Here's the worst problem when playing online/OTP - Operation Sports Forums

Here's the worst problem when playing online/OTP

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • qroach
    Rookie
    • Jun 2003
    • 31

    #1

    Here's the worst problem when playing online/OTP

    I've played a heck of a lot of online versus games in NHL09 (933 games played), NHL10 (1800+ games played) and now NHL 11 (287 games played). I've gone from being a bad player to learning lots of techniques people use online. However something has been alluding me in this game for a while. Sometimes you play online and for some reason the game plays totally strange. You play someone and they take one or two penalties a game, they skate circles around your players without ever losing the puck, they steal the puck off you with ease, they seem faster than your players and worst of all can win 95% of face offs.

    Has anyone here ever played a online game like that where there was nothing you could do? feels like it was a different game right? I have, and it always seemed strange until now. It always seemed like the opponent was playing with some hidden controls, or cheating in some way that you didn't think was possible. Well technically speaking they ARE!!!

    This is something I'd like EA to address quickly as it completely ruins the online game. It not only ruins it, but it's completely broken and unfair. It's probably also the reason we have people with over 4000 points online and 300 + wins with 11 or less losses.

    It's the nhl94 controls built into the game!!!! If you get good with them, you can totally dominate other players using the advanced controls. I tested this theory last night. if you switch to using the NHL94 controls a bunch of things become easier:

    1. I started winning 95% of face offs in a game. All you have to do is hit the A button to win every face off.

    2. Your players seem to skate faster ( ever play a game where your opponents players are on you before you can do anything with the puck?). Since there is no push puck or hustle. It also seems they get tired less quickly. For some reason they are harder to body check too.

    3. You can spam poke check and rarely get called for a penalty. On advanced controls doing this results in regular penalties being called.

    4. You can turn left or right incredibly fast without losing the puck. Doing this on advanced controls results in your player blowing a tire or you just losing the puck off your stick altogether (unless you have someone with a high dangle rating). regardless you can spin around down low in the attacking zone in a way that is idiotic, and if you're good at it, you become unstoppable.

    5. You don't really need to aim to shoot. So I'm assuming there is some sort of aiming assists happening with these controls.

    6. Your best offensive play is cross crease one timer. However if you get good with these controls the inside outside deke is even easier than normal.

    7. You hardly ever loose the puck!


    Basically using these controls makes the game play in a way that gives the player an unfair or distinct advantage, and a difficult one to overcome if you're not expecting it. The worse part is that you hardly take any penalties and can win nearly every face off easily. Winning face offs is the best way to control the flow of the game. if you almost always have the puck, and it's harder to get the puck off you, it's a huge advantage.

    I want EA to do something about this. At the very least if they can display what control scheme a player is using when you get matched up with someone, then you can choose if you want to play them or not. There's some players with really good records and it's not because they are good, they are exploiting an unfair advantage in face offs, speed, and holding onto the puck. It would be great if you do something about this and reset these players stats.

    This really needs to be fixed and I decided to blow the lid off this nonsense!
    Last edited by qroach; 10-25-2010, 10:50 PM.
  • football0021
    Rookie
    • Feb 2003
    • 66

    #2
    Re: Dear Redshirt: here's the worst problem when playing online/OTP

    Anyone else experience this? Sounds interesting. I have had these games sometimes, but I would have never guessed it something to do with the basic controls.

