Just tell me the Challenge system has been corrected

[Myth]

tell me there is no more letting the AI decide what it is i'm trying to challenge, and that we actually have a list of things to choose from.

[king525]

Re: Just tell me the Challenge system has been corrected

It hasnt been fixed, i was also very disappointed about this.

Just the other day the CPU throw touchdown in the endzone but the receiver got tackled in mid air and lost the ball the refs called a TD and i wanted to challenge that receiver didnt have possession of the ball. But the only option was SPOT OF THE BALL.

[Myth]

Re: Just tell me the Challenge system has been corrected

It hasnt been fixed, i was also very disappointed about this.

Just the other day the CPU throw touchdown in the endzone but the receiver got tackled in mid air and lost the ball the refs called a TD and i wanted to challenge that receiver didnt have possession of the ball. But the only option was SPOT OF THE BALL.

OMG...i can't imagine this will be fixed before released. they're probably making copies of the final build as i type this to you. wow man...

i can't believe people are so willing to let these sort of things go. the challenge system in the game of football is HUGE deal

[king525]

Re: Just tell me the Challenge system has been corrected

OMG...i can't imagine this will be fixed before released. they're probably making copies of the final build as i type this to you. wow man...

i can't believe people are so willing to let these sort of things go. the challenge system in the game of football is HUGE deal

Skipping this year anyway (NO FRANCHISE UPDATES ), i just hope fifa 11 is good this year havent owned one since 08.

[MJenness]

Re: Just tell me the Challenge system has been corrected

THIS!! To me, this and penalties not called even with sliders to max, AND many missing penalties really stand out to me. And the out of sequence cut scenes, such as the QB on the phone one second, then at the LOS next minute.

[Myth]

Re: Just tell me the Challenge system has been corrected

amazing

[WorldIsYours]

Re: Just tell me the Challenge system has been corrected

Atleast half of this problem has already been fixed when you come to think about it (sideline catches have been fixed).

[Myth]

Re: Just tell me the Challenge system has been corrected

Atleast half of this problem has already been fixed when you come to think about it (sideline catches have been fixed).

not even close man, not even close


if what the previous poster says is true, that's a very big problem. the receiver gets tackled in mid-air, fumbles, and the ai thinks you want to challenge the spot of the ball? come on madden team...wow

[Evan_OS]

Re: Just tell me the Challenge system has been corrected

not even close man, not even close


if what the previous poster says is true, that's a very big problem. the receiver gets tackled in mid-air, fumbles, and the ai thinks you want to challenge the spot of the ball? come on madden team...wow

To be honest with you. I don't think I've ever really had a hard time trying to challenge something. 99% of the time, the challenge call is called for the correct reason. The only situation I've ever had a problem was a touchdown catch wasn't called right and I challenged it and a bunch of glitches happened with the players having the other teams helmets on etc. That was ONCE, and it was also back in 2007 on the PS2.

Every game ever made has had it's problems, and maybe Madden has had a few more than most games would. But, when a glitch happens, don't act like EA Sports' games are the only games that have glitches.

[Segagendude]

Re: Just tell me the Challenge system has been corrected

It hasnt been fixed, i was also very disappointed about this.

Just the other day the CPU throw touchdown in the endzone but the receiver got tackled in mid air and lost the ball the refs called a TD and i wanted to challenge that receiver didnt have possession of the ball. But the only option was SPOT OF THE BALL.

You're talking about M10, right?

[cubsball899]

Re: Just tell me the Challenge system has been corrected

To be honest with you. I don't think I've ever really had a hard time trying to challenge something. 99% of the time, the challenge call is called for the correct reason. The only situation I've ever had a problem was a touchdown catch wasn't called right and I challenged it and a bunch of glitches happened with the players having the other teams helmets on etc. That was ONCE, and it was also back in 2007 on the PS2.

Every game ever made has had it's problems, and maybe Madden has had a few more than most games would. But, when a glitch happens, don't act like EA Sports' games are the only games that have glitches.

go check out APF system of challenges... i'm not saying become a fan of of APF but thats the best comparison for M10... APF challenge system is amazing gives the user TOTAL control and there is no reason it cannot be implemented in madden

[King Gro23]

Re: Just tell me the Challenge system has been corrected

I constantly see endzone challenges whether it be: Was it a catch, Did he get in? did he fumble before crossing? All those regarding endzones are the worst to me. Also the catch they do were you dive for it and roll across your back they always challenge the spot of the ball in M10 even if your in the endzone it goes back to the one yard line

[Myth]

Re: Just tell me the Challenge system has been corrected

To be honest with you. I don't think I've ever really had a hard time trying to challenge something. 99% of the time, the challenge call is called for the correct reason. The only situation I've ever had a problem was a touchdown catch wasn't called right and I challenged it and a bunch of glitches happened with the players having the other teams helmets on etc. That was ONCE, and it was also back in 2007 on the PS2.

Every game ever made has had it's problems, and maybe Madden has had a few more than most games would. But, when a glitch happens, don't act like EA Sports' games are the only games that have glitches.

we're not talking about minor hiccups

we're talking about things that change the entire outcome of a game. i've lost many games on a fumble. the defense picks it up, runs it in for a touchdown, i go to challenge, and the AI thinks i want to challenge the spot of the ball.

that's not real football

[Pringles]

Re: Just tell me the Challenge system has been corrected

i hope it is fixed i know it was a eye sore to see the ref animations signaling'
touchdowns when in fact they were not and you coud not overturn them calls

[vodkatonic]

Re: Just tell me the Challenge system has been corrected

Just remember EA and Maddens motto...

Maybe next year....but probably not.