton. Quite a difference between Gasol, Bynum, Fisher, Artest, Odom etc.

[randombrother]

Re: NBA Elite 11, NBA Jam Impressions from New York

Well to his defense, it's not that he didn't trust his teamates before. It was because they sucked. The starting lineup was Kwame Brown, Chris Mihm, Smush Parker, and Luke Walton. Quite a difference between Gasol, Bynum, Fisher, Artest, Odom etc.

But he didn't start trusting these guys right out the box either. Artest just came over but them other guys were there during the "no-trust" era.

[thomonkey]

Re: NBA Elite 11, NBA Jam Impressions from New York

Sup thomonkey. In theory, while a bit of an exaggeration, your right, If were talking over the course of a game or two against a bad defensive team and if your hot you can shoot a high percentage. Maybe not 80 but high.

However a bad defensive team would probably be giving up layups and dunks and offensive rebounds and things like that. With this system against a poor defender you could have guys shooting 60 % off of jumpers if they are wide open.

since no one has yet played a build with all the defensive stuff effecting the sweet spot and in a 5 on 5 situation we don't really know. I'm definitely intrigued though and there will definitely be two completely different and hopefully excellent games to choose from which is what I know a lot of us want.

I don't think we can loose this year.

From a me vs you standpoint that could be pretty entertaining as long as your playing with people of equal skill level and there are no major exploits.

hey czar i think that it is hard to say what percentage an nba shooter would actually shoot if they took wide open shots the whole game, but i really do believe that if you let kobe take wide open shots during the entire game he would shoot in the 60 or 70 percents each game. (80 may have been an exaggeration :P). that's why i dont really see a problem in having the user be able to shoot such a high percentage if left alone. as long as it is hard to score when a guy is defending you i don't think we will have a problem. ive watched a game keeping my eye on wide open shots, and let me tell you, those nba players can shoot the lights out when they are left alone.

[sportyguyfl31]

I'm really intrigued to see how this plays out in full game play, full court 5 on 5.

I applaud their efforts, and I hope they are able to execute. I always root for the game that used to be called Live, to re-capture the fun that made me love the series int he 1st place.

The gradual death of pre determined canned animations, is nothing but a good thing for me.

I want to be in full control of everything my player does, as much as possible.

[DC]

Somebody just brought this article up to me and damn, this was sad man.

They had SO much Promise with NBA Live 10