    Comment

    • Fiddy
      Twitch/YouTube: Fiddy14
      • Jul 2002
      • 12579

      #3
      Re: Dear Redshirt: here's the worst problem when playing online/OTP

      you know honestly, i have always wondered about this. a guy that plays a few club games here and there with us hates the default controls. i do believe he uses classic, not the 94 ones, he can shoot and pass with the buttons (as well as shoot with the right stick as well). when he uses the buttons to shoot, i swear to god its way to accurate.

      this wouldnt be shocking that something like this has issues.. add it to the list if true!!
      Twitch
      twitch.tv/Fiddy14
      YouTube
      http://www.youtube.com/@Fiddy14
      X
      https://x.com/Fiddy14_

      Favorite Teams
      Pittsburgh Penguins
      New York Mets
      Cleveland Cavaliers
      Cleveland Browns
      Notre Dame Fightin Irish
      Liverpool FC

      Comment

      • qroach
        Rookie
        • Jun 2003
        • 31

        #4
        Re: Dear Redshirt: here's the worst problem when playing online/OTP

        yeah it's true there's also some weirdness with both of those control schemes. Classic controls have an auto aim occurring I think. I'm also surprised so many people are viewing this topic but not posting in it. makes me think they are trying the theories out.

        Comment

        • bukktown
          MVP
          • Jan 2007
          • 3261

          #5
          Re: Dear Redshirt: here's the worst problem when playing online/OTP

          That makes sense. It was always something that I noticed but didn't think the user could control when it happened.

          Comment

          • NHLandPESFan
            Rookie
            • Dec 2008
            • 229

            #6
            Re: Dear Redshirt: here's the worst problem when playing online/OTP

            EA should fix and balance this in a way that people can still use the control scheme they would like. I personally despise the default scheme and stick to classic. It would be really nice if EA would let you customize the controls like games like Gran Turismo and Pro Evolution Soccer do. Until they fix it, seeing the other user's control scheme in the same place as GUESTS: appear would be a good thing to have in the meantime. I am grateful to see if there are guests as I refuse to play against any more than one person.

            Comment

            • CdnHockey
              Banned
              • Oct 2010
              • 7

              #7
              Re: Dear Redshirt: here's the worst problem when playing online/OTP

              Interesting find!

              Comment

              • bloemer
                Rookie
                • Jun 2010
                • 4

                #8
                Re: Here's the worst problem when playing online/OTP

                Originally posted by qroach
                I've played a heck of a lot of online versus games in NHL09 (933 games played), NHL10 (1800+ games played) and now NHL 11 (287 games played). I've gone from being a bad player to learning lots of techniques people use online. However something has been alluding me in this game for a while. Sometimes you play online and for some reason the game plays totally strange. You play someone and they take one or two penalties a game, they skate circles around your players without ever losing the puck, they steal the puck off you with ease, they seem faster than your players and worst of all can win 95% of face offs.

                Has anyone here ever played a online game like that where there was nothing you could do? feels like it was a different game right? I have, and it always seemed strange until now. It always seemed like the opponent was playing with some hidden controls, or cheating in some way that you didn't think was possible. Well technically speaking they ARE!!!

                This is something I'd like EA to address quickly as it completely ruins the online game. It not only ruins it, but it's completely broken and unfair. It's probably also the reason we have people with over 4000 points online and 300 + wins with 11 or less losses.

                It's the nhl94 controls built into the game!!!! If you get good with them, you can totally dominate other players using the advanced controls. I tested this theory last night. if you switch to using the NHL94 controls a bunch of things become easier:

                1. I started winning 95% of face offs in a game. All you have to do is hit the A button to win every face off.

                2. Your players seem to skate faster ( ever play a game where your opponents players are on you before you can do anything with the puck?). Since there is no push puck or hustle. It also seems they get tired less quickly. For some reason they are harder to body check too.

                3. You can spam poke check and rarely get called for a penalty. On advanced controls doing this results in regular penalties being called.

                4. You can turn left or right incredibly fast without losing the puck. Doing this on advanced controls results in your player blowing a tire or you just losing the puck off your stick altogether (unless you have someone with a high dangle rating). regardless you can spin around down low in the attacking zone in a way that is idiotic, and if you're good at it, you become unstoppable.

                5. You don't really need to aim to shoot. So I'm assuming there is some sort of aiming assists happening with these controls.

                6. Your best offensive play is cross crease one timer. However if you get good with these controls the inside outside deke is even easier than normal.

