Do you think this is a fair trade?

[Bengals28]

Bengals Get:

64 ovr WR Armanti Edwards

Panthers Get:

62 ovr Quan Cosby
57 ovr Jerome Simpson
7th round draft pick

[Heroiczero13]

Re: Do you think this is a fair trade?

Well if Edwards has an A or B potential it would be a good one for the Bengals.

[PantherBeast_OS]

Re: Do you think this is a fair trade?

Hmmm well it all depends on how good Edwards becomes this season. For now I would think this is a decent trade off. But it is hard to say right now.

[the drewster 7]

Re: Do you think this is a fair trade?

Seems pretty even but if I was the Panthers i wouldn't make that trade.

[DTSkins]

Re: Do you think this is a fair trade?

That seems like a pretty fair trade, but the Bengals are getting the better deal. Armanti Edwards would be awesome in a wildcat formation.

[Bengals28]

Re: Do you think this is a fair trade?

what if I replaced quan cosby with 68 ovr Dezmon Briscoe, thatd be fair both ways right?

[cam780]

Re: Do you think this is a fair trade?

If you're looking for realism, I don't think this deal would go down. You're dealing with three third tier wide receivers. Why would the bengal's give up two #5 receivers and a pick for one?

Look for another position. I'm not familiar with the rosters but look for the spots where your strengths and weaknesses matchup. You're looking for a wide receiver check the Panther's roster and find something that they're lacking. Maybe they need a backup tackle or a third string QB and you have the spare parts. Get it done that way one for one or throw in a late pick if necessary.

[Superrandy]

Re: Do you think this is a fair trade?

As a Panther fan theres no way I'd do that trade. Edwards could be perfect for the slot and wildcat as a bonus. But in Madden I would maybe consider someone like DE M. Johnson (72) straight up for him, or a combination of some other guys and a draft pick like CB B. Ghee (68) and a 6th, or WR Shipley (68) and a 6th, maybe WR Simpson (57) and 3rd.

[Bengals28]

Re: Do you think this is a fair trade?

Yeah it's not really realistic. There's no way I'd give up M. Johnson and it wouldnt make sense giving up any of those players except simpson with a pick since there 4 points better ovr. Edwards wouldnt crack my lineup at all I just want him on my team bc im a big fan of him. I'll just wait a year or 2 into franchise when he hasnt done anything.

[StreetCarp]

Re: Do you think this is a fair trade?

Including any rookies in a trade is unrealistic.