The Official Rate My Trade Thread

[richyung62]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I am the Blazers:

Portland Sends:
Greg Oden
Rudy Fernandez
2nd Round 2011

Chicago sends:
Luol Deng
Taj Gibson
1st Round Pick 2011

ripped them off completely, IRL this wouldnt happen, Oden cant stay healthy & the Bulls were only willing to give up a 1st rounder for Fernandez. Taj Gibson has way more upside than Oden.

[parker987]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Knicks (Me) receive:
Demar Derozan
Ed Davis

Raptors receive:
Landry Fields
Toney Douglas
Danilo Galinari

[richyung62]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Knicks (Me) receive:
Demar Derozan
Ed Davis

Raptors receive:
Landry Fields
Toney Douglas
Danilo Galinari

pretty fair IMO.

[ewing6]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I just started a Wise Chise(dynasty rosters V 2) Im trying to trade Gilbert, I want to be fair as possible so Im gonna find teams that need a scoring SG, post the most fair deals I can find and get your opionions of them

1. Wiz Trade:
Gilbert 4 years 80 mil 81 overall SG
Josh Howard 73 SF 1 year 3 mil SF

Jazz Trade:
A. Kirilenko SF 75 17.75 mil for 1 year
CJ Miles 66 SG 1 year 3.70 mil
maybe a 2nd

They get a big scorer at the SG to put next to Dwill, they lose AK 47 but get a capable sf starter in howard, then would have gilbert and bell at SG so Miles could go. I get a solid sf on a 1 year deal, cap space eos, and I get a young sg to use, then maybe a 2nd round pick. I don't think it's too bad.

2. Wiz trade:
Gilbert 4 years 80 mil 81 overall SG
A. Gee 1 year 473k 61 overall SF (roster spot evener)
H. armstrong 1 year 853k 61 overall C

Pacers Trade;
Mike Dunleavy 71 overall SG 1 year 10.56 mil
Paul George 65 overall sf 2 years 4.64 mil(D+ pot on this roster so its not like hes studly)
Jeff Foster 66 overall C 1 year 6.66 mil

They get a big time scoring SG to go with the Granger/Collison/Hibbert core. They can trade Mike since they would have Gilbert and Rush. They get a younger cheaper pretty much as good backup c. Gee is there to even up the roster spots. I get a SG and a backup center with expiring deals and a young SF stuck behind Granger and comp. Not as sure if this is fair.

Any thoughts? Raps had the contracts to matchup, but I don't think they want Gilbert at this time while rebuilding and the Knicks and Nets have the things also, but do I ruin there runs at Melo. Bulls were a fit, but didnt have the contracts to even it out, could bring a 3rd team into it to spar this perhaps. Any thoughts here, or anything Im missing

[J-Clutch1]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I just started a Wise Chise(dynasty rosters V 2) Im trying to trade Gilbert, I want to be fair as possible so Im gonna find teams that need a scoring SG, post the most fair deals I can find and get your opionions of them

1. Wiz Trade:
Gilbert 4 years 80 mil 81 overall SG
Josh Howard 73 SF 1 year 3 mil SF

Jazz Trade:
A. Kirilenko SF 75 17.75 mil for 1 year
CJ Miles 66 SG 1 year 3.70 mil
maybe a 2nd

They get a big scorer at the SG to put next to Dwill, they lose AK 47 but get a capable sf starter in howard, then would have gilbert and bell at SG so Miles could go. I get a solid sf on a 1 year deal, cap space eos, and I get a young sg to use, then maybe a 2nd round pick. I don't think it's too bad.

2. Wiz trade:
Gilbert 4 years 80 mil 81 overall SG
A. Gee 1 year 473k 61 overall SF (roster spot evener)
H. armstrong 1 year 853k 61 overall C

Pacers Trade;
Mike Dunleavy 71 overall SG 1 year 10.56 mil
Paul George 65 overall sf 2 years 4.64 mil(D+ pot on this roster so its not like hes studly)
Jeff Foster 66 overall C 1 year 6.66 mil

They get a big time scoring SG to go with the Granger/Collison/Hibbert core. They can trade Mike since they would have Gilbert and Rush. They get a younger cheaper pretty much as good backup c. Gee is there to even up the roster spots. I get a SG and a backup center with expiring deals and a young SF stuck behind Granger and comp. Not as sure if this is fair.

Any thoughts? Raps had the contracts to matchup, but I don't think they want Gilbert at this time while rebuilding and the Knicks and Nets have the things also, but do I ruin there runs at Melo. Bulls were a fit, but didnt have the contracts to even it out, could bring a 3rd team into it to spar this perhaps. Any thoughts here, or anything Im missing

Both are fine. I say do the first one.