                7. You hardly ever loose the puck!


                Basically using these controls makes the game play in a way that gives the player an unfair or distinct advantage, and a difficult one to overcome if you're not expecting it. The worse part is that you hardly take any penalties and can win nearly every face off easily. Winning face offs is the best way to control the flow of the game. if you almost always have the puck, and it's harder to get the puck off you, it's a huge advantage.

                I want EA to do something about this. At the very least if they can display what control scheme a player is using when you get matched up with someone, then you can choose if you want to play them or not. There's some players with really good records and it's not because they are good, they are exploiting an unfair advantage in face offs, speed, and holding onto the puck. It would be great if you do something about this and reset these players stats.

                This really needs to be fixed and I decided to blow the lid off this nonsense!
                i had the same theory some days ago and wrote an email to ea about it. now i found your post here what gives me confirmation that i'm not the only one who thinks that way. till now no reply from ea. i think many top 50 players in the leader board are using these control's to take advantage in the points you mentioned because i experienced the same things you wrote about. last weekend i played someone who won 89% of the face offs (my normal face off rate is 50-60%), the complete game was very slow, and all my players moved like lame ducks - always one step behind my opponent but he moved very quickly and scored easily . but I think there is nothing you can do about it.

                Comment

                • xxjgbxx
                  Pro
                  • Apr 2008
                  • 697

                  #9
                  Re: Here's the worst problem when playing online/OTP

                  if its nhl 94 controls ill try it out now but i dont think their is a poke check with these controls

                  Comment

                  • xxjgbxx
                    Pro
                    • Apr 2008
                    • 697

                    #10
                    Re: Here's the worst problem when playing online/OTP

                    well you def seem more agile and seem to skate faster but you cant deke which SUCKS and hitting/poke check are the same button ill pass

                    Comment

                    • swil
                      Rookie
                      • Sep 2009
                      • 216

                      #11
                      Re: Here's the worst problem when playing online/OTP

                      this would certainly explain the many reports of how n00b players with absolutely zero hockey sense are able to regularly defeat seasoned veterans of the game.

                      Would love to hear a dev's thoughts on this

                      Comment

                      • bradigor
                        Rookie
                        • Sep 2009
                        • 82

                        #12
                        Re: Here's the worst problem when playing online/OTP

                        It makes sense, certainly explains some of the games I have had.

                        Comment

                        • football0021
                          Rookie
                          • Feb 2003
                          • 66

                          #13
                          Re: Here's the worst problem when playing online/OTP

                          Yea, I would love to hear a dev's thoughts as well.

                          Comment

                          • thedudedominick
                            MVP
                            • Mar 2009
                            • 3787

                            #14
                            Re: Here's the worst problem when playing online/OTP

                            Yeah this would explain how I can win 60-70% of my faceoffs overall, and have some games where I am lucky to win even 10% of them.

                            Has anyone themselves used these controls? And any feedback on the shooting and if it is indeed easier to score as well?
                            NHL: Vegas Golden Knights
                            NCAAF: Ohio State
                            NFL: Minnesota Vikings
                            MLB: Chicago Cubs

                            Comment

                            • Fiddy
                              Twitch/YouTube: Fiddy14
                              • Jul 2002
                              • 12579

                              #15
                              Re: Here's the worst problem when playing online/OTP

                              just tested this in practice mode with a few of my team members. there is a def advantage with the 94 and even classic controls.

                              i was scoring topshelf without having to aim with a twoway forward, shot acc both at like 60.

                              terrible!!

                              add another thing to the list..
                              Twitch
                              twitch.tv/Fiddy14
                              YouTube
                              http://www.youtube.com/@Fiddy14
                              X
                              https://x.com/Fiddy14_

                              Favorite Teams
                              Pittsburgh Penguins
                              New York Mets
                              Cleveland Cavaliers
                              Cleveland Browns
                              Notre Dame Fightin Irish
                              Liverpool FC

                              Comment

                              Working...