[youALREADYknow]

Quote: Originally Posted by khaliib

I could note my feelings about this area also, as many have done. Then, it hit me that I could use this issue to add some replay value to the game. For QB's I would call it the Tebow factor. Meaning a great college QB with all the attributes that fit the college game, but a major "Challenge" to transfer such Collegiate talent to the Pro's. Again, we could go on about what it wrong with the game and what EA needs to do, but this situation does parallel to the issue GM/pro scout's face when so called collegiate experts (Kiper's/McShay's) hype college player's up. I'm actually having fun doing this.

Exactly, it's quite fun with a little creativity.

I've actually completely abandoned the use of Madden's "Scouting" and created a custom scouting "big board" using Excel and a little bit of manual data entry once the class is imported into Madden. Then I use the big board in a 32 team franchise to draft for each team. Some teams get booms, some get busts, the 3-4 DE and OLB prospects go to the right teams, etc.