Yeah, the show is pretty subtle unless you're batting, then obviously you can see the sky changing. But there's absolutely ZERO way you can play NCAA and not notice it.
NCAA gives it a run for it money, and is in some way better if you can believe it.
So far, I've only played in one domed stadium on NCAA, and that's Cowboys Stadium....but it is very well lit and nicely done on there. I can only imagine Madden is the same way.