[greenieblue]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Here is the only problem I see:

Gilbert's contract is so bad, it almost sinks a franchise single-handedly.

The Jazz deal isn't terrible. But imagining that Gilbert and Jerry could co-exist is hard to do.

What about dealing him to the Cavs for Antawn and Parker/Gibson?

That one kind of makes sense. Or to LAC for Baron & someone?

Or maybe throw in a 1?

You should probably try to bail out the team you are doing the deal with on some level-- take on really bad contracts, give them a couple 1's or a 1 and a 2, etc.

I would start by looking around the league for really bad contracts (high $, terrible players) that don't expire for 2-3 years.

Gilbert is toxic. A good player, but toxic.

[thaprodigyisback]

Needed a starting SF that could hit a open 3 when Jennings or DeRozan penetrate because Maggette can't shoot 3s so I struck a deal with the Suns.

Bucks (Me) Get:
Josh Childress
Mickael Pietris

Suns Get:
Corey Maggette
Ersan Ilyasova

My Roster
PG- Jennings averaging 27 PPG, Keyon Dooling, Boykins
SG-Demar Derozan, Michael Redd, Mickael Pietris
SF-Josh Childress, Mickael Pietris, Carlos Delfino
PF-Bargnani, Drew Gooden, Hassan Whiteside
C-Marcus Camby, Gooden, Hassan Whiteside

[J-Clutch1]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Here is the only problem I see:

Gilbert's contract is so bad, it almost sinks a franchise single-handedly.

The Jazz deal isn't terrible. But imagining that Gilbert and Jerry could co-exist is hard to do.

What about dealing him to the Cavs for Antawn and Parker/Gibson?

That one kind of makes sense. Or to LAC for Baron & someone?

Or maybe throw in a 1?

You should probably try to bail out the team you are doing the deal with on some level-- take on really bad contracts, give them a couple 1's or a 1 and a 2, etc.

I would start by looking around the league for really bad contracts (high $, terrible players) that don't expire for 2-3 years.

Gilbert is toxic. A good player, but toxic.

Toxic? As in what? Bad for team chemistry? This isn't the real NBA. And you very well know that Jerry Sloan will retire a year or two after in this game.

For the OP, if you're affected by this, just do the Pacers one.

[greenieblue]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Toxic? As in what? Bad for team chemistry? This isn't the real NBA. And you very well know that Jerry Sloan will retire a year or two after in this game.

For the OP, if you're affected by this, just do the Pacers one.

Well, you have him for the next four years at 20 mil, meaning he will be the highest paid player on your team for four years. The salary cap is 58 mil. He is 28 and declining. And a team can't win with him as the highest paid player.

That's pretty toxic.

[ewing6]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Pacers could have and granger come off at the same time for 30 mil! Summer of 2014!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[greenieblue]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Pacers could have and granger come off at the same time for 30 mil! Summer of 2014!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Maybe you're right. I just know...

Spoiler Alert


with the living rosters, Paul George turns out to be a nice little player.

Look, I'm only one opinion (GM). I just wouldn't acquire GA unless he got me salary cap relief a year early. I don't think he is a bad player, but his skills/age/contract are a bad combination.

[ewing6]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Any more thoguhts here, I'm playing my first game since I couldn't think of anything else LOL

[lambo_maggot]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Hey guys ths is my first post so anyway tomorrows christmas and im getting 2k and im gonna be playing wit the thunder in association is there anyway to get john wall without giving up kd or westbrook dont really care about jeff green or draft picks

[THE POLISH HAMMER]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Hey guys ths is my first post so anyway tomorrows christmas and im getting 2k and im gonna be playing wit the thunder in association is there anyway to get john wall without giving up kd or westbrook dont really care about jeff green or draft picks

That seems pretty pointless. Wall and Westbrook are the same style player, both attackers who dish the ball to teammates. Neither have great outside shots. If you really want Wall that much, you might as well give up Westbrook and get Wall & McGee or something. If one of 'em was a good shooter, I'd say try to get both and play one a little at SG (Orlando w/ Jameer/Arenas, for instance), but that's not really an option.

Yeah, I get it tomorrow, too. Gonna play w/ Orlando and just try to get a backup C (thinking about delving into the D-League or trying to package Duhon & Q for a decent big).

[mjh91]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I'm the Bucks and traded Michael Redd to the Hornets for Peja Stojakovic. Both have one year left on contracts, with Redd making $3M more than Peja - basically a change of scenery type of deal. I've had Redd un-active all season because my team plays well without him. He was clearly showing frustration with no playing time, so I found a team that needed a SG. Hornets have a solid starting five now. Probably won't give Peja critical minutes, but his outside shot will be nice to have come playoff time.