Finally returned a punt for a TD, 2 in one game actually.

[swhyte21]

After 8 seasons of this game, I finally got a TD from a punt return. 68 yard return with one reverse field.

Two possesions later, another return. 63 yards with a huge broken tackle and 2 reversals of field. Well, one and a half. Though, stupid PS3 replays makes it awful cause I can't see it, though it did capture the kicker getting laid out flat on the 7 yard line on a huge block. Laughed my *** off when I saw that on the replay.

[tlef316]

Re: Finally returned a punt for a TD, 2 in one game actually.

i've gotten a few (all american) as well as 7 or 8 Kick off returns (have to catch the ball with a running start to accomplish this).

The PR is just so difficult though. 95% of the time, your blockers totally whiff on the gunners. Plus, it seems like the gunners cover the last 20 yards in about 1/2 a second. So there are a lot of times where i catch the ball thinking i have 10 yards of space, but all 4 of my blockers whiff and i get rocked.

I may have to try the running start on punt returns. But i imagine it will be a lot more difficult to time.

[tsp120]

Re: Finally returned a punt for a TD, 2 in one game actually.

This is something that has bothered me for years, and it spans all football games I've ever played from NCAA to Madden to 2K.

Why is it that in every game as soon as you catch the ball there are two guys on you ready to tackle you? I've seen some games in the past where kick returning felt realistic, but I've never seen realistic punt returning.

I don't know if the computer has ever had a return of longer than 10 yards against me in this game.

[Indian Joe]

Re: Finally returned a punt for a TD, 2 in one game actually.

After 8 seasons of this game, I finally got a TD from a punt return. 68 yard return with one reverse field.

Two possesions later, another return. 63 yards with a huge broken tackle and 2 reversals of field. Well, one and a half. Though, stupid PS3 replays makes it awful cause I can't see it, though it did capture the kicker getting laid out flat on the 7 yard line on a huge block. Laughed my *** off when I saw that on the replay.

Congratulations. You are now exalted in the NCAA realm. I've played 3 seasons and my longest punt return is 17 yards.

[Hova57]

Re: Finally returned a punt for a TD, 2 in one game actually.

i have 3 but they all came against a fcs team , which was funny cause my next game the opposing team punted away from him three times before they kicked to him

[Exonerated]

Re: Finally returned a punt for a TD, 2 in one game actually.

i had 3 in 1 game in my 5th season. equal to all combined the 4 seasons before. the game froze in the 4th qtr though.

[GopherFan]

Re: Finally returned a punt for a TD, 2 in one game actually.

I got 4 in one game and 2 in another. One of those games was against FCS and another agiasnt ARmy

[murph3733]

Re: Finally returned a punt for a TD, 2 in one game actually.

I still have yet to return a punt! what return formation do you guys use to return one?

[Buckeyes_Doc]

Re: Finally returned a punt for a TD, 2 in one game actually.

I'm horrible at returning punts, I'm lucky if I get over 10 yards.

I've returned 3 kickoffs though, well 2. One was called back for holding.

[bartolet7]

Re: Finally returned a punt for a TD, 2 in one game actually.

No returns here. Zero. Nada. And none even close. I'm lucky to get 5 yards on PR, and make it past the 20 on KR. Same goes for the CPU vs me. Very frustrating. If possible, I wish EA would address this with a tuner fix or patch. I understand that big returns are and should be rare occurances, but they DO and should occur once in a while . . . .

Then again, maybe my stick skills are simply lacking.

[swhyte21]

Re: Finally returned a punt for a TD, 2 in one game actually.

i've gotten a few (all american) as well as 7 or 8 Kick off returns (have to catch the ball with a running start to accomplish this).

The PR is just so difficult though. 95% of the time, your blockers totally whiff on the gunners. Plus, it seems like the gunners cover the last 20 yards in about 1/2 a second. So there are a lot of times where i catch the ball thinking i have 10 yards of space, but all 4 of my blockers whiff and i get rocked.

I may have to try the running start on punt returns. But i imagine it will be a lot more difficult to time.

I've gotten 4 or 5 but never try the running start... I always mess it up. But any time I have returned a kickoff, it was untouched with the same big hole on the left side of the field.

[swhyte21]

Re: Finally returned a punt for a TD, 2 in one game actually.

I still have yet to return a punt! what return formation do you guys use to return one?

I used return middle. Where ever the first gunner was blocked, I went to that side, and watched the defenders flow to that side of the field, and looked for a cut back lane through them. You usually will have one guy to make miss and then head for the sideline.

[Spanky]

Re: Finally returned a punt for a TD, 2 in one game actually.

43 games, one kickoff return for a TD and no punt returns for a TD, probably no PR longer than 15 yards. At least I'm not getting hammered right when I catch the ball anymore. I switched to a different formation, I think it's called punt return block or something like that. Your return team blocks the kicking team at the line of scrimmage instead of falling back. It leaves a lot of open field when you catch the ball, but the defenders close it quickly. Still. it's good for 10-15 yards every time.

[Rebel10]

Re: Finally returned a punt for a TD, 2 in one game actually.

In my very first game in dynasty I had a kick off return for a TD... and I thought "Well, looks like they're not impossible this year."

And four seasons later, I've yet to break the 35, I think.
My strategy on punt returns is that I _know_ that I'm not going to get a touchdown or any lengthy return, and rather than risk getting blown up and fumbling, I usually pick the punt block or punt block man-return. That makes the CPU come out in the extra blockers formation (proof of psychic AI btw, that they always come out in the formation that matches your formation on special teams), and then they always out-kick their coverers or kick it out of bounds. Because they out kick their cover guys, you can get a solid 10 - 15 yards and run out of bounds or dive to the ground before risking the fumble.

[TXHusker25]

Re: Finally returned a punt for a TD, 2 in one game actually.

I ran a punt back 60 yards for a TD once, only to have it called back for clipping 35 yards down field. I was angry, I was on the 10 by the time the FLAG icon showed up and I ended up getting the ball on the +40, which means the flag was on the +25.

Where is the BS chant when you need it?

Haven't been close since then, I fair catch more than I attempt to return. I've even started just playing base defense on punts and letting them bounce, the bigger threat vs. humans is someone going for it or faking it than maybe returning it 5 yards.