[RaychelSnr]

Quote: Originally Posted by Legend Killer

I really have to agree with JP on this one. I respect the reviews from Chris and his partner who played the demo. But I was more impressed with the demo after seeing ShopMaster play it. I think the Demo looked good from the live stream. I can't wait to get it in my hands to try it. To be honest for anyone to really get a feel for the game itself. You need to play the demo yourself to find out. Reviews from other people are good and all. But playing itself is the best thing to do to get a good feel for the game.

I really think Madden is on par with NCAA.....not sure how that got lost in translation in this. I consider NCAA possibly the best football game ever as far as overall realism and quality, so for Madden to be pretty close is a pretty big compliment IMHO. However, I think the camp that's expecting Madden to be leaps and bounds better than NCAA will be rather disappointed. Both games are on par with each other IMHO, which isn't a bad thing for Madden....but I just don't see Madden being the GOAT right now. But it's got a chance to top NCAA, especially if they nail the presentation and atmosphere of each team in the final build. The jury is still out for sure though