NBA 2K11: Starting Five Roster Ratings

[threes_co]

Re: NBA 2K11: Starting Five Roster Ratings

i think they should add a loyalty rating and make queen james's 0 and his clutch rating should also be 0 to represent the fact that he gave up in the playoffs the last 2 years. that way his overall will drop big time! kobe should be the only 97 in the game because he's the only one close to being as good as jordan and i hope jordan is 100 because no one will ever be what he was

I LOL'd @ that.

It's getting late.

[shawnomega]

Re: NBA 2K11: Starting Five Roster Ratings

Brandon Jennings is definitely underrated!!! He should at least be 78 or 79. And Any rookie rated over 75 is overrated(John Wall being the highest rated rookie should be 75 at most) Dwade should be about a 95 and not be rated same as Kobe and Lebron!!!

Your dreaming, if anything Lebron should be 95, and wade should be higher. They were WAY to generous to put Lebron on the same level as Kobe, and I don't like Kobe all that much...

[knicksfan1013]

gallo is most def a 77 easy he can shoot and defend. 72 is tooooo low

[DakkoN]

Re: NBA 2K11: Starting Five Roster Ratings

gallo is most def a 77 easy he can shoot and defend. 72 is tooooo low

We seen it the first time.

It's ridiculous to set a specific overall and change the other ratings until you get that overall. That's just ignorant.

[Phreezy P]

Re: NBA 2K11: Starting Five Roster Ratings

gallo at 72 thats crazy hes def atleast a 77

All he does is jack treys all day.

[Dachozen1]

Re: NBA 2K11: Starting Five Roster Ratings

So what are you saying?...lol just kidding

I think KD is just one notch under Melo.

But also understand not having a post game like Melo hurts his overall rating at the end of the day.

I feel ya, Melo's post game is beast, but KD led the entire league in scoring and was efficient doing it last season, not to mention is a better defender than Melo. So with that said, I don't have a problem with both of their overalls.

[Stickz24]

JaVale McGee might agree wih some of you re the ratings .. lol. Cute.
http://kotaku.com/5647586/seven+foot-man-unhappy-with-bad-rating-in-nba-2k11

[SenpaiRd-MVP]

Re: NBA 2K11: Starting Five Roster Ratings

some of my comments as a good basketball analyst.

Brandong Jennings 75? (78-79)
Watching the playoffs last season, jennings really stepped up his offense and stunned the hawks to force game 7. His quickness and passing is really stands out and he can really hurt you when he got his shooting touch. I think 75 is a bit low for a go to guy of bucks.

John Salmons 74? (79-80)
I think 74 is the rating, he should have when he is still with the bulls. When he got traded to the bucks, he improved a lot. He always good decisions when handling the ball, shoots with efficiency, plays kinda good defense, he is also good in drawing fouls and shoots the freethrows so good. he is also brilliant when he handles the ball down the clutch. 74 is just so low for him

Trevor Ariza 79? (75-76)
79 is too high for him, he plays good defense but is not too efficient in offense to be rated that high.

Jameer Nelson 75? (81-82)
Did the guys who made this roster watched how brilliant jameer nelson this season? especially in the playoffs. I really don't know why jameer is rated this low man, he shoots so well, he is quick and can beat you with his dribble, good passer, play good defense, great hustle. I think he is on the top 7 point guards in nba.

Vince Carter 81? (77-78)
Carter is not the same carter we know, his jumping ability and quickness is gone and as i saw him now his defense declines.

Dirk Nowitzki 83? (85-86)
Dirk is an outstanding offensive player. He can shoot everywhere on the court even with defenders all over him. Also he plays average defense

Tim Duncan 90? (86-87)
Timmy is aging and doesn't have 100% of his great post footwork he had in the past. His efficieny in offense is declining but he still plays outstanding defense.

Kleiza 55??! (68-71)
Give some respect to kleiza please. 55 is just gruesome rating for him! In fiba, he played like a beast, he plays good defense and explosive offense. I know what you will say, fiba is different from nba. If i would be asked how should be his rating in fiba it would be 81-83 but fiba is totally different from nba. Atleast give him 68-71 for showing a great perfomance this summer.

