Operation Sports Forums - View Single Post - Official Xbox 360 community roster correction thread

sf.irish · 07-23-2010, 03:42 AM

MrBlonde, it's possible that those players really are that good- but it doesn't justify edited ratings.

Again, 78-82 are what 5 star recruits are rated, and UCLA's freshmen, with the exception of Ogi, are NOT 5 star recruits. Barr, James, and Jones are all solid recruits, but they are consensus 4 star recruits by almost all the ratings services. Koster is a 2 star recruit freshman, there's no way he should be even sniffing a 78.

Prince had 8 TD's and 8 INT last year, which suggests a subpar qb. If we argue that it was due to limited pt, we'd have his recruiting rating to fall back on, which was also poor.

Fauria was good at ND and showed promise, we just had two guys that were better (Ragone and Rudolph, each the top TE in their class) Fauria should stay at 77.

07-23-2010, 03:42 AM	#807
sf.irish Rookie OVR: 1 Join Date: Jul 2010	Re: Official Xbox 360 community roster correction thread MrBlonde, it's possible that those players really are that good- but it doesn't justify edited ratings. Again, 78-82 are what 5 star recruits are rated, and UCLA's freshmen, with the exception of Ogi, are NOT 5 star recruits. Barr, James, and Jones are all solid recruits, but they are consensus 4 star recruits by almost all the ratings services. Koster is a 2 star recruit freshman, there's no way he should be even sniffing a 78. Prince had 8 TD's and 8 INT last year, which suggests a subpar qb. If we argue that it was due to limited pt, we'd have his recruiting rating to fall back on, which was also poor. Fauria was good at ND and showed promise, we just had two guys that were better (Ragone and Rudolph, each the top TE in their class) Fauria should stay at 77. Last edited by sf.irish; 07-23-2010 at 03:50 AM.