[LiquorLogic]

Quote: Originally Posted by rgiles36

Good thread... I'm for longer animations myself. If it presents the game better visually as it has proven in 2Ks games, I'm all for it. I see this still happens. People don't seem to want 2K5/2K8 compared to the most recent edition of Madden unless it's a favorable comparison. This is not a dig at you in particular Liq. I just think it goes both ways: if we can make a laundry list of things that APF simulates better, then it's also ok to mention some of the things that Madden today does better.

I hear you, but 2k5/2k8 were made ages ago in video game years. In my opinion, Madden 11 doing something better that games than were release 6 and 3 years ago, respectively, isn't really a dig at 2k football. At this point there shouldn't be anything that Madden doesn't do better than 2k did years ago. Madden 11 should have been at least two development cycles better than APF.

If Madden 12 is finally better than APF, which is the only way I'll purchase it, I'll be happy, but I'll still expect more. Then again, I've never experience a football game better than APF, game-play wise, so maybe I won't know the difference.