Kevin Durant 91?(94-95)
Durant is the best offensive player in the nba today! better than kobe and lebron. He grabs rebound really well and play defense better and better. Watching fiba this summer, i clearly saw how quicker he was than the last season.

John Wall 81?(78)
why 81?


sorry bad english

[Real2KInsider]

Re: NBA 2K11: Starting Five Roster Ratings

John Wall's Official NBA 2K11 Ratings

http://thereal2kinsider.blogspot.com/2010/09/john-walls-official-nba-2k11-ratings.html

Find out why he's overrated here!

[Jukeman]

Re: NBA 2K11: Starting Five Roster Ratings

John Wall's Official NBA 2K11 Ratings

http://thereal2kinsider.blogspot.com/2010/09/john-walls-official-nba-2k11-ratings.html

Find out why he's overrated here!

Same goes for *Enter Every Player Name Here*

[OGKing]

Re: NBA 2K11: Starting Five Roster Ratings

Let's take a look at the lakers.

Fisher 69 - That's a great rating for him, he lost a step, and is only getting older. He's one of those guys you use for his 3 point shooting, and clutch free throw line shots.

Kobe 97 - Well, i think kobe deserves a 98 tbh, but 97 is a great way to put away the "who do you think is going to have a better rating? Kobe, bron, or wade discussion" So why not give them all 97's?

Artest 79 - Eh, i'm not feeling this rating. Artest really struggled this season, and yes, he's ron artest, former defensive player of the year. But if your a laker fan like me, we all hated artest, and we all loved artest. He deserves a 77.

Gasol 89 - That's a pretty good rating for the best PF in the league today, do he deserve a 90? Eh, i don't think so, 89 is high enough for me. That's a great rating.

Andrew Bynum 77 - Again. Decent rating. Bynum do not, i repeat, do not deserve a 80. He was injured majority of the season. BUT, when he's healthy, he's one of the best C's in the league.

Also, i'm wondering what's odom rating going to be? probably a 77-78. Oh yea, and steve blake is most likely going to be rated higher than fisher.

[Andy187]

Although I'm a Magic fan and you coud call it biased but Nelson 75, Lewis 76, Pietrus 72 and Howard 88? Really? Nelson is the one of the best point guards in the East with Rondo and Rose and in the NBA and he's 75? He should be up in the high 80s. Lewis should be the same as Vince Carter or even 82 and Pietrus should be 79 at the least. Dwight is the best defensive player in the leauge and he's 88? No he should be 90. And how the hell is Melo 93? His best attribute is attacking the rim and then what? These boys better fix up the ratings. They're damn inaccurate

[MeanMrMustard]

lol... come on 2K. Again with rating Dirk the same as guys like David Lee, and only 2 points higher than Caron Butler? Oh, and worse than Gerald Wallace and Stephen Jackson.

It seems what's lacking is any kind of separation between the upper-tier but *not-quite-LeBron* guys and the ones you think of as being good-not-great. Fandom dictates I have to harp on Dirk as my example, but there's a ton of potential HOF types that are getting lumped in with guys who aren't even a lock for the ASG every year. What gives?

[RubenDouglas]

Re: NBA 2K11: Starting Five Roster Ratings

2k should release what goes into an overall rating.. maybe a great midrange is valued less than offensive awareness, speed, quickness, or vertical.

Ie. Player one could be rated 4 points higher in overall rating simply because he has +5speed, and +5vertical, with everything else the same.

I can see why I avoided this thread for this long. Logic is thrown out when people start talking numbers

[MeanMrMustard]

Oh, and to the several people who have argued "as long as they play like they do in real life.. what's the difference?"

These ratings are part of the reason Franchise Mode trades are so jacked up, imo. Guys like Dirk and Paul Pierce are in the Would Not Be Traded Under Any Circumstances echelon of player, not lumped in with the SJax and Carlos Boozers of the world. They need to be rated accordingly, otherwise it's perfectly defensible for the CPU to swap Dirk (83 PF) for Josh Smith (83 PF). Hell, if anything, the AI might think it was a steal for the Mavs to land Smith, given that he's